I don't think they should, but if someone is not going to vote for someone for whatever they did off the field, then I do think someone should go in for charity work like that. Seems like the only fair thing to do, and list it proudly in their accomplishments.
When talking with my father, he doesn't consider Brady nor Manning the #1 QB in the league. He likes them both, but thinks #1 belongs to someone who can have success under so many different situations, as bringing in new coaches, different systems, going to a whole different team, etc. So his #1 QB is Jeff Garcia, and Kurt Warner will always be around there for this.
My question is that should it really go that deep when picking this? Brady, Manning not #1 just because they have the same stability in the system, and their coaches? Is the undersized journeyman really the #1 QB in the league?
Yeah, jumbled mess of a few questions I tried to make into one... so have at it.