Well, now that we've seen the four cocks I expected to show up in this thread, here's my critique:
Me: quite average, which is good, because as a sexual adventurer, I like to have an everycock. It can easily adapt to any role I cast it in. Good shape.
CoreyLaz: Nice. If you hadn't told the size before, I'd have thought it was bigger, probably because it has a good, healthy thickness. Aesthetically, a porn cock.
New Me: Pretty good, though I can't properly judge the size soft. Looks decent though. Shares some of the everycock quality with my own. Better than mine at 100% soft, ya'll are lucky I didn't post that, it's the smallest thing you've ever seen.
Game: A fat one. Pretty bulbous and knobby, this is a formidable cock indeed. A warrior's cock.