Jump to content
TSM Forums
Sign in to follow this  
Guest JAxlMorrison

My star ratings

Recommended Posts

Guest Anglesault

Vince McMahon vs. Zach Gowen--*.  Gowen is utterly exposed as the 2-move wonder that he is.  Totally bored with this match.  WAY too long.  Nice gusher though, Vince. 

 

EDIT: Once I posted I figured I'd be safe and add spoiler tags.  Is that right?  Do I need to?

I can't believe a one legged wrestler is being criticized for his moveset.

The novelty wore off after the first match.

 

We're left with an obnoxious as all hell character dominating a show that he's no where near over enough (And gettung less over-as a face, anyway-by the show)-to dominate with his drop kick and moonsault.

 

Doesn't work that way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest oxymoron

Chris Benoit Vs. Eddie Guerrero *** 3/4

Jamie Noble Vs. Billy Gunn **

APA Brawl *3/4

Benjamin/Haas Vs. Kidman/Mysterio *** 1/4

Sable Vs. Steph 1/4*

John Cena Vs. The Undertaker **3/4

Zack Gowen Vs. Vince 3/4*

Brock Lesnar Vs. Big Show Vs. Kurt Angle ***

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Coffey
Ultimo Dragon Vs. Kanyon *1/4

Chris Benoit Vs. Eddie Guerrero *** Once again the WWE curtain jerks with a title match. *sigh*

Jamie Noble Vs. Billy Gunn ** It was high energy but too much nonsense

APA stuff was mildly humorous. I marked for Brother Love & Doink. No star ratings for a non-match.

Benjamin/Haas Vs. Kidman/Mysterio **3/4 A lot better than I thought it would be.

Sable Vs. Steph 1/2* Not much of a catfight, but I don't think anyone expected it to be. I thought it may have been better than that however. A-Train. *blah*

John Cena Vs. The Undertaker **1/2 A lot better than expected.

Zack Gowen Vs. Vince * It was better than Sable/Steph just because of Vince's juicing. Damn, that was vicious. I hate fucking Zack and his sickening hobble.

Brock Lesnar Vs. Big Show Vs. Kurt Angle **1/4 I'm glad Angle won. Too many finisher spots for my liking. Brock sucks at blading. Big Show sucks at jumping.

 

Still, best PPV of the year. Better than Wrestlemania in my opinion. Better than Royal Rumble. Obviously better than Badd Blood. I give Angle/Benoit from RR ****, and nothing on this card reached that high, but that card was better overall. At least to me.

Not to be a jerk, and it IS your opinion but...WHAT THE FUCK?! All Your Match ratings were given almost *+ higher by everyone else, except for the Gunn/Noble match and Vince/Gowen.

I don't throw around 4 and 5 star ratings often...

 

Benoit/Angle @ RR was 4-star for comparison.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Dynamite Kido

Beniot/Eddie - *****

Gunn/Noble - **1/2 (surprisingly entertaining)

APA Fight - *** (how funny was this!)

Tag Titles - ***3/4

steph/sable - 1/4*

Vince/gowen - **

cena/ut - **3/4 (solid brawl)

WWE Title - ***1/2 (good spots and entertainment)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest slabinskia

benoit-eddy-****1/4

this was a great match and i would give another 1/4 without the rhyno finish.

 

gunn-knoble-**

ok match

 

barroom brawl-1/4*

i didnt like this at all

 

wgtt-rey/kidman-****

great tag match

 

sable-steph-1/2*

i didnt care about this to start with

 

taker-cena-***

this was very good i thought.id give more if cena went over.

 

vince-gowen-**

i don't see whats special about this match.1/2* is for vince's blade job.

 

angle-show-lesnar-***3/4

as good as a big show match will be.very good main event.

 

overall-great show.even better considering how bad the last 3 were.this proves once and for all smackdown is better than raw but we already knew that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest godthedog

Vince McMahon vs. Zach Gowen--*.  Gowen is utterly exposed as the 2-move wonder that he is.  Totally bored with this match.  WAY too long.  Nice gusher though, Vince. 

 

EDIT: Once I posted I figured I'd be safe and add spoiler tags.  Is that right?  Do I need to?

I can't believe a one legged wrestler is being criticized for his moveset.

Should we just accept that he's a mediocre wrestler then just because he's got 1 leg? Fuck that.

 

Vince spends the whole time working the leg, but when Zach makes the comeback he hops around on it like normal because he HAS to. I don't see any way to work around the leg.

 

Keep him in Cruiser spotfests if you must use him, but any match with psych involved is going to be a joke with him, because of his inability to sell the leg AND do his moves.

 

It's like RVD x 10.

he could make his comeback using only handspring moves, thus not having to use the leg. it would be the greatest comeback ever.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest BionicRedneck

The main even was no more than ***. It was your basic spotfest, and Angle and Show were both blown-up, and the finish stank.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Ronixis

Kid Peagus Vs Black Tiger II : *1/2 (Reason- Rhynos Interferance) should have been a ****3/4

Gunn Vs Jamie Noble: ** (BORING)

The Fithy Animals Vs Worlds Greatest Tag Team ****3/4 (The Smackdown Titles have gained in image and is now the best Titles in the Fedration, every body in this match went over)

Sable Vs Steph *** Better than it should have been- Steph is a Mediocre to OK Joshi wresler- This would have been ever a better rating if the Smackdown GM spot was up for grabs.

APA Inventainal **(Fun Factor)

Vince Vs Zack *1/2 (Vince cant carry a crusier but nice blade job)

3 Way Dance for Smackdown Brand World Title ****1/2 (Angle wins- Brock cant beat the Big Show and the Big Show has improved big time)

 

This PPV was better than Bad Blood. Smackdown is the Brand's better promotion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest AlwaysPissedOff

I don't get the 4-star+ ratings for the tag title match. Don't get me wrong, it was pretty fun and all, but man, they were blowing stuff all over the place.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Choken One
I don't get the 4-star+ ratings for the tag title match. Don't get me wrong, it was pretty fun and all, but man, they were blowing stuff all over the place.

I can only conjure up ONE missed spot...What were you watching?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest AlwaysPissedOff

One? Haas screwed up the West Coast Pop, Rey blew whatever he was trying on Benjamin when he got the hot tag. There's two off the top of my head.

 

I probably embleished a bit with "all over the place", but I still didn't think it was a 4 star match.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Retro Rob

Regardless of the rating, I would place the tag match in the Top 5 PPV matches of the year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest EMAXSAUN

Benoit v. Eddie Guerrero - ****1/4 - Would have better without Rhyno

 

Billy Gunn v. Jamie Noble - ** - Some of the spots were okay I guess.

 

Bar Room Brawl - DUD - Bad

 

Charlie Haas & Shelton Benjamin v. Rey Mysterio & Billy Kidman - ****1/2 - Match of the FN night

 

Sable v. Stephanie - *1/4 - This was okay for some fun I guess

 

Undertaker v. John Cena - ***3/4 - Great match, Cena should have won though

 

Vince McMahon v. Zach Gowen - *** - This was really good IMO.

 

Brock Lesnar v. Kurt Angle v. Big Show - ****1/4 - An amazing world title match with the right guy winning.

 

Overall this is the PPV of the year so far and completely kills Bad Blood

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×