Since I am shot from working my ass off these past two days, I am staying home tonight. But to make sure I am an extra geek, I'm going to grade every single Buffy episode and grade the monster from that episode too.
Remember, I might be off about a few of these episodes because how good they were/are is from old memories. I only saw some of these episodes once or twice and a long time ago at that. I'll average up each season and rank them below.
This is what each letter grade equals to number grades.
A+: 100
A: 95
A-: 92
B+: 88
B: 85
B-: 82
C+: 78
C: 75
C-: 72
D+: 68
D: 65
D-: 62
F: 55
Season 1
1. "Welcome to the Hellmouth" - Ep: A, Mon: A
2. "Harvest" - Ep: A, Mon: A
3. "The Witch" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
4. "Teacher's Pet" - Ep: C, Mon: D
5. "Never Kill a Boy on a First Date" - Ep: B-, Mon: B
6. "The Pack" - Ep: B-, Mon: C+
7. "Angel" - Ep: A, Mon: A
8. "I, Robot -- You Jane" - Ep: F, Mon: F
9. "The Puppet Show" - Ep: B-, Mon: B-
10. "Nightmares" - Ep: B+, Mon: B
11. "Out of Mind, Out of Sight" - Ep: B, Mon: B
12. "Prophecy Girl" - Ep: A, Mon: A
Season 1 Average Grade: B+ (84.8)
I changed a few grades from my orginal grading because I was being too generous with a few of the episodes. "I, Robot -- You Jane" gets an F because the whole idea is SO STUPID. A demon that is stuck in a book, gets scanned into the computer and stalks Willow? Huh? He leaves the computer and becomes a robot? I didn't know a demon who was from 1418 knew how to use a computer like that. He is one smart demon...No wonder Thomas A. Swyden hasn't wrote anything since 97 and Ashley Gable hasn't wrote anything since 2001.
Season 2
13. "When She Was Bad" - Ep: B, Mon: B-
14. "Some Assembly Required" - Ep: B-, Mon: B-
15. "School Hard" - Ep: B+, Mon: A
16. "Inca Mummy Girl" - Ep: C-, Mon: D
17. "Reptile Boy" - Ep: D, Mon: D-
18. "Halloween" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
19. "Lie to Me" - Ep: C+, Mon: B-
20. "The Dark Age" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
21. "What's My Line Pt 1" - Ep: A-, Mon: B+
22. "What's My Line Pt 2" - Ep: A, Mon: A
23. "Ted" - Ep: B-, Mon: B+
24. "Bad Eggs" - Ep: C, Mon: C-
25. "Surprise" - Ep: A, Mon: A
26. "Innocence" - Ep: A, Mon: A+
27. "Phases" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
28. "Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
29. "Passion" - Ep: A+, Mon: A+
30. "Killed by Death" - Ep: C+, Mon:C+
31. "I Only Have Eyes For You" - Ep: B, Mon: B
32. "Go Fish" - Ep: D+, Mon: D
33. "Becoming Pt 1" - Ep: A, Mon: A+
34. "Becoming Pt 2" - Ep: A, Mon: A+
Season 2 Average Episode Grade: B+ (85.3)
There were a lot of monster of the week episodes that held the season down. But the Angelus storyline was soooooo damn good, plus we had Spike and Dru. "Passion" gets a A+ because, well, it ruled and everyone agrees with that one.
Season 3
35. "Anne" - Ep: C+, Mon: C
36. "Dead Man's Party" - Ep: C, Mon: C
37. "Faith, Hope and Tricks" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
38. "Beauty and the Beasts" - Ep: B+, Mon: B
39. "Homecoming" - Ep: B, Mon: B
40. "Band Candy" - Ep: B, Mon: B+
41. "Revelations" - Ep: B, Mon: B
42. "Lover's Walk" - Ep: A, Mon: A
43. "The Wish" - Ep: A+, Mon: A+
44. "Amends" - Ep: A, Mon: A-
45. "Gingerbread" - Ep: C+, Mon: C
46. "Helpless" - Ep: C+, Mon: B-
47. "The Zeppo" - Ep: A, Mon: A-
48. "Bad Girls" - Ep: A-, Mon: A-
49. "Consequences" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
50. "Doppelgängland" - Ep: A, Mon: A
51. "Enemies" - Ep: A, Mon: A
52. "Earshot" - Ep: B-, Mon: B-
53. "Choices" - Ep: B+, Mon: B
54. "The Prom" - Ep: B-, Mon: C
55. "Graduation Day Pt 1" - Ep: A-, Mon: A
56. "Graduation Day Pt 2" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
Season 3 Average Episode Grade: B+ (87.6)
Wow, I thought this season would do better than it did. Even though "The Prom" had the infamous "Class Protector" speech, the episode itself was pretty weak, so that is why I gave it a B-. "Graduation Day Pt 2" only gets a B+ because the Mayor turning into a giant snake is just too damn corny.
Season 4
57. "The Freshman" - Ep: C+, Mon: C+
58. "Living Conditions" - Ep: C, Mon: C
59. "In the Harsh Light of Day" - Ep: B, Mon: B+
60. "Fear, Itself" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
61. "Beer Bad" - Ep: F, Mon: F
62. "Wild at Heart" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
63. "The Initiative" - Ep: A-, Mon: A-
64. "Pangs" - Ep: B-, Mon: C
65. "Something Blue" - Ep: B-, Mon: B+
66. "Hush" - Ep: A, Mon: A+
67. "Doomed" - Ep: B+, Mon: B
68. "A New Man" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
69. "The I In Team" - Ep: B, Mon: B
70. "Goodbye Iowa" - Ep: C+, Mon: C+
71. "This Year's Girl" - Ep: A-, Mon: A
72. "Who Are You?" - Ep: A-, Mon: A
73. "Superstar" - Ep: B-, Mon: B
74. "Where the Wild Things Are" - Ep: C+, Mon: C+
75. "New Moon Rising" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
76. "The Yoko Factor" - Ep: A-, Mon: A
77. "Primeval" - Ep: B+, Mon: A-
78. "Restless" - Ep: A, Mon: A+
Season 4 Average Episode Grade: B+ (84.8)
I am not a big fan of this season. "Hush" doesn't get an A+ because I have seen it SOOOO many times its grade gets lowered. Plus, it isn't as good as the other two A+ episodes so far: "Passion" and "The Wish." And I gave "Superstar" a B- because it never did anything for me. I am not a big fan of it, unlike most people who seem to like it a lot.
Season 5
79. "Buffy vs. Dracula" - Ep: B-, Mon: C+
80. "Real Me" - Ep: B-, Mon: B
81. "The Replacement" - Ep: B, Mon: B
82. "Out of My Mind" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
83. "No Place Like Home" - Ep: B+, Mon: B
84. "Family" - Ep: A-, Mon: B+
85. "Fool For Love" - Ep: A+, Mon: A+
86. "Shadow" - Ep: B, Mon: B-
87. "Listening to Fear" - Ep: B+, Mon: B-
88. "Into the Woods" - Ep: B, Mon: B
89. "Triangle" - Ep: A-, Mon: A
90. "Checkpoint" - Ep: A, Mon: A-
91. "Blood Ties" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
92. "Crush" - Ep: B+, Mon: A-
93. "I Was Made To Love You" - Ep: C+, Mon: C+
94. "The Body" - Ep: A, Mon: A+
95. "Forever" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
96. "Intervention" - Ep: A, Mon: A
97. "Tough Love" - Ep: A-, Mon: A
98. "Spiral" - Ep: A, Mon: A
99. "The Weight of the World" - Ep: B+, Mon: A
100. "The Gift" - Ep: A+, Mon: A+
Season 5 Average Episode Grade: A- (89.5)
Of course this season gets a A- because it rules. The only episode to in the C range was a "I was Made To Love You," and it wasn't even that bad. I gave "Dracula vs. Buffy" a B- even though most people don't like it for two reasons: a) I like it. b) It set up the most of the season's themes, blood being life. "The Body" didn't get an A+ because the vampire ending was out of place. And if you couldn't tell, this is my favorite season.
Season 6
101. "Bargaining Pt 1" - Ep: A, Mon: A
102. "Bargaining Pt 2" - Ep: A, Mon: A
103. "After Life" - Ep: C+, Mon: C
104. "Flooded" - Ep: B, Mon: B
105. "Life Serial" - Ep: B, Mon: B+
106. "All the Way" - Ep: C+, Mon: B-
107. "Once More, With Feeling" - Ep: A+, Mon: A
108. "Tabula Rasa" - Ep: A, Mon: A
109. "Smashed" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
110. "Wrecked" - Ep: A, Mon: A-
111. "Gone" - Ep: B-, Mon: B
112. "Doublemeat Palace" - Ep: F, Mon: F
113. "Dead Things" - Ep: B+, Mon: B
114. "Older and Far Away" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
115. "As You Were" - Ep: B-, Mon: B-
116. "Hell's Bells" - Ep: A-, Mon: B+
117. "Normal Again" - Ep: B, Mon: B
118. "Entropy" - Ep: B, Mon: B
119. "Seeing Red" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
120. "Villians" - Ep: A-, Mon: A
121. "Two To Go" - Ep: A, Mon: A
122. "Grave" - Ep: A, Mon: A
Season 6 Average Episode Grade: B+ (87.3)
This season gets tons of bad rap because it doesn't have a overall story arc like the past Buffy seasons. However, each episode is a stand alone which builds up to thw Willow turn (just like Angel Season 5). Plus it is a darker season, which I am a big fan of. Some people might think I gave "Bargaining Pt 1&2" a high grade, but I love those episodes. I am also a big fan of "Wrecked" since we get to see Willow like we have never seen her before.
Season 7
123. "Lessons" - Ep: C+, Mon: C+
124. "Beneath You" - Ep: B-, Mon: C+
125. "Same Time, Same Place" - Ep: B+, Mon: B+
126. "Help" - Ep: B+, Mon: B-
127. "Selfless" - Ep: C+, Mon: B-
128. "Him" - Ep: F, Mon: F
129. "Conversations With Dead People" - Ep: A+, Mon: A
130. "Sleeper" - Ep: B, Mon: B-
131. "Never Leave Me" - Ep: C+, Mon: B-
132. "Bring On the Night" - Ep: B-, Mon: B+
133. "Show Time" - Ep: B-, Mon: B+
134. "Potential" - Ep: B-, Mon: C+
135. "The Killer In Me" - Ep: C+, Mon: C
136. "First Date" - Ep: B, Mon: C+
137. "Get it Done" - Ep: B, Mon: B+
138. "Storyteller" - Ep: C, Mon: C
139. "Lies My Parents Told Me" - Ep: A-, Mon: B+
140. "Dirty Girls" - Ep: A-. Mon: A
141. "Empty Places" - Ep: B-, Mon: B+
142. "Touched" - Ep: C, Mon: B+
143. "End of Days" - Ep: B+, Mon: A-
144. "Chosen" - Ep: A, Mon: A
Season 7 Average Episode Grade: B- (82.9)
This season gets canned all the time because of the continuty of it. I used to defend it at first, but now that I think about it more and not be so damn stubborn, there are some problems. However, that is another discussion. I gave "Selfless" a C+ for two reasons: a) It didn't do anything for me. b) They said that Anya was always stupid, but we were always told that she is stupid because she was a demon for so long. "Him" got an F because I hate it and it is the worst episode ever. And "Storyteller" got a C because I don't like the episode. I thought it was silly and I am not a big fan of Andrew.
Top seasons according to AEG.
1. Season 5, A- (89.5)
2. Season 3, B+ (87.6)
3. Season 6, B+ (87.3)
4. Season 2, B+ (85.3)
5. Season 4, B+ (84.8) T
6. Season 1, B+ (84.8) T
7. Season 7, B- (82.9)
There were only 6 A+ episodes. (Probably most of you agree with those too)
1. "Passion" - Season 2
2. "The Wish" - Season 3
3. "Fool for Love" - Season 5
4. "The Gift" - Season 5
5. "Once More, With Feeling" - Season 6
6. "Conversations With Dead People" - Season 7
I could have messed up with the math, so if you want to check it knock yourself out. Plus I think I was too generous with a few episodes, but most of it is from memory and I just did 132 episodes in a row.
I can't believe I just did all of that, I am such a geek and I love it!