I read the first and agreed with the points at this point in video gaming the graphics are so good that being immersed in a game is more important than ever. Little things like not having to click signs and such go a long way, think of watching a movie, those moments where you go "That's bullshit!" detatch you from the movie and once that happens it's hard to get the viewer back.
I don't understand why they didnt just implement the nun-chuck controls on the Gamecube, at this stage in the game there's no excuse to lack in the graphics department. Good graphics add to gameplay when used right.
Oh and the second guy came off as a total tool, btw.