I agree with everything the article said. I just got it and was pretty disappointing considering what the 360 is capable of. I might have been better served getting the regular X-Box version. 
 
  
I think the 360 version is just fine, for the first foray on a next-gen system for college football. I don't care about all the fluff. 
  
The gamplay is really solid. 
The Dynasty is solid as well. 
Online play works great.. 
The game looks pretty damn good at least in HDTV....if you compare the xbox and xbox 360 versions its like night and day. If you dont have a HDTV, then there is no reason to have a 360. 
  
I am loving the game. The gameplay is the best in NCAA in a long long long time.