I think rock stars get ass easier than athletes. But then they aren't being glorified because of it. Envied maybe. But everyone knows why they're getting it.
Now there is some truth in what you're saying. Your flaw is that you said "a good looking guy in shape". Nobody in this thread except me and you fit those qualifications. Most guys are average looking, but an average looking girl can get laid 100% as easily as an incredibly hot one. Throws the curve way off.
And remember, we weren't talking about college students, we were talking about Lita, who apparently fucked in exchange for goods and services, pulled trains and was pissed on. I've done those things, but I don't think anyone's going to call me a stud because of it.