1/26: Super Bowl Rankings, Sorta
5 p.m.
• Yesterday I was listening to Mark Madden’s local radio show, and he brought up this article on ESPN.com that ranked all 80 Super Bowl teams. Normally I don’t care for stupid lists/rankings like this, but for some reason I was intrigued. Below is ESPN’s rankings, followed by a comment about each team. The entire list and full commentary about each team can be found here.
80) 1979 LOS ANGELES RAMS
The Rams led the NFL in interceptions thrown in '79, with four different QBs contributing.
79) 2003 CAROLINA PANTHERS
The Panthers barely outscored their opponents during the regular season (seven of their 11 wins were by three points or less) despite a pretty easy schedule – only six games against .500-or-better teams.
78) 2000 NEW YORK GIANTS
The Giants were strong on D, especially against the run (allowing just 3.2 yards per carry) and did beat the Eagles three times, but won a weak conference and lacked star power (only two Pro Bowlers).
77) 1982 MIAMI DOLPHINS
The Dolphins were 19th in total yards, making them one of the worst offensive teams to reach the Super Bowl.
76) 1985 NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS
QB Tony Eason had more picks than TDs (17 to 11).
75) 1986 DENVER BRONCOS
How did they reach Super Bowl with such mediocre team statistical rankings? Oh yeah, they beat a Marty Schottenheimer-coached team in the AFC title game.
74) 1996 NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS
It certainly wasn't a great team and was helped when 9-7 Jacksonville knocked off 13-3 Denver in the divisional round.
73) 1993 BUFFALO BILLS
Despite a 12-4 record, this team had slipped substantially from previous years.
72) 1999 TENNESSEE TITANS
Despite its 13-3 record, there were some smoke and mirrors involved since the Titans barely outgained their opponents and didn't dominate any statistical category.
71) 1994 SAN DIEGO CHARGERS
This team takes its lumps because of the pummeling it took in the Super Bowl against one of the finest offenses ever assembled.
70) 1970 DALLAS COWBOYS
They went just 3-4 against teams .500 or better, including drubbings of 38-0 and 54-13.
69) 1988 CINCINNATI BENGALS
They allowed the second-most points of any playoff teams, and while three of Cincinnati's four losses were by seven or fewer points, the fourth was a 35-point defeat at Houston with home-field advantage and the playoffs still at stake.
68) 1995 PITTSBURGH STEELERS
Their leading rusher was Erric Pegram, and they lost three games by 13 or more points.
67) 1966 KANSAS CITY CHIEFS
Len Dawson compiled the second-best passer rating of his Hall of Fame career.
66) 1992 BUFFALO BILLS
The Bills had excellent rankings in the major categories, with the exception of 13th in yards allowed.
65) 1974 MINNESOTA VIKINGS
This team lost by more than four points only once, but laid an egg in the Super Bowl, compiling a mere 119 net yards and scoring only on a blocked punt recovered in the end zone.
64) 1987 DENVER BRONCOS
After allowing more than 30 points just once in 12 nonstrike games, Denver coughed up a combined 75 in the AFC Championship Game and the Super Bowl.
63) 1975 DALLAS COWBOYS
Staubach didn't have one of his better seasons statistically (16 picks), and the Cowboys had the worst record among NFC playoff participants.
62) 1981 CINCINNATI BENGALS
The Bengals held the NFL's highest-scoring team, the Chargers, to a single touchdown in the AFC Championship Game – the coldest contest in league history at minus-9 degrees with a wind chill of minus-59.
61) 1977 DENVER BRONCOS
Denver had neither a 500-yard rusher nor a 30-catch wide receiver, but still went 8-2 against opponents .500 or better.
60) 1973 MINNESOTA VIKINGS
The Vikings allowed the second-fewest points in the NFL, but ranked toward the middle of the pack in yards allowed.
59) 1972 WASHINGTON REDSKINS
The Redskins enjoyed solid performances from Billy Kilmer and Larry Brown, but their offense ranked just 11th in total yardage.
58) 1989 DENVER BRONCOS
Yes, this team was the victim of the largest blowout in Super Bowl history. Because of that drubbing, many fans forget that the Broncos allowed the fewest points in the league in '89.
57) 2002 OAKLAND RAIDERS: The Raiders faced a difficult schedule, going 9-4 against teams .500 or better. But they lost four straight at one point, and were woefully unprepared for Tampa Bay in the Super Bowl.
56) 1971 MIAMI DOLPHINS
Offensively, Bob Griese compiled the highest passer rating of his career, and Larry Csonka had the first of three consecutive 1,000-yard rushing seasons.
55) 1967 OAKLAND RAIDERS
The Raiders did nothing for the credibility of the upstart league by losing convincingly to a Packers team that was in decline and coming off the "Ice Bowl."
54) 1980 PHILADELPHIA EAGLES
Philadelphia loses style points for dropping three of its last four regular-season games and for going just 4-3 against teams with a record of at least .500.
53) 1976 MINNESOTA VIKINGS
The Vikings were just 2-2-1 against teams .500 or better in playing a weak schedule and the defense was 21st in average yards per rush.
52) 1991 BUFFALO BILLS
Amazingly, this Bills defense allowed the second-most yardage in the league.
51) 1970 BALTIMORE COLTS
The Colts had the second-easiest strength of schedule among postmerger Super Bowl teams, losing two of their three games against .500-plus teams -- by 20 and 17 points.
50) 2005 SEATTLE SEAHAWKS
What does it say about Seattle that it became the only team to outgain and commit fewer turnovers than its Super Bowl opponent and still lose?
49) 1968 NEW YORK JETS
The Jets had just the third-best record in the AFL that season. Namath completed fewer than 50 percent of his passes, throwing more interceptions than touchdowns.
48) 1967 GREEN BAY PACKERS
This team gets docked for ranking just ninth out of 16 NFL teams in points and yards gained.
47) 2001 NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS
The Patriots had poor rankings in offensive and defensive yardage (outgained overall).
46) 2004 PHILADELPHIA EAGLES
This team was near the top of the league in just one major statistical category, fewest points allowed, and it played just two teams in the regular season with records above .500.
45) 1969 MINNESOTA VIKINGS
Minnesota was just 10th out of 16 teams in yards but still led the NFL in scoring (yeah, those league-leading 30 interceptions helped).
44) 1998 ATLANTA FALCONS
Atlanta knocked out the highest-scoring team in NFL history in the NFC Championship Game. Its only two losses came against 12-4 teams.
43) 1990 BUFFALO BILLS
Despite possessing the ball for less than 20 minutes, the Bills narrowly lost as Scott Norwood's 47-yard field-goal attempt sailed wide right.
42) 1988 SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS
Although the Niners lost six games in Bill Walsh's final season, they went 6-3 against .500 or better teams and easily won their first two postseason games (34-9 and 28-3).
41) 2005 PITTSBURGH STEELERS
The Steelers hit their stride at the right time and won the Super Bowl as a wild card after winning their final four regular-season games to qualify for the playoffs.
40) 1980 OAKLAND RAIDERS
Ordinary statistically (they relied on a league-leading 35 interceptions, including 13 by Lester Hayes), the Raiders ramped things up in the postseason.
39) 1982 WASHINGTON REDSKINS
Despite allowing the fewest points in the NFL during a nine-game, strike-shortened regular season, Washington was a three-point underdog in the Super Bowl.
38) 1969 KANSAS CITY CHIEFS
The Chiefs didn't even win their division, getting swept by the Raiders and losing to the second-year Bengals. Their primary quarterback, Len Dawson, threw 13 interceptions and just nine touchdowns.
37) 1997 GREEN BAY PACKERS
The Packers went 7-1 against teams with a record of .500 or better. But the Pack had one weakness: stopping the run. Terrell Davis rushed for 157 yards and three TDs and Denver had the upset.
36) 1968 BALTIMORE COLTS
It allowed the fewest points in the NFL and ranked No. 2 in points scored. Its only loss came against Cleveland, a division champion.
35) 2002 TAMPA BAY BUCCANEERS
Defense, defense, defense. Tampa Bay's offensive rankings were even worse than those of the 2000 Ravens.
34) 1984 MIAMI DOLPHINS
Wide receivers Mark Clayton and Mark Duper each topped 70 receptions and 1,300 yards as the Dolphins scored more touchdowns than any team in NFL history (70).
33) 1990 NEW YORK GIANTS
How did the Giants win? They didn't make mistakes, committing just 14 turnovers -- the fewest since the NFL went to a 16-game schedule in 1978.
32) 2003 NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS
New England's stout defense made up for a pedestrian offense, as the Patriots allowed the fewest points in the league for the only time in franchise history.
31) 1974 PITTSBURGH STEELERS
Pittsburgh made up for its lack of a strong passing attack by pounding the ball effectively on the ground.
30) 1987 WASHINGTON REDSKINS
Washington entered the playoffs with a quarterback controversy and a defense ranked 18th in yards allowed. It had just the third-best record in the NFC, even with a soft schedule and a 3-0 mark in games involving replacement players.
29) 2000 BALTIMORE RAVENS
Statistically, this was the best defense in NFL history (the Ravens allowed 33 fewer points than the '85 Bears).
28) 1983 WASHINGTON REDSKINS
Something often overlooked regarding this team is its ordinary defense, which ranked 11th in points allowed and 12th in yards allowed and featured just one Pro Bowler (Dave Butz).
27) 1983 LOS ANGELES RAIDERS
The impressive Super Bowl win helps vault this team to No. 27 despite some shaky times during the regular season (the Raiders allowed more than 30 points five times).
26) 1995 DALLAS COWBOYS
This team equaled the 8-2 mark against teams .500 or better of the '93 Cowboys and had 10 players named to the Pro Bowl.
25) 1981 SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS
Despite the reputation of the 49ers' passing attack, with Joe Montana, Dwight Clark and Freddie Solomon, the team's defense was actually more impressive, ranking No. 2 in the NFL in points and yards allowed.
24) 1977 DALLAS COWBOYS
Dallas' defense wasn't as stout as it would be the following year, as it ranked eighth in points allowed, five spots lower than in '78.
23) 2001 ST. LOUIS RAMS
St. Louis ranked No. 1 in the NFL in points scored (despite committing the most turnovers in the league) and offensive yardage and third in the league in yards allowed – 21 spots ahead of the Pats.
22) 1966 GREEN BAY PACKERS
The '66 team was pretty mediocre on offense, ranking in the middle of the NFL pack in yards gained, and its leading rusher, Jim Taylor, averaged just 3.5 yards per carry.
21) 1973 MIAMI DOLPHINS
The '66 team was pretty mediocre on offense, ranking in the middle of the NFL pack in yards gained, and its leading rusher, Jim Taylor, averaged just 3.5 yards per carry.
20) 1997 DENVER BRONCOS
The balanced Broncos ranked No. 1 in the NFL in points and offensive yardage, and its defense allowed the fifth-fewest yards in the league.
19) 1978 DALLAS COWBOYS
The Cowboys ranked No. 1 in points scored and No. 3 in fewest points allowed, and they narrowly lost to one of the greatest teams in NFL history in the Super Bowl.
18) 1976 OAKLAND RAIDERS
A less-than-impressive 113-point scoring differential means the Raiders pulled out a lot of squeakers – they won five games by four points or less – and their biggest win was 49-16 over the 0-14 expansion Bucs.
17) 1993 DALLAS COWBOYS
All three of their postseason victories were by double figures, including wins over a young Brett Favre and the Steve Young-led Niners in the NFC title game.
16) 1979 PITTSBURGH STEELERS
The Steelers lose style points for 34-10 and 35-7 losses in the regular season and for letting a 9-7 opponent take the lead into the fourth quarter of the Super Bowl.
15) 1971 DALLAS COWBOYS
Roger Staubach compiled a career-best passer rating, and the Cowboys won their last seven regular-season games after Landry made Staubach the unquestioned starter over Craig Morton.
14) 1999 ST. LOUIS RAMS
The knock on this team was its easy schedule. It went 3-2 against teams .500 or better, and they played two close postseason games.
13) 1975 PITTSBURGH STEELERS
The Steelers held their opponents to 10 points or fewer 10 times in 17 total games.
12) 1998 DENVER BRONCOS
John Elway compiled the best passer rating of his career, and Terrell Davis became the only NFL player to rush for 2,000 yards and 20 touchdowns in the same season.
11) 1994 SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS
Over its final 13 games (including the playoffs), it scored more than 40 six times and less than 30 just twice, and one of those was the season finale – which the Niners lost – when Young and Jerry Rice were benched after the first quarter.
10) 1991 WASHINGTON REDSKINS
Their point differential (+261) is tied for second-best since the 16-game schedule began. They lost two games by a combined five points, and one of those came in the final game.
9) 2004 NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS
The stats are strong on both sides of the ball, the two losses were on the road to 15-1 Pittsburgh and by one point to Miami, and they were 9-1 against .500 or better teams.
8) 1986 NEW YORK GIANTS
For those of you who think we have this team ranked too high, we offer five words: Lawrence Taylor in his prime.
7) 1972 MIAMI DOLPHINS
The Dolphins played the easiest schedule of all 80 Super Bowl participants, and their passing game was ordinary.
6) 1996 GREEN BAY PACKERS
The '96 Packers are one of two postmerger Super Bowl participants to lead the NFL in points scored while allowing the fewest points.
5) 1984 SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS
Joe Montana was entering his prime and enjoyed the first of three seasons with a passer rating higher than 100.
4) 1992 DALLAS COWBOYS
The only knock against this team is its soft schedule, which is the sixth-easiest of any Super Bowl participant since the AFL-NFL merger.
3) 1978 PITTSBURGH STEELERS
Pittsburgh's two losses were by a total of 10 points, and both defeats came against playoff qualifiers.
2) 1985 CHICAGO BEARS
The Bears won 14 games by double digits, including three dominant postseason performances.
1) 1989 SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS
This team gets our nod due to its excellence on both sides of the ball, mind-boggling statistics and perhaps the most dominant postseason run in NFL history.
Like I said before, I usually don’t care about “Who is/what team is the greatest of all-time?” but I decided to do a little calculating. Below is a list of each Super Bowl game and the competitiveness of each matchup. What I did was take each Super Bowl game, took the team that was higher ranked (the worse team in rankings, as according to ESPN) and subtracted it from the other team’s rank. The higher the score, the bigger the mismatch, according to ESPN. For example, the biggest mismatch was in 1985 with the second-ranked Bears clobbering the 76th-ranked Patriots. I included the final score of each game, too.
Strength-of-Team Differentials
High Score: 74
Low Score: 1
Average Score: 36.8
1985: 74 Score
Bears (2), Patriots (76)
Chicago 46, New England 10
1996: 68 Score
Packers (6), Patriots (74)
Green Bay 35, New England 21
1986: 67 Score
Giants (8), Broncos (75)
N.Y. Giants 39, Denver 20
1979: 64 Score
Steelers (16), Rams (80)
Pittsburgh 31, L.A. Rams 19
1992: 62 Score
Cowboys (4), Bills (66)
Dallas 52, Buffalo 17
1994: 60 Score
49ers (11), Chargers (71)
San Francisco 49, San Diego 26
1999: 58 Score
Rams (14), Titans (72)
St. Louis 23, Tennessee 16
1989: 57 Score
49ers (1), Broncos (58)
San Francisco 55, Denver 10
1993: 56 Score
Cowboys (17), Bills (73)
Dallas 30, Buffalo 13
1972: 52 Score
Dolphins (7), Redskins (59)
Miami 14, Washington 7
1975: 50 Score
Steelers (13), Cowboys (63)
Pittsburgh 21, Dallas 17
2000: 49 Score
Ravens (29), Giants (78)
Baltimore 34, N.Y. Giants 7
2003: 47 Score
Patriots (32), Panthers (79)
New England 32, Carolina 29
1966: 45 Score
Packers (22), Chiefs (67)
Green Bay 35, Kansas City 10
1991: 42 Score
Redskins (10), Bills (52)
Washington 37, Buffalo 24
1995: 42 Score
Cowboys (26), Steelers (68)
Dallas 27, Pittsburgh 17
1971: 41 Score
Cowboys (15), Dolphins (56)
Dallas 24, Miami 3
1973: 39 Score
Dolphins (21), Vikings (60)
Miami 24, Minnesota 7
1982: 38 Score
Redskins (39), Dolphins (77)
Washington 27, Miami 17
1977: 37 Score
Cowboys (24), Broncos (61)
Dallas 27, Denver 10
1981: 37 Score
49ers (25), Bengals (62)
San Francisco 26, Cincinnati 21
2004: 37 Score
Patriots (9), Eagles (46)
New England 24, Philadelphia 21
1976: 35 Score
Raiders (18), Vikings (53)
Oakland 32, Minnesota 14
1974: 34 Score
Steelers (31), Vikings (65)
Pittsburgh 16, Minnesota 6
1987: 34 Score
Redskins (30), Broncos (64)
Washington 42, Denver 10
1998: 32 Score
Broncos (12), Falcons (44)
Denver 34, Atlanta 19
1984: 29 Score
49ers (5), Dolphins (34)
San Francisco 38, Miami 16
1988: 27 Score
49ers (42), Bengals (69)
San Francisco 20, Cincinnati 16
2001: 24 Score
Patriots (47), Rams (23)
New England 20, St. Louis 17
2002: 22 Score
Buccaneers (35), Raiders (57)
Tampa Bay 48, Oakland 21
1970: 19 Score
Colts (51), Cowboys (70)
Baltimore 16, Dallas 13
1997: 17 Score
Broncos (20), Packers (37)
Denver 31, Green Bay 24
1978: 16 Score
Steelers (3), Cowboys (19)
Pittsburgh 35, Dallas 31
1980: 14 Score
Raiders (40), Eagles (54)
Oakland 27, Philadelphia 10
1968: 13 Score
Jets (49), Colts (36)
N.Y. Jets 16, Baltimore 7
1990: 10 Score
Giants (33), Bills (43)
N.Y. Giants 20, Buffalo 19
2005: 9 Score
Steelers (41), Seahawks (50)
Pittsburgh 21, Seattle 10
1967: 7 Score
Packers (48), Raiders (55)
Green Bay 33, Oakland 14
1969: 7 Score
Chiefs (38), Vikings (45)
Minnesota 7, Kansas City 23
1983: 1 Score
Raiders (27), Redskins (28)
L.A. Raiders 38, Washington 9
Another thing I decided to check out was each Super Bowl game in terms of team quality. Here I took the rankings of each team per Super Bowl and added them together. The higher the score, the worse the game was, in terms of quality of teams, according to ESPN. For example, the 1970 Super Bowl was the worst when it came to quality of teams, with the 51st-ranked Colts beating the 70th-ranked Cowboys on a last-second field goal. Final score are also posted.
Quality of Team Matchups:
High Score: 121
Low Score: 22
Average Score: 81
1970: 121 Score
Colts (51), Cowboys (70)
Baltimore 16, Dallas 13
1982: 116 Score
Redskins (39), Dolphins (77)
Washington 27, Miami 17
1988: 111 Score
49ers (42), Bengals (69)
San Francisco 20, Cincinnati 16
2003: 111 Score
Patriots (32), Panthers (79)
New England 32, Carolina 29
2000: 107 Score
Ravens (29), Giants (78)
Baltimore 34, N.Y. Giants 7
1967: 103 Score
Packers (48), Raiders (55)
Green Bay 33, Oakland 14
1974: 96 Score
Steelers (31), Vikings (65)
Pittsburgh 16, Minnesota 6
1979: 96 Score
Steelers (16), Rams (80)
Pittsburgh 31, L.A. Rams 19
1980: 94 Score
Raiders (40), Eagles (54)
Oakland 27, Philadelphia 10
1987: 94 Score
Redskins (30), Broncos (64)
Washington 42, Denver 10
1995: 94 Score
Cowboys (26), Steelers (68)
Dallas 27, Pittsburgh 17
2002: 92 Score
Buccaneers (35), Raiders (57)
Tampa Bay 48, Oakland 21
2005: 91 Score
Steelers (41), Seahawks (50)
Pittsburgh 21, Seattle 10
1993: 90 Score
Cowboys (17), Bills (73)
Dallas 30, Buffalo 13
1966: 89 Score
Packers (22), Chiefs (67)
Green Bay 35, Kansas City 10
1981: 87 Score
49ers (25), Bengals (62)
San Francisco 26, Cincinnati 21
1999: 86 Score
Rams (14), Titans (72)
St. Louis 23, Tennessee 16
1968: 85 Score
Jets (49), Colts (36)
N.Y. Jets 16, Baltimore 7
1977: 85 Score
Cowboys (24), Broncos (61)
Dallas 27, Denver 10
1969: 83 Score
Chiefs (38), Vikings (45)
Kansas City 23, Minnesota 7
1986: 83 Score
Giants (8), Broncos (75)
N.Y. Giants 39, Denver 20
1994: 82 Score
49ers (11), Chargers (71)
San Francisco 49, San Diego 26
1973: 81 Score
Dolphins (21), Vikings (60)
Miami 24, Minnesota 7
1996: 80 Score
Packers (6), Patriots (74)
Green Bay 35, New England 21
1985: 78 Score
Bears (2), Patriots (76)
Chicago 46, New England 10
1975: 76 Score
Steelers (13), Cowboys (63)
Pittsburgh 21, Dallas 17
1990: 76 Score
Giants (33), Bills (43)
N.Y. Giants 20, Buffalo 19
1971: 71 Score
Cowboys (15), Dolphins (56)
Dallas 24, Miami 3
1976: 71 Score
Raiders (18), Vikings (53)
Oakland 32, Minnesota 14
1992: 70 Score
Cowboys (4), Bills (66)
Dallas 52, Buffalo 17
2001: 70 Score
Rams (23), Patriots (47)
New England 20, St. Louis 17
1972: 66 Score
Dolphins (7), Redskins (59)
Miami 14, Washington 7
1991: 62 Score
Redskins (10), Bills (52)
Washington 37, Buffalo 24
1989: 59 Score
49ers (1), Broncos (58)
San Francisco 55, Denver 10
1997: 57 Score
Broncos (20), Packers (37)
Denver 31, Green Bay 24
1998: 56 Score
Broncos (12), Falcons (44)
Denver 34, Atlanta 19
1983: 55 Score
Raiders (27), Redskins (28)
L.A. Raiders 38, Washington 9
2004: 55 Score
Patriots (9), Eagles (46)
New England 24, Philadelphia 21
1984: 39 Score
49ers (5), Dolphins (34)
San Francisco 38, Miami 16
1978: 22 Score
Steelers (3), Cowboys (19)
Pittsburgh 35, Dallas 31