The One And Only Smackdown Thread (01/22/04)

[Guest JRE]

If Kurt is genuinely trying to help, Eddy looks like an ass for turning on him when he does.

That's assuming Eddy turns on Kurt. Also, seeing as Kurt's "helping" is becoming destructive to the family and to Eddy's career- well...there's Eddy's reasons to be mad right there. Though, I do agree with you that Kurt should be the one to turn himself fully heel.

 

EDIT:

 

You also have to remember that Kurt, while a genuine helper in his own eyes, is also a very selfish character...and the fans (*GASP*) catch onto this.

[Guest Anglesault]

If Kurt is genuinely trying to help, Eddy looks like an ass for turning on him when he does.

That's assuming Eddy turns on Kurt. Also, seeing as Kurt's "helping" is becoming destructive to the family and to Eddy's career-

It's also partly Eddy's fault. He's not blameless.

 

Though, I do agree with you that Kurt should be the one to turn himself fully heel.

 

And he'll do that because.....

 

Now we're back to square one.

[Guest JRE]

If Kurt is genuinely trying to help, Eddy looks like an ass for turning on him when he does.

That's assuming Eddy turns on Kurt. Also, seeing as Kurt's "helping" is becoming destructive to the family and to Eddy's career-

It's also partly Eddy's fault. He's not blameless.

 

Though, I do agree with you that Kurt should be the one to turn himself fully heel.

 

And he'll do that because.....

 

Now we're back to square one.

1. Of course Eddy's not blameless...is he supposed to be perfect? Nah, he's just supposed to be liked by the fans.

 

2. Kurt hasn't turned yet, he hasn't had a reason. That's something that will eventually happen for reasons that probably haven't occured yet. Unless we're predicting the future...we can't argue the reason that hasn't occured yet for a heel turn that hasn't happened yet.

[Guest Anglesault]

If Kurt is genuinely trying to help, Eddy looks like an ass for turning on him when he does.

That's assuming Eddy turns on Kurt. Also, seeing as Kurt's "helping" is becoming destructive to the family and to Eddy's career-

It's also partly Eddy's fault. He's not blameless.

 

Though, I do agree with you that Kurt should be the one to turn himself fully heel.

 

And he'll do that because.....

 

Now we're back to square one.

1. Of course Eddy's not blameless...is he supposed to be perfect? Nah, he's just supposed to be liked by the fans.

Fans won't like a guy who blames a third party for hs family problems.

 

2. Kurt hasn't turned yet, he hasn't had a reason. That's something that will eventually happen for reasons that probably haven't occured yet. Unless we're predicting the future...we can't argue the reason that hasn't occured yet for a heel turn that hasn't happened yet.

 

I can argue that your scenario presents no reason for him to turn.

[Guest JRE]

If Kurt is genuinely trying to help, Eddy looks like an ass for turning on him when he does.

That's assuming Eddy turns on Kurt. Also, seeing as Kurt's "helping" is becoming destructive to the family and to Eddy's career-

It's also partly Eddy's fault. He's not blameless.

 

Though, I do agree with you that Kurt should be the one to turn himself fully heel.

 

And he'll do that because.....

 

Now we're back to square one.

1. Of course Eddy's not blameless...is he supposed to be perfect? Nah, he's just supposed to be liked by the fans.

Fans won't like a guy who blames a third party for hs family problems.

 

2. Kurt hasn't turned yet, he hasn't had a reason. That's something that will eventually happen for reasons that probably haven't occured yet. Unless we're predicting the future...we can't argue the reason that hasn't occured yet for a heel turn that hasn't happened yet.

 

I can argue that your scenario presents no reason for him to turn.

1. They will when it's f'n obvious that the third-party is being obviously hypocritical and damaging. Hmm. Let's see this through a fans eyes in your "eddy is being heel like scenario"

 

Fan 1: Jeez...Kurt is hurting Eddy's career....sticking his nose into his business and *insert reasons yet to occur that involve Kurt's future heel turn*....I'm really hating him, plus, he's a dork

 

Fan 2: But...Eddy blamed a third party for family problems...... Eddy sucks! Eddy sucks!

 

Besides....isn't that where the story is right now? Kurt's kinda screwing things up....bringin' in Chavo Sr. and such- but Eddy's trying not to hurt Kurt- even though he's screwing things up...because he's trying to help

 

2. I didn't type out a fucking scenario for the future. What I think can happen would make perfect sense. But I don't wanna type the damn thing out. What will actually happen MAY make sense...it may not- but it hasn't happened. Ya can't argue it. I'm not gonna waste my time arguing over a scenario I predict.

[Guest Anglesault]

If Kurt is genuinely trying to help, Eddy looks like an ass for turning on him when he does.

That's assuming Eddy turns on Kurt. Also, seeing as Kurt's "helping" is becoming destructive to the family and to Eddy's career-

It's also partly Eddy's fault. He's not blameless.

 

Though, I do agree with you that Kurt should be the one to turn himself fully heel.

 

And he'll do that because.....

 

Now we're back to square one.

1. Of course Eddy's not blameless...is he supposed to be perfect? Nah, he's just supposed to be liked by the fans.

Fans won't like a guy who blames a third party for hs family problems.

 

2. Kurt hasn't turned yet, he hasn't had a reason. That's something that will eventually happen for reasons that probably haven't occured yet. Unless we're predicting the future...we can't argue the reason that hasn't occured yet for a heel turn that hasn't happened yet.

 

I can argue that your scenario presents no reason for him to turn.

1. They will when it's f'n obvious that the third-party is being obviously hypocritical and damaging. Hmm. Let's see this through a fans eyes in your "eddy is being heel like scenario"

 

Fan 1: Jeez...Kurt is hurting Eddy's career....sticking his nose into his business and *insert reasons yet to occur that involve Kurt's future heel turn*....I'm really hating him, plus, he's a dork

I still think it makes Eddy look like a whiner.

2. I didn't type out a fucking scenario for the future. What I think can happen would make perfect sense. But I don't wanna type the damn thing out. What will actually happen MAY make sense...it may not- but it hasn't happened. Ya can't argue it. I'm not gonna waste my time arguing over a scenario I predict.

 

You typed out a whole reason for them to be feuding. And I said (or meant to say) tthat no where in that idea is there logical step where Angle turns heel.

[Guest JRE]

"I still think it makes Eddy look like a whiner."

 

That's...good for you then. Ignorant of the fact that Chavo turned on him because he was jealous....ignorant of the fact that Eddy's brother turned on him...ignorant of the fact that his family can't respect his personal success...ignorant of the fact that an someone with no business to try and help him out screwed things up more. But, good for you just the same!

 

"You typed out a whole reason for them to be feuding. And I said (or meant to say) tthat no where in that idea is there logical step where Angle turns heel. "

 

Right, I typed out why they have been feuding- I explained what has happened. What I'm saying is the logical step for the turn by Angle...has yet to come, because obviously, it hasn't yet.

[Guest Anglesault]

of the fact that an someone with no business to try and help him out screwed things up more. But, good for you just the same!

I agree with the family, but this is where we differ.

 

Eddy CLEARLY was fucking up the Chavo situation pretty damn well on his own. It's not like he had the situation at all under control before Kurt started to pave the road to hell.

 

For him to turn around and blame Kurt makes him look like someone who can't accept responsibility.

[Guest PowerPB13]

What would you prefer he fued with A-Train?

I'd prefer he retires.

By your standards, should about 90% of the WWE roster retire due to not being used correctly?

 

-Patrick