Comparing 5 star matches is hard since ***** is the highest you can go and that means there are a lot of 5 star matches out there that are better than other 5 star matches. It's hard when all you have seen is American wrestling or if you have seen only limited puro. Some American stars that we see as best ever are pretty low on the list once compared to some puro stars and vice versa. I don't know if you can list based on how many 5 star matches they have had, but it is a good sign if they have had many.