1. Texas (13-0) - The Texas Longhorns are the undefeated, undisputed champions of the world. They went into Pasadena and they just outscored the defending national champion Trojans. A lot of people thought that the Longhorns' defense woud have to make the difference for Texas to win, but they just went score for score with the champs. In the end, Vince Young just ran too fast and threw too well for Leinart, Bush, and Co. to keep up. Tremendous win to cap a tremendous season for Texas.
2. USC (12-1) - No way that the Trojans can possibly fall further than this. They were one or two coaching decisions away from being crowned "best team in the history of college football" by the national media. If they give Bush the ball on the last third down, or run play action on fourth down, or maybe if Bush runs upfield instead of going to the sideline with 0:08 to go, we might be looking at a three-time champion right now. As it is, the Trojans will have to settle into their place in history alongside the 2002 Miami squad, as a great team that just didn't quite get it done when it mattered most.
3. Ohio State (10-2) - Yes, they lost to Penn State with the conference title on the line, but that doesn't mean they're not the third best team in the country. They lost to Penn State because they were on the road, the same reason Penn State lost to Michigan. The loss to Texas is also a non-issue, as there's no one in the country that could stop this Longhorn team. After watching the Buckeyes pick apart Notre Dame while Penn State struggled with FSU, deep down I just know that Ohio State's the better team at the end of the year.
4. Penn State (11-1) - Now, despite the the slight of dropping them a spot at the end of the year, I'm not trying to take anything away from Penn State's run this year. It was incredible. A Nittany Lion team that was supposed to do nothing at all blew through their schedule, and were 0:02 against Michigan away from going 12-0. The fact is that Penn State passed every test this year, and accomplished more than they could possibly be expected to. Great year for JoePa's crew.
5. West Virginia (11-1) - The Mountaineers were disrespected all year, but they came up huge when it mattered most. They came back from a big 4th quarter deficit to beat Louisville with the Big East on the line, and then they ran all over an elite Georgia team. West Virginia not only won respect for their program with that win, but may have saved their entire conference from being relegated to the ranks of mid-majors. When your looking at what a team's accomplished in a year, winning the Big East, and then winning the Sugar Bowl has to be right up there near the top.
6. Notre Dame (9-3) - This may look a little high after watching what the Buckeyes did to ND in the Fiesta Bowl, and seeing USC's aura of invincibility get crushed in the Rose Bowl. However, every upper echelon team has two goals for the regular season. Get to a BCS bowl, and win the national title. If they can't do the second, then the first is the most they can hope to get out of the regular season. Notre Dame got the job done there, going through a very tough schedule to end up with nine wins, and they were still one close call away from a Fiesta Bowl victory. The fact of the matter is, there are only two teams that in the nation that could beat OSU at a neutral site, and they were deciding something a little more important on Jan. 4.
7. Georgia (10-3) - Okay, so the Bulldogs didn't look very good in the Sugar Bowl, getting embarrassed in their home state. However, if they hadn't solidly beaten LSU with the conference on the line, they never would have gotten that opportunity. If I'm Mark Richt, I take a Sugar Bowl loss over a Peach Bowl win every day. Also, it's not like WVU was that much more talented than Georgia; the Dawgs just overlooked their opponents and came out a little flat. The BCS bowls are a showcase, and earning the right to play in that showcase is more crucial than coming out a little rusty when you get there.
8. LSU (11-2) - LSU may not have accomplished everything they wanted to this year, but that doesn't mean that they don't have scary talent. The Tigers absolutely destroyed a highly ranked Miami team in the Peach Bowl, and have every reason to look forward to next year. Not only does Matt Flynn look as if he might take JaMarcus Russell's job next year, he looks like he could lead LSU to the Fiesta Bowl. Great finish to the season for the Tigers.
9. Virginia Tech (11-2) - The Hokies may have lost their undefeated season against Miami, and their conference crown against Florida State, but they were still the best team in the ACC, as they blew through most of the competition en route to a 7-2 conference record. If that's not enough, they also have a road win over Sugar Bowl champ West Virginia, and a Gator Bowl win over Louisville to keep them warm through the off-season. The Hokies still have an elite program, and definitely have the kind of talent that you wouldn't want to face in a playoff.
10. Alabama (10-2) - The final rankings are about what a team accomplished throughout the entire season. Well for half of the season, Alabama was the third best team in college football. Their defense was the best in the country, and their offense was still relatively explosive behind Brodie Croyle and Tyrone Prothro. Unfortunately, Prothro went down for the season, and with him Alabama's SEC title hopes went downhill as well. However, that defense was still more than enough to completely shut down an explosive Texas Tech team holding them to just 10 points in a Cotton Bowl victory. Definitely a Top 10 year for the Tide.
11. Wisconsin (10-3) - Wisconsin played a very tough schedule this year, and still managed to send off Barry Alvarez with a ten win season. The Badgers picked up huge regular season wins over Michigan and Minnesota, and then finished off the season with a dominating victory over the Auburn Tigers. The Badgers were a couple wins short of elite status this year, but their Capital One Bowl victory shows that they are still a very good football program.
12. Auburn (9-3) - The Tigers both started and ended the season with disappointing losses (to Ga. Tech and Wisconsin respectively). However, in between those games the Tigers played some of the best football in the country. They beat the SEC Champion Bulldogs with DJ Shockley in the lineup, and then followed that up with a win over Alabama as well. Take out a missed FG against LSU and Auburn might have been playing in the Sugar Bowl. While not consistent enough to crack the Top Ten, the Auburn Tigers definitely showed flashes of brilliance during a very good 2005 season.
13. Florida (9-3) - Expectations were sky-high for the Florida Gators coming off the hiring of Urban Meyer as head coach. It seemed that pretty much anything less than an SEC Title would be a disappointment for the mighty Gators this year. While they didn't quite reach that goal, they have plenty of reasons to be optimistic for the future. Their wins were as impressive as any team in the nation's as they defeated both SEC Champion Georgia and ACC Champion Florida State in the same year, the latter being by a huge margin. The Outback Bowl may not be where Gator Nation wanted to end up this year, but the win there is something that Meyer can build on, and the Florida program should be back to contending for national titles in the near future.
14. Florida State (8-5) - Consistency was a huge issue for the Seminoles this year, as they lost games to the likes of Virginia, NC State, and Clemson. Yet in really big games, Florida State's talent still shone through. Season opening clash with Miami to establish dominance in the ACC? Win. Battle with BC for the Atlantic title? Win. ACC Title game with Virginia Tech? Win. Sugar Bowl against #4 Penn State? One missed FG away from victory. The Seminoles got the job done in big games this year, and had about as good of a five-loss season as any team could possibly have.
15. Oregon (10-2) - A ten win season's a ten win season, even if the competition is somewhat mediocre. The loss to Oklahoma was disappointing and will cast some of the Ducks' accomplishments in a rather unflattering light. However, the Sooners were the worst possible matchup for Oregon and their weak front four. Against another mid-level opponent, the Ducks could have easily finished the year 11-1.
16. Miami (9-3) - The vaunted Miami defense that looked so dominant against the Hokies earlier in the year looked absolutely lost in a 40-3 Peach Bowl loss to LSU. If you don't think the bowl game mattered or if you don't think this year was really a failure for Miami, just ask Larry Coker. The man fired nearly his entire staff after the loss, as the Canes were absolutely embarrassed. The Canes still have the building blocks for a big year, but until they can come up with a big win without the stigma of being an underdog, they will not return to their previous level of prominence.
17. UCLA (10-2) - UCLA also had a ten-win season in 2005, defeating Oklahoma and Cal along the way, before finishing up with a Sun Bowl victory over Northwestern. While they played very well for the balance of the year, the black marks on their season were so black that they can't be ignored. When most of your wins come by 3 or 4 points, and your losses come by 45 and 48, you just have to say that the team overachieved and leave it at that. UCLA did all they could with their talent, but against a tougher schedule, they might have been exposed much further.
18. TCU (11-1) - The Horned Frogs accomplished about as much as they possibly could this year. They beat Oklahoma in the opener, went undefeated through MWC play, and then beat a very good Iowa State team in the Houston Bowl. They were a letdown game against SMU away from being undefeated, and finished with a much better year than most of the BCS teams they're not supposed to compete with. When wondering why TCU isn't higher however, remember this. The worst bad loss for the other "top" programs doesn't approach the quality of the SMU loss. If TCU faced the kind of opposition week in and weak out where a "letdown" game was NC State or even Stanford, their results might not have been as good.
19. Oklahoma (8-4) - After a start that looked like it could lead to the most disappointing season in recent Sooner history, Oklahoma rebounded nicely, and ended up one bad call away from finishing the season on a seven game winning streak. The wins at Kansas and Nebraska look much better in hindsight, and the Holiday Bowl victory over Oregon was a great capper to the season. With Vince Young likely going to the NFL, Oklahoma may be the favorite to pick up another Big XII title in 2006.
20. Boston College (9-3) - The Eagles didn't have a big year, but they steadily and consistently pounded out a solid season. Coming from a very down Big East, there was a question if BC would be able to compete with the traditional ACC powers. They answered that question with a resounding yes, finishing one loss away from qualifying for the ACC title game, and then defeating a game Boise State team in the MPC Computers Bowl.
21. Michigan (7-5) - The faithful followers of the Maize and Blue won't want any positive spin on the school's first five loss season since 1984. However, there are many positives to look at here. The Wolverines defeated #4 Penn State, and were one of the most feared teams in the Big Ten when Mike Hart was healthy. They have many of the pieces coming back next year, and have more than enough talent to reach the Rose Bowl. Given all the things that went wrong this year from injuries to officiating, it seems likely that this will be remembered as one bad fluke season, not the start of a steady decline.
22. Texas Tech (9-3) - The Red Raiders didn't play the toughest schedule this year, but they did have a very successful season by and large. They finally established themselves as one of the top programs in the Big XII, finishing second in a conference that wasn't anywhere near as bad as it appeared early in the year. Mike Leach's program is slowly moving forward, and may challenge the Texas's and Oklahoma's of the world for the conference crown some time in the near future.
23. Clemson (8-4) - The Clemson Tigers finish 2005 on a roll, winning their last three games against Florida State, South Carolina, and Colorado. An upset, a rivalry win, and a bowl win, should be enough to keep the alumni happy, and the football program will have plenty of momentum and confidence going into 2006.
24. Nebraska (8-4) - The Huskers redeemed a disappointing season in the Big XII with a huge Alamo Bowl victory over classic power Michigan. Perhaps most importantly, this will buy Bill Callahan some time with Lincoln fans to allow him to rebuild the program. When you're changing 100 years of history, turning a Wishbone offense into a spread passing game, you're not going to be conference champions overnight. However, the Huskers definitely look to be on the right track for the future.
25. Louisville (9-3) - The Cardinals had all the talent in the world, but just couldn't come through in big games this year. They blew 14 point leads not once, but twice in the fourth quarter. You could see all the pieces for an undefeated run this year, but when Rutgers is the only bowl team you beat all season, it's hard to be overly effusive with the praise.