Which one of these WM would get higher buyrate?

[LooseCannon25 0]

Ok, i thought it would be interesting to make a topic and ask all of you which one of these WrestleMania cards would get more buys. Now keep in mind of all the marks out there and the big names.

 

Here is the mark's Wrestlemania dream card:

 

Goldberg vs. The Rock

HHH vs. Stone Cold vs. Scott Steiner [ World Heavyweight Title Match]

Kurt Angle vs. Brock Lesnar [WWE Title Match]

Shawn Michaels vs. Kevin NAsh

Hulk Hogan vs. Vince McMAhon

RVD/Kane vs. Storm/Regal [World Tag Title]

Chris Jericho vs. Booker T

Dudley Boyz vs. 3MW

Team Angle vs. Benoit/Edge [WWe Tag Title]

Billy Kidman vs. MAtt Hardy [Cruiserweight Title]

Trish vs. Victoria vs. Jazz [Womens Title]

Rey Mysterio vs. Eddie Guerrero

 

Now here's a card that i would personally drool over:

 

Brock vs. Angle [WWE Title]

HHH vs. Stone Cold [Heavyweight Title]

Vince McMahon vs. Hulk Hogan

The Rock vs. Chris Benoit

Chris JEricho vs. Shawn Michaels

Team Angle vs. Los Guerreros [WWE Tag Titles]

Booker T/Goldust vs. Batista/Orton

Storm/Regal vs. Dudley Boyz

JAzz vs. Victoria [Womens Title]

Kane vs. RVD

Undertaker vs. Rhyno

 

Ok, number 1 which card do you guys think is better...and number 2, which card gets the most buys?

[Guest Kotzenjunge]

I'd rather watch the first, and it would also get more buys.

 

(sees Benoit/Rock on the second one)

 

Nevermind, it's a draw.

[Guest Nevermortal]

I'm going like this:

 

Brock v. Angle (SD! Title)

HHH v. Booker T (Raw Title)

Chris Benoit v. Edge (Edge turns heel prior to WM XIX)

Rey Misterio Jr. v. Matt Hardy (LHW Title)

Shawn Michaels v. Chris Jericho

Austin v. The Rock (Rock Jumps Ship)

Team Angle v. Los Guerreros (SD! Tag Titles)

Regal/Storm v. The Dudley Boys

Trish v. Jazz v. Victoria (Women's Title)

RVD v. Kane (Kane turns heel)

Undertaker v. Rhyno (don't ask me why)

Hogan v. McMahon

 

A lot of matches, but I'm pretty sure that the 4 hour window can get them all in.

[Guest bob_barron]

I'll post my WM card again-

Brock v. Kurt

HHH v. Booker T

Rock v. RVD

Austin v. Benoit

HBK v. Y2J

Hogan v. McMahon

Edge/Rey v. Los Guerreros v. Team Angle

Rhyno v. Scott Steiner

KaneiDust v. Commonwealth Connection v. Dudleyz v. Evolution

Trish v. Jazz v. Victoria

Matt Hardy v. Shannon Moore

[Guest DawnBTVS]

Here are my estimated * ratings first

#1

Goldberg vs. The Rock **1/4-**1/2

HHH vs. Stone Cold vs. Scott Steiner [ World Heavyweight Title Match] **1/2

Kurt Angle vs. Brock Lesnar [WWE Title Match] ***1/2-***3/4

Shawn Michaels vs. Kevin Nash ****-****1/4(HBK will pull out everything and Nash will bust ass to make up for injuries)

Hulk Hogan vs. Vince McMahon **-**1/4

RVD/Kane vs. Storm/Regal [World Tag Title] **3/4-***

Chris Jericho vs. Booker T ***3/4-****

Dudley Boyz vs. 3MW *1/2-*3/4

Team Angle vs. Benoit/Edge [WWe Tag Title] ***1/2-***3/4

Billy Kidman vs. MAtt Hardy [Cruiserweight Title] ***1/4-***1/2

Trish vs. Victoria vs. Jazz [Womens Title] **1/2-**3/4

Rey Mysterio vs. Eddie Guerrero ***3/4-****

 

#2

 

Brock vs. Angle [WWE Title] ***1/2-***3/4

HHH vs. Stone Cold [Heavyweight Title] ***-***1/4

Vince McMahon vs. Hulk Hogan **-**1/4

The Rock vs. Chris Benoit ****1/4-****1/2

Chris JEricho vs. Shawn Michaels ****1/4-****1/2

Team Angle vs. Los Guerreros [WWE Tag Titles] ***3/4-****

Booker T/Goldust vs. Batista/Orton **-**1/4

Storm/Regal vs. Dudley Boyz **1/4-**1/2

JAzz vs. Victoria [Womens Title] **1/4-**1/2

Kane vs. RVD **1/2-**3/4

Undertaker vs. Rhyno **-**1/4

 

1st Card is better Overall. Granted the 2nd card has 2 possibly ****1/2 matches, the rest of the card is weaker. I also feel the 1st card can get easier buyrates.

[Guest the pinjockey]

I personally like Nevermortal's the most with at least 6 matches that should be a guaranteed *** under the most conservative guesses.

[Guest Angle-plex]

Brock v. Angle (SD! Title)

HHH v. Booker T (Raw Title)

Chris Benoit v. Edge (Edge turns heel prior to WM XIX)

Rey Misterio Jr. v. Matt Hardy (LHW Title)

Shawn Michaels v. Chris Jericho

Austin v. The Rock (Rock Jumps Ship)

Team Angle v. Los Guerreros (SD! Tag Titles)

Regal/Storm v. The Dudley Boys

Trish v. Jazz v. Victoria (Women's Title)

RVD v. Kane (Kane turns heel)

Undertaker v. Rhyno (don't ask me why)

Hogan v. McMahon

Have RVD turn heel instead (he needs a new direction, and I don't want to see Kane heel turn #2482374), and that's as good a card as Wrestlemania 19 could look like.

[Guest Showstoppa Icon]

Brock v. Angle (SD! Title)

HHH v. Booker T (Raw Title)

Chris Benoit v. Edge (Edge turns heel prior to WM XIX)

Rey Misterio Jr. v. Matt Hardy (LHW Title)

Shawn Michaels v. Chris Jericho

Austin v. The Rock (Rock Jumps Ship)

Team Angle v. Los Guerreros (SD! Tag Titles)

Regal/Storm v. The Dudley Boys

Trish v. Jazz v. Victoria (Women's Title)

RVD v. Kane (Kane turns heel)

Undertaker v. Rhyno (don't ask me why)

Hogan v. McMahon

Have RVD turn heel instead (he needs a new direction, and I don't want to see Kane heel turn #2482374), and that's as good a card as Wrestlemania 19 could look like.

i would agree that RVD does need a change. but he is so over w/ the marks (and the smarks) that it would be a bad move. And if he turns out not to be over as a heel its another reason for Vince to not elevate him.

[Guest El Satanico]

Both would draw well as most of the guys on the "smarks WM card" are over with the marks as well.

 

Other than Goldberg vs. whoever i don't see anything that would make the "mark's card" outdraw the "smarks card".

[LooseCannon25 0]

I would agree with truning RVD heel but i'd rather NOT see him against Kane.....how about against Booker T

[Guest CanadianChick]

I would agree with truning RVD heel but i'd rather NOT see him against Kane.....how about against Booker T

Who would you put over though? And would Trips face Austin?

[LooseCannon25 0]

hmmm............I guess if you wanna build up RVD as a heel you have him go over Kane or maybe even HBK and have JEricho vs. Booker T instead

[Guest Brian]

When I booked this first time through, I had this in mind:

 

Brock vs. Angle

Austin vs. HHH

Rock vs. Benoit

Jericho vs. HBK

Hogan vs. Vince

 

Basically with those five matches and good build, plus advertising it as Hogan's last PPV match, they could get a ton of buys.

[cawthon777 0]

Here is the mark's Wrestlemania dream card:

 

Goldberg vs. The Rock

HHH vs.  Stone Cold vs. Scott Steiner [ World Heavyweight Title Match]

Kurt Angle vs. Brock Lesnar [WWE Title Match]

Shawn Michaels vs. Kevin NAsh

Hulk Hogan vs. Vince McMAhon

RVD/Kane vs.  Storm/Regal [World Tag Title]

Chris Jericho vs. Booker T

Dudley Boyz vs. 3MW

Team Angle vs. Benoit/Edge  [WWe Tag Title]

Billy Kidman vs. MAtt Hardy [Cruiserweight Title]

Trish vs. Victoria vs. Jazz  [Womens Title]

Rey Mysterio vs. Eddie Guerrero

 

Now here's a card that i would personally drool over:

 

Brock vs. Angle  [WWE Title]

HHH vs. Stone Cold [Heavyweight Title]

Vince McMahon vs. Hulk Hogan

The Rock vs. Chris Benoit

Chris JEricho vs. Shawn Michaels

Team Angle vs.  Los Guerreros  [WWE Tag Titles]

Booker T/Goldust vs. Batista/Orton

Storm/Regal vs. Dudley Boyz

JAzz vs. Victoria  [Womens Title]

Kane vs. RVD

Undertaker vs. Rhyno

Gotta go with the second on both questions. Goldberg's been gone long enough that I don't know if bringing him back would do much in terms of buyrates. Maybe if there were a lot of die-hard Goldberg marks that might make the determining factor, I don't know.

 

I think if you take Goldberg off the first card the second is stronger without a doubt. Austin / HHH one-on-one. Hogan / McMahon is on both so that doesn't make a difference either way. Same with Brock / Angle. Jericho / Michaels can draw a lot better than Nash / Michaels - both on workrate and buyrate.

 

Undertaker / Rhyno, Rock / Benoit (with Benoit going over if there is a god), and Team Angle / Guerreros sway my vote.

[Guest BionicRedneck]

Shawn Michaels vs. Kevin Nash ****-****1/4(HBK will pull out everything and Nash will bust ass to make up for injuries)

[Guest Brian]

They couldn't even do that well when both guys were younger and healthier.

[Guest El Satanico]

ahaha...i missed that.

 

Nash in a 4 Star match only happens in Nash's dreams.