Too harsh in my opinion. MVP did just fine, and I don't remember Benoit favouring his arm much at all. Another 5 or 10 minutes and it would have been much better, and shown MVP in a better light.
I'd like to know if redbaron51 had his eyes covered in the Benoit vs. MVP match, because MVP did a good job and was very nifty with the chain wrestling. He looked very solid, imo.