SK clears it up: Stephanie's "heat" with Nidia.

[Guest AndrewTS]

By the way, the reasoning for the Noble/Nidia depush? Stephanie felt that Nidia looked too fat in a bikini contest, and thus not worthy of a further push until she lost weight. Let’s break that down again…STEPHANIE felt that NIDIA looked TOO FAT. You can’t make this stuff up, folks.

 

Credit:  Scott Keith's Smarkdown Rant.

 

Aye chee-wa-wa...

[Guest Anglesault]

Yeah, I saw that and at this point, it doesn't even really get to me anymore. It makes less and less sense by the day.

[Guest Kotzenjunge]

Stephanie isn't fat either, so I don't know what kind of point he was trying to make. Stephanie looks like a normal female as far as girth goes.

[Guest edotherocket]

I am amazed at how the McMahons can top themselves on an almost daily basis for this kind of stupid shit.

[Guest Ram]

Stephanie isn't fat either, so I don't know what kind of point he was trying to make. Stephanie looks like a normal female as far as girth goes.

Not anymore. She looks life a heffer from the side.

 

Definitely overweight.

[Guest AndrewTS]

Well, even though Kotz as we know has the hots for Steph, I don't see how he can deny she's gained weight and also that she's obviously chunkier than Nidia.

[Guest Kotzenjunge]

Oh, she's gained weight for sure, but she's still well within acceptable boundaries.

 

Speaking of Nidia, she sounded awful last night on the TE finale. She sounded as if she was trying to be in character, but not, all while trying to blend a New York accent with a hick accent.

[Guest dreamer420]

I don't believe that rumor for two reasons. First off, it's Scott Keith that's reporting it and all he seems to care about anymore is reviewing DVD's and hardly watching the wrestling he commentating on. Secondly, Stephanie has obviously gained a few pounds in the past few months (I'd still stick it in here) so she wouldn't be dumb enough to depush Nidia for being overweight. If anything Nidia has lost weight and gotten into better shape since being in the WWE.

[Guest AndrewTS]

Yeah, because we know that Steph is not only intelligent, but that McMahons NEVER EVER do anything hypocritical. Nope, nope, never.

[Guest NoSelfWorth]

I've heard something similar from Meltzer, that Stephanie, for whatever reason, doesn't like Nidia, so is stopping her push.

[Guest Just call me Dan]

What push????

[Guest mach7]

I am amazed at how the McMahons can top themselves on an almost daily basis for this kind of stupid shit.

I am amazed at how some of you people accept Idiot Scott Keith's word as gospel.

[Guest Kotzenjunge]

As Dreamer said, SK simply reviews DVDs and talks about random shit in his writing because he thinks that we give two flying fucks about what he thinks outside of wrestling match ratings. I honestly don't read him anymore except to see what he rated matches or what he thought of a big angle, and more often than not he hates it anyway. How'd he get big in the first place?

[Guest Mole]

Howd he get big Kotzen? It's called being a good writer.

[Guest SP-1]

Stephanie isn't really fat. She's a little meaty but I doubt she's actually overweight. She seems to be within the boundaries of acceptability for her height and all.

[Guest Kotzenjunge]

A pox on that good writing. It's a shame a lot of recappers on the internet took up his style, because it isn't all that great.

[Guest Brian]

Meltzer reported it last week. Well, he didn't actually give the reason but it's costing Knoble.

[Guest imajackoff?]

I cant believe Im defending Stephie baby on something, but she is a part of management. She isnt held to the same criteria that Nidia and the rest of the female staff is. It's sort of like Andy Reid cutting someone from the Eagles because they are out of shape. That's his job.

[Guest Youth N Asia]

I don't think she's as much fat as she just is a big healthy girl...much like Stephanie

[Guest HollywoodSpikeJenkins]

Howd he get big Kotzen? It's called being a good writer.

I some how doubt thats it....

 

 

 

 

and while I am here...

 

 

 

NIDIA ISN'T FAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

She doesnt throw up after eating her lunch (read: non-fat, no salt, 0 calorie salad.), like Stacy does, so managment quickly think, shes fat.

 

 

 

 

We are talking about the WWE here, so of course things aren't going to make sense.

[Guest Mik at Cornell]

Well just because Stacy is skinny doesn't mean she throws up her lunch, now does it? Some people are born that way and others are not. That's a nice, broad, stupid sweeping generalization to make...

[Guest buffybeast]

I cant believe Im defending Stephie baby on something, but she is a part of management. She isnt held to the same criteria that Nidia and the rest of the female staff is. It's sort of like Andy Reid cutting someone from the Eagles because they are out of shape. That's his job.

I must disagree with you. Stephanie gets paid for her role as Director of Television Creative Services or whatever and as a performer/talent. Therefore she should in theory be held by the same standards as the rest of the girls.

[Guest the pinjockey]

If Andy Reid went out on the field for plays than he should be held to the same standard as the players.

 

Stephanie, by getting on camera is essentially going out on the field for plays, so if fat=depush than she should not be on TV.

 

It is a useless point because the boss can do what they want, but it is hypocritical considering they should be held to the same standard.

[Guest CanadianChick]

Well just because Stacy is skinny doesn't mean she throws up her lunch, now does it? Some people are born that way and others are not. That's a nice, broad, stupid sweeping generalization to make...

Thank you! I'm sick of people just assuming that if you're thin, then you're anorexic. Hey, she might very well be, but don't just assume.

 

 

And Nidia isn't fat at all. Steph, while maybe has gained a few pounds, isn't fat either, but if she is calling Nidia fat, then she should look in the mirror because she isn't thin like Miss Keibler either.

[Guest TheZsaszHorsemen]

I think that the Kieth haters should just concede the point that he is a good writer. He may not be a backstage authority, but he is an entertaining re-capper and I enjoyed his book very much.

[Guest evenflowDDT]

Nidia... fat?

Scott Keith... accepted as fact?

 

Bizarre.

[Guest Kahran Ramsus]

Keith rarely makes up stuff. He just recycles stuff that Meltzer said a week earlier.

[Guest AndrewTS]

When Keith cites rumors, if he doesn't know of it being true or not he'll say so, like with the alleged HHH-Steph breakup.

[Guest Ace309]

Nidia is NOT fat.

 

At worst, she's slightly above the curve. *rimshot*

 

And I thought they deliberately made her look silly int he bikini contest... gee...

[Conspiracy_Victim 0]

I personally like SK's reviews, although he seems to have an imbalance toward Benoit and most other Canadian wrestlers (face it, Keith would give Benoit vs. a broomstick ***1/2) and against women's wrestling because it isn't just like Japan's wrestling.

 

Now about Steph. I agree that IF this is true, it's rediculous. Nidia looks good (although yes she sounded horrible at the TE3 finale) and looks like she is in better shape since TE1. OTOH, Steph seems to have gotten a bit..plumper. When she was the victim of the "Higher Power" angle, she looked thin and hot in the rich-girl-next-door way. Now, her body looks like it's compensating for her surgery that, as Jericho put it, "Let the boobies hit the floor!" Seriously it almost seems like her body is trying to support her *ahem* larger upper body. Just IMHO.