Exactly. Basically, Jay & his friends' tape sites have been sinned against, and thus Jay is pissed (understandably), hence he wants a ban. But really, Tim did nothing wrong. He just did something really prickish and sneaky.
Edit: Well, Tim got banned now anyway, so I guess there's no sense in continuing this argument. So, I guess next time when someone brags about downloading some MP3s, someone will go and rat them out to the RIAA???