I actually thought it was pretty bad. Both matches last year SMOKE it. Orton NO-SOLD! the headbutt to my disgust, but I was even more upset with the fact that they didn't build on the swank headbutt spots from last year. I never get the feeling that Orton's building to the RKO. I mean, people actually like Orton using the chinlocks and headlocks and stuff because it seems like he's setting up for his finisher. I don't get that. I never think "oh, Orton's preparing for the RKO, cool!". I don't think Orton thinks "this will be some smart work leading to the finish!". It just seems like he's filling time. They look nice and realistic, but they don't really, ya know, do anything. Benoit's first german was better than it's been in a while, though. From then on it's just spot after spot, with no rhyme or reason. Benoit's sharpshooter sucked, again, and he knew it, hence his kneeling, which was actually mega cool. I appreciated the tease of the gutwrench neckbreaker that Orton does, but I'm being kind. It may be that he just couldn't lift Benoit. There was other things I liked, and other things I didn't, but I can't even remembr now.
I'm probably being too hard on it because I expected so much after the good stuff they produced last year. I guess it wasn't THAT bad, but it was hardly good. You're completely wrong if you think it's the best SD match this year, though. Eddie/Rey, Eddie/Angle, Angle/Rey, and Angle/JBL, to name just a few, are all way better than it. Maybe I need to rewatch it, but I can safely say it wasn't anything special.