Guest Shaved Bear Report post Posted June 25, 2002 S&M and Binge and Purge were left off, just vote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Shaved Bear Report post Posted June 26, 2002 im predicting that load reload and garage get 0 votes Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest redbaron51 Report post Posted June 26, 2002 It was a tough decide between Master of Puppets and Load Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest cartman Report post Posted June 26, 2002 I also put in my vote for S&M whether u like it or not Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest areacode212 Report post Posted June 26, 2002 It was tough to choose "Puppets" over "Lightning", but I did. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Anubis Puppet Report post Posted June 26, 2002 Justice. For nostalgic purposes only. I listened to it a lot when I was ten. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Shaved Bear Report post Posted June 26, 2002 why is the black album winning Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Big McLargeHuge Report post Posted June 26, 2002 Why not? I voted for it. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Human Fly Report post Posted June 26, 2002 The Black album is a good album, but this is where Metallica started showing signs of going downhill. Bob Rock came in and basically turned Metallica into a made for radio band. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Shaved Bear Report post Posted June 26, 2002 because it has 5 good songs Sandman Sad But True Unforgiven Nothing Else Matters Wherever I may Roam the rest is kinda filler Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Big McLargeHuge Report post Posted June 26, 2002 It's all a matter of opinion. I like some songs off of Master (MoP, Sanitarium, Orion, etc...) but, like you said, the rest seems like filler. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Shaved Bear Report post Posted June 26, 2002 agreed, which is why i voted for ride the lightning, which is 8 songs of kick-ass Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest mesepher Report post Posted June 26, 2002 I'm surprised no one else has voted for the rawest Tallica album... Kill Em All! my favorite of theirs, sadly, when I listen to it... it depresses me to think of what Metallica could have been! I mean Master of Puppets and Ride the Lightning are both awesome... but Kill Em All rules. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest redbaron51 Report post Posted June 26, 2002 The Black album as other good songs on it too, like My Friend of Misery, The God that Failed, Holier than Thou...other than that...its decent Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest swan Report post Posted June 26, 2002 "Ride the Lightning" all the way. Really you should of left everything after "Justice.." off the list. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest swan Report post Posted June 26, 2002 Why didn't you list the "The 5.98 EP (9.98 CD) Garage Days Revisited"? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Shaved Bear Report post Posted June 26, 2002 Why didn't you list the "The 5.98 EP (9.98 CD) Garage Days Revisited"? eh one Garage Album is plenty Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest areacode212 Report post Posted June 26, 2002 I actually owned a copy of The $5.98 EP on cassette. Shortly after it got deleted, my copy got eated by my Walkman! Arrgh! I was so pissed because it was irreplaceable. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest swan Report post Posted June 26, 2002 Why didn't you list the "The 5.98 EP (9.98 CD) Garage Days Revisited"? eh one Garage Album is plenty Yeah but the first one is awesome. Might only have 5 or 6 songs on it but it kicked ass. Love "Crash Course In Brain Surgery". Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest endgame722 Report post Posted June 27, 2002 The first four albums are all great but if I had to choose one it would be Ride the Lightning Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Shaved Bear Report post Posted June 27, 2002 so my prediction stands, load reload and garage inc are allo pulling a donut Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Doomsault Report post Posted June 27, 2002 Kill 'Em All baby! Every song on it is awsome the only one I can't listen twice in a row without getting sick of it is Metal Malisha, but even that's good. The black album only gets a bad rap because it's when they started changing styles but everyone was too busy whining about that to actually grade it on it's actual quality. I like it. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest CoreyLazarus416 Report post Posted June 27, 2002 Or maybe people don't like The Black Album because it's simply their worst album? Think about it. The first 4 LPs are CLASSICS on the hard rock/metal scene. Hell, even hardcore elitist punkers own those albums, and nobody would make fun of them, because the albums were that good. Metallica made thrash metal, then made it popular, and were known for putting on a great live show and playing nothing but pure, straight-up, kick ass metal. They settled for nobody, tore down arenas, and drove their fans crazy with the raw energy of their shows. The songs were complex, but in a "simplistic" way of being complex. And then they released The Black Album. The Black Album is by far their most successful album in a mainstream sense, true. But the songs were written to strictly be catchy, the band got rid of their 4-5 riffs per song rule and replaced it with a 2-3 riffs per song rule. The lyrics and vocals are the only thing to improve, honestly. I'm a hardcore Metallica fan. Always have been, and I always will be, and I say The Black Album is their worst album from both a musical standpoint and a career standpoint. It began the transition from Kings Of Metal to Some Old Guys In A Rock Band. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Shaved Bear Report post Posted June 28, 2002 shit someone voted for garage inc!!!! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Doomsault Report post Posted June 28, 2002 Or maybe people don't like The Black Album because it's simply their worst album? Think about it. The first 4 LPs are CLASSICS on the hard rock/metal scene. Hell, even hardcore elitist punkers own those albums, and nobody would make fun of them, because the albums were that good. Metallica made thrash metal, then made it popular, and were known for putting on a great live show and playing nothing but pure, straight-up, kick ass metal. They settled for nobody, tore down arenas, and drove their fans crazy with the raw energy of their shows. The songs were complex, but in a "simplistic" way of being complex. And then they released The Black Album. The Black Album is by far their most successful album in a mainstream sense, true. But the songs were written to strictly be catchy, the band got rid of their 4-5 riffs per song rule and replaced it with a 2-3 riffs per song rule. The lyrics and vocals are the only thing to improve, honestly. I'm a hardcore Metallica fan. Always have been, and I always will be, and I say The Black Album is their worst album from both a musical standpoint and a career standpoint. It began the transition from Kings Of Metal to Some Old Guys In A Rock Band. Well, I liked it. *sniff* Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest undisputedjericho Report post Posted June 28, 2002 I voted Master of Puppets though its really more like a tie with Ride the Lightning. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest cartman Report post Posted June 28, 2002 Or maybe people don't like The Black Album because it's simply their worst album? Think about it. The first 4 LPs are CLASSICS on the hard rock/metal scene. Hell, even hardcore elitist punkers own those albums, and nobody would make fun of them, because the albums were that good. Metallica made thrash metal, then made it popular, and were known for putting on a great live show and playing nothing but pure, straight-up, kick ass metal. They settled for nobody, tore down arenas, and drove their fans crazy with the raw energy of their shows. The songs were complex, but in a "simplistic" way of being complex. And then they released The Black Album. The Black Album is by far their most successful album in a mainstream sense, true. But the songs were written to strictly be catchy, the band got rid of their 4-5 riffs per song rule and replaced it with a 2-3 riffs per song rule. The lyrics and vocals are the only thing to improve, honestly. I'm a hardcore Metallica fan. Always have been, and I always will be, and I say The Black Album is their worst album from both a musical standpoint and a career standpoint. It began the transition from Kings Of Metal to Some Old Guys In A Rock Band. ....Or maybe they did the right thing and GREW UP into something they all thought was better. They just HAPPENED to make a shitload of money and fame on it. NO band can make it big without making at least ONE quality...I mean true QUALITY song. Just because you people are so called "Metal purists" doesnt mean you are "musically knowledgeable" Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest MaxPower27 Report post Posted June 29, 2002 shit someone voted for garage inc!!!! I did, as a gag. HA HA HA I'm so funny. You guys were talking about the fact that that LOAD and RELOAD would pulla donut, and Garage Inc. was the least offensive out of all of them. Truth be told, I like almost all of their CD's, expect the Loads. Kill Em all was great metal, raw and loud. Ride the Lightning is one of my favorites, Trapped under ice is one of my favorite 'Tallica songs. Did anyone here like S&M? I thought some of it was a little awkward, but all in all, it was a good CD. My favorite: Master of Puppets Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Doomsault Report post Posted June 29, 2002 Or maybe people don't like The Black Album because it's simply their worst album? Think about it. The first 4 LPs are CLASSICS on the hard rock/metal scene. Hell, even hardcore elitist punkers own those albums, and nobody would make fun of them, because the albums were that good. Metallica made thrash metal, then made it popular, and were known for putting on a great live show and playing nothing but pure, straight-up, kick ass metal. They settled for nobody, tore down arenas, and drove their fans crazy with the raw energy of their shows. The songs were complex, but in a "simplistic" way of being complex. And then they released The Black Album. The Black Album is by far their most successful album in a mainstream sense, true. But the songs were written to strictly be catchy, the band got rid of their 4-5 riffs per song rule and replaced it with a 2-3 riffs per song rule. The lyrics and vocals are the only thing to improve, honestly. I'm a hardcore Metallica fan. Always have been, and I always will be, and I say The Black Album is their worst album from both a musical standpoint and a career standpoint. It began the transition from Kings Of Metal to Some Old Guys In A Rock Band. ....Or maybe they did the right thing and GREW UP into something they all thought was better. They just HAPPENED to make a shitload of money and fame on it. NO band can make it big without making at least ONE quality...I mean true QUALITY song. Just because you people are so called "Metal purists" doesnt mean you are "musically knowledgeable" Damn fuckin' straight! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest KoR Fungus Report post Posted June 29, 2002 I voted for Ride the Lightning, just barely beating out Master of Puppets. They're both great albums from begining to end, but Fade to Black is the best song on either album, so Ride wins. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
