Thorton also had PATRICK MARLEAU, a pretty damn great player who had 90+ points on the 2nd line for D guys to worry about, while Jagr had Steve Rucchin, Prucha (who Jagr basically made), and Petr Sykora (who again Jagr was basically responsible for)
edit: DID ANYBODY WATCH THE PLAYOFFS!?!? The Rangers couldn't do SHIT on offesnse without Jagr. The Panthers had Lungo standing on his head the entire year and didn't make the playoffs. The Rangers I guarantee are DEAD last without Jagr.