I'm think # 1 and # 2 are Shelton and Matt Hardy, with Jeff and Nitro coming in within about five spots or so. That way, they tease a Hardys/WGTT feud, and Nitro's there to pick up the MNM/Hardys feud. Punk comes in around # 8 and lasts at least half an hour, without doing anything hugely important. Sandman will enter around # 10 or so with plunder. He'll get a couple cane shots in, but will be tossed in short order like Dreamer was in 2003.
Around # 15 or so, Khali comes in and cleans house of some dead weight (Crazy, Dreamer, Chavo, Viscera). Within a number, Undertaker comes out and starts the fight against Khali. Taker along with some of the other remaining guys in the ring all work together and toss Khali. HBK will enter around # 17-19 or so.
Between # 20-30 will be Edge, Orton, Benoit, RVD, Finlay, Kane, Booker, Holly, Sabu, and # 30 MVP. Sabu will likely only last a minute or two by doing a couple highspots and being tossed. He'll probably even get the idiot elimination by missing a big move and accidently eliminating himself.
Final four are Taker, HBK, Orton, and Edge. HBK goes first by shady means, whether it's cheating by Edge & Orton, or if a freshly eliminated Booker pulls him out. Taker fights with R-RKO for a minute before managing to toss Orton. And he finally gets rid of Edge to win.