Alright, Al.
Lets say they don't sign Lieber. And lets say the Yankees get either RJ or Pavano, and Milton or Radke or Wells.
That leaves the rotation as RJ/Pavano, Milton/Radke/Wells, Vazquez (if they don't trade him) Mussina, and ???.
And we might not get RJ or Pavano. And I'd take Lieber over Milton and Radke anyday of the week. Wells is on his last legs. I just don't see how, considering how well he pitched in the 2nd half, and being a playoff savior, not sign him.
Although, we said that about Pettite last year, and look what happened.