'God' was their idea, thus automatically making it a good one.
I can see at least one possible Sci-Fi storyline ECW can do, that won't seem stupid. They can have a babyface wrestler who is a big Sci-Fi fan. He'll get mocked by some heels for a while for being a geek, loser, etc, and the heels can say he's just like every Sci-Fi fan. The babyface can fight back, and, in the end, beat the heels and prove that Sci-Fi fans can kick ass too. It probably won't satisfy the people who are pressing for a Sci-Fi orientated storyline, but I think it's a good compromise.
"Enterprise" Shane Helms, tonight in this very ring...you're facing...
KHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAN~!
Exactly who I thought of, if you have a nerdy gimmick Shane Helms will take it on.