Jump to content
TSM Forums
  • entries
    111
  • comments
    406
  • views
    45360

About this blog

TSM's second highest rated blog!

Entries in this blog

 

All Time Yankees Draft

A mini-MLB draft is in the works. Instead of the whole of MLB history for this one, we are going to focus solely on the New York Yankees. Why the Yankees, a team I despise? They simply have the talent necessary to sustain this kind of idea. I'd run Phillies, but who is going to get excited over Fred Luderus?   We have five entrants. Myself, Canadian Chris, Smues, Brooklyn Zoo and 161st and River. One more person can join in if they are interested.   Here are the basics. 1. 21 man rosters (eight position players and a DH, three reserves, five starters, three relievers, and a manager) 2. You draft a player's career ONLY as a Yankee. If you draft Randy Johnson, you're getting 34 career victories. 3. A player may only be chosen either as a manager or player. A player may not be chosen twice for each role. Two exceptions, Hal Chase and Clark Griffith may be player-managers. 4. All home parks are assumed to be Yankee Stadium.   Results Round One CC: Babe Ruth Al: Mickey Mantle Bored: Lou Gehrig BZ: Joe Dimaggio Smues: Alex Rodriguez 161st: Bernie Williams   Round Two 161st: Whitey Ford Smues: Yogi Berra BZ: Mariano Rivera Bored: Derek Jeter Al: Charlie Keller CC: Bill Dickey   Round Three CC: Tony Lazzeri Al: Lefty Gomez Bored: Red Ruffing BZ: Don Mattingly Smues: Spud Chandler 161st:Ron Guidry   Round Four 161st: Jorge Posada Smues: Jason Giambi BZ: Thurman Munson Bored: Reggie Jackson Al: Joe Gordon CC: Andy Pettitte   Round Five CC: Goose Gossage Al: Allie Reynolds Bored: Rickey Henderson BZ: Dave Winfield Smues: Roger Clemens 161st: Roger Maris   Round Six 161st: Orlando "El Duque" Hernandez Smues: Mike Mussina BZ: Earle Combs Bored: Ed Lopat Al: Phil Rizzuto CC: Paul O'Neill   Round Seven CC: Bobby Murcer Al: Elston Howard Bored: Graig Nettles BZ: Tommy Henrich Smues: Casey Stengel (manager) 161st: Dave Righetti   Round Eight 161st: Willie Randolph Smues: Sparky Lyle BZ: Wade Boggs Bored: John Wetteland Al: Herb Pennock CC: Bob Shawkey   Round Nine CC: Jimmy Key Al: Bill Skowron Bored: Hideki Matsui BZ: Joe McCarthy (manager) Smues: Mel Stottlemyre 161st: Waite Hoyt   Round Ten 161st: Joe Torre (manager) Smues: Tino Martinez BZ: Catfish Hunter Bored: Tommy John Al: Gil McDougald CC: David Cone   Round Eleven CC: Home Run Baker Al: Roy White Bored: Alfonso Soriano BZ: Vic Raschi Smues: Robinson Cano 161st: Lou Piniella   Round Twelve 161st: Hank Bauer Smues: Frankie Crosetti BZ: Tony Kubek Bored: David Wells Al: Carl Mays CC: Chien-Ming Wang   Round Thirteen CC: Mike Stanton Al: Johnny Murphy Bored: Gary Sheffield BZ: Bobby Richardson Smues: David Justice 161st: Clete Boyer   Round Fourteen 161st: Jeff Nelson Smues: Gene Woodling BZ: George Selkirk Bored: Steve Howe Al: Miller Huggins (manager) CC: Don Baylor   Round Fifteen CC: Kid Elberfeld Al: Bob Meusel Bored: Billy Martin (manager) BZ: Al Downing Smues: Ben Chapman 161st: Wally Pipp   Round Sixteen 161st: Jack Chesbro Smues: Mickey Rivers BZ: Bob Turley Bored: Butch Wynegar Al: Steve Hamilton CC: Nick Etten   Round Seventeen CC: Jerry Mumphrey Al: Urban Shocker Bored: Ron Davis BZ: Fritz Peterson Smues: Hal Chase 161st: Bob Wickman   Round Eighteen 161st: Roberto Kelly Smues: Clark Griffith BZ: Joe Page Bored: Ralph Terry Al: Ryne Duren CC: Lindy McDaniel   Round Nineteen CC: Johnny Blanchard Al: Mike Stanley Bored:Roy Smalley BZ: Red Rolfe Smues: Joba Chamberlain 161st: Ron Blomberg   Round Twenty 161st: Tom Tresh (or Shane Spencer) Smues: Wally Schang BZ: Joe Girardi Bored: Ron Hassey Al: Snuffy Stirnweiss CC: Randy Velarde   Round Twenty-One CC: Ralph Houk (manager) Al: Birdie Cree Bored: Tim Raines BZ: Ramiro Mendoza Smues: Tom Gordon 161st: Rick Cerone   Round Twenty-Two (Relief Pitchers) 161st: Shane Spencer Smues: Lee Guetterman BZ: Dick Tidrow Bored: Hal Reniff Al: Steve Farr CC: Jack Aker

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Yankee Draft - The Competition

A couple weeks ago six of us ran an All-Time Yankees draft. With six teams chosen, the time has come to create a competition. I entered all six teams into a baseball simulator. The games are yet to come. Before the festivities begin, I thought it would be helpful to lay out the specifics and ground rules of the tournament.   1. Each team will play ten games, two against each opponent (one home and one away). 2. The top three teams will advance to the playoffs. The team with the best record receives a bye. 3. In the case of a tie for a playoff berth (first or third place), a tiebreaker game (or games as necessary) will be held. Teams can not be eliminated in a tiebreak scenario, except via an on-field game. Seeding for those games will be decided by: Head to Head record among tied teams Overall Run Differential Random Draw 4. Playoff rounds are five games apiece. Home field format is 2-2-1. 5. Each team will use a five man rotation, ensuring two starts per pitcher. 6. Each team will use their reserve catcher in the 5th and 9th games, their reserve infielder in their 6th game and their reserve outfielder in their 7th game. 7. The extra reserves and relievers (those not drafted) will only be used in an extra inning game, or if a team has exhausted their bullpen.   See the comments for game details.   Day Ten Yankees 7 Bridegrooms 5   Giants 9 Dodgers 2   Highlanders 12 Gothams 2   Day Nine Bridegrooms 3 Yankees 10   Dodgers 4 Giants 10   Gothams 2 Highlanders 5   Day Eight Highlanders 4 Bridegrooms 5 11 Innings   Gothams 4 Dodgers 5   Yankees 1 Giants 3   Day Seven Bridegrooms 4 Highlanders 6   Dodgers 8 Gothams 2   Giants 8 Yankees 10   Day Six Gothams 7 Bridegrooms 4   Yankees 5 Dodgers 3   Highlanders 7 Giants 11   Day Five Bridegrooms 10 Gothams 2   Dodgers 18 Yankees 2   Giants 4 Highlanders 8   Day Four Giants 2 Bridegrooms 4   Highlanders 3 Dodgers 12   Yankees 5 Gothams 4   Day Three Bridegrooms 3 Giants 4   Dodgers 6 Highlanders 5   Gothams 7 Yankees 8 10 Innings   Day Two Dodgers 3 Bridegrooms 6   Gothams 3 Giants 4   Yankees 4 Highlanders 6   Day One Bridegrooms 4 Dodgers 11   Giants 2 Gothams 6   Highlanders 7 Yankees 0

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Live Wrestling, Part IV

After a sabbatical from wrestling, 24/7 got me interested again in the product. I'll confess that I'm a John Cena fan, and I think the in-ring product has been as good as ever perhaps. So with a live Monday Night Raw coming, my friend, his fiance and I picked up some tickets for the show. We lucked out with it becoming a three-hour special featuring the draft lottery.   -Legends! We got appearances from Dusty Rhodes, Roddy Piper and the Fabulous Moolah.   -Chris Benoit's last Raw match.   -Local product Snitsky got DQ'ed for beating up Miz after the bell. Like that merited a DQ. My friend actually worked with Snitsky a short time at a local resort.   -The limo explosion. What an odd event at a show, we found out later that it was actually filmed the night before. The arena is actually in a fairly isolated spot, which made it an attractive venue to pull off that stunt.   For those who bash John Cena, it is really obvious from most live crowds like this that he is a tremendous draw. What struck me more than anything though is that the sound feedback was incredible. During the matches you just heard this incredible hum through the sound system. WWE cranks up the music to the point where I'm surprised the announcers can function.   Next up: Smackdown

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Live Wrestling, Part I

This Saturday I'm attending a WWE house show in Wilkes-Barre, PA. In the week prior, I thought it would be fun to look back at various live shows I have attended.   Kicking off is my first live wrestling experience. In the early days of Monday Night Raw, WWE would run shows in much smaller venues. The Fernwood Event Center was a small convention hall in Bushkill, PA that held maybe 3,000. The town more or less consists of a single resort. Parking at the place was sparse, with cars lining Route 209 perhaps for half a mile. My friend, my father and I got standing tickets for the show, I being unable to convince my dad that the show just might sell out beforehand. Still, we were in.   The show was a combined live show and taping. The matches started with a series of squash matches, some of which aired the next week on Raw. What I remember most is that it seemed to take ten minutes between each squash, more frustrating when the matches themselves lasted two minutes apiece. Razor Ramon defeated Pat Tanaka, the Headshrinkers won a squash, Diesel won a squash, and Ramon came out again and beat the Brooklyn Brawler. (As an aside, one of the jobbers against the Headshrinkers was a young Mike Bucci, who later rose to fame as Nova and Simon Dean.)   Finally we got some competitive matches. IRS defeated Marty Jannetty clean and Doink defeated Bastian Booger. Those matches later aired on the Survivor Series Showdown. Bret Hart beat Jerry Lawler in a dark match. That may have been scheduled to air, but Lawler was charged with statutory rape soon after and was taken off television. Then we got the live Raw, which consisted of Ludwig Borga vs. Scott Steiner and a few more squash matches. The live show saw Randy Savage attack Crush in the dressing area, but without monitors all the live crowd saw was Bob Backlund vs. Barry Horowitz.   Being late, we left during Luger vs. Pierre. An Undertaker/Yokozuna dark match followed.   The show itself is almost entirely unmemorable, as Raw was not much more than a live episode of Superstars at that time. Fernwood was a poor venue, it was cramped and allowed little space for movement to concessions and merchandise, and some fans found themselves sitting directly in walkways. Adding the poor location, and it's a wonder WWE bothered. I would have liked to see them run the Scranton CYC for a Raw once or twice. Or even the Ag Hall in Allentown. Those would have accomplished the same goal of an intimate venue, with a nod towards history.   Coming tomorrow: March '99 in the Meadowlands

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Live Wrestling, Part II

Fast forwarding to 1999, a friend winning a radio contest netted us tickets to WWE Raw at the Meadowlands, the day after Wrestlemania XV.   This event featured a two hour live Raw, along with Shotgun and Super Astros tapings. Some highlights I recall.   -The Public Enemy pinned by six other guys in a four team tag match. -El Hijo del Santo! -Goldust winning the Intercontinental title from the Blue Meanie.   We got the taping first. The night's Raw featured the usual Russo era storylines. The problem with this type of show is that while everything is designed to engage the live audience, none of it is particularly memorable. The Undertaker kidnaps Stephanie McMahon, leading Vince to order his hooligans to find her. Ken Shamrock gets a confession from Christian. All a little more soap operaish than I prefer. Austin regained his Smoking Skull championship belt at this show. The Rock's popularity was on the rise, and it was clearly evident that he would turn face within a month.   Apologies for a short entry, but I'm really at a loss to write anything really interesting here.   Coming tomorrow: Live shows in 2000 and 2003.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Forgotten Trade Rumors

Watching the Glory Days documentary of the 1980 Phillies, former owner Ruly Carpenter mentioned a potential trade with the Texas Rangers over the winter of 1979 that would have removed three star performers of the 1980 season. Narrator Dallas Green states, "of course, we won't mention the players involved," while showing a clip of Tug McGraw. What was that trade? What would it have entailed?   Paperofrecord.com carries archives of the Sporting News. Searching for "McGraw" over the period of 1979 would bring up potential trade rumors, I would think. Sure enough, we find our answer. The Phillies seemed keen on acquiring an ace reliever. Whispers of offers to the Cubs for Bruce Sutter are mentioned, but the big one is a package to the Rangers for Sparky Lyle. Specifically, the Phillies would have sent Tug McGraw, Larry Christenson and Bake McBride to the Rangers for Sparky Lyle, outfielder Johnny Grubb, reliever Adrian Devine and maybe shortstop Pepe Frias.   Swapping Lyle for McGraw must have looked good at the time. Sparky Lyle at the time was the greatest lefty reliever of all time. Lyle however was hanging on the precipice. He bombed in 1980, producing a 4.69 ERA with Texas. Tug McGraw meanwhile battled tendonitis, but after a three week stint on the DL he came back and posted an amazing 0.52 ERA from July through the end of the season. I count 12 one-run victories among his appearances. Given that the Phillies won the NL East by a single game, surely that trade costs them the pennant.   The rest of the package looks a little more interesting. Bake McBride was the starting right fielder and a good player. McBride hit .309 in 1980 with 52 extra base hits. Among right fielders, he was middle of the pack. Grubb meanwhile was a lefty slugger, a tremendous platoon player in the era. With Grubb, the Phillies likely platoon him in right field with blazing rookie Lonnie Smith. Offensively that's a good move. Defensively with Smith in right and Greg Luzinski in left? Thank god Maddox was the Secretary of Defense.   Adrian Devine had a good ERA in 1979 but it was a fluke. He struck out merely 22 batters in 66.7 innings pitched. Sure enough, he had a 4.82 ERA the next season and never again pitched in the Majors. Frias was just an awful hitter.   So that trade costs them 1980. McBride faded after the season. Christenson gave the Phillies about 350 quality innings the rest of his career. McGraw had another good season in 1981 and hung on three more years. Grubb was a quality player but not a star. Oddly, the Phillies snagged Sparky Lyle later in the season in a September trade, sending Kevin Saucier after the season for a PTBNL. 1981 was the strike year, that is almost impossible to gauge. One wonders if the Phillies in 1982 could have contended without Christenson pitching a full season. And of course in '83 they won the pennant.   In retrospect, the trade costs them a World Championship. Thank goodness it did not happen.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Wrestling Draft: My Top 64 Prospects

Over in the General Wrestling forum, there is a draft going on to select all-time rosters of wrestlers. I missed out on this, but it provides an opportunity to do a little list creation in my spare time. I created a list of my ideal top 64 picks. When selecting a wrestler, I feel you need to look for uncommon attributes, something to stand out from the crowd. Mid-carders are crucial to a good promotion, but you can find many, many guys at that level. Also, I think a wrestler needs some ability to succeed in today's environment. Gorgeous George was extremely popular as a heel for a time, but he was a limited attraction and today the novelty would be gone. I don't think he would be a top draw today. Let's see how my 64 stands up against the actual draft. I will divide this into four sections.   1. Wrestlers both in my top 64 and the draft top 64. 2. Wrestlers in my top 64 who just missed (first 100 picks). 3. Whiffs, Guys in my top 64 who went beyond the 100th pick. 4. Undrafted wrestlers.   I did not rank my list, so it is simply a list of 64 wrestlers/teams.   1. Wrestlers both in my top 64 and the draft top 64.   Since there is a consensus, there should be no need to comment on these names individually.   1. Bret Hart 2. Hulk Hogan 3. The Rock 4. Ric Flair 5. Steve Austin 6. Randy Savage 7. Andre the Giant 8. Shawn Michaels 10. John Cena 11. Triple H 12. Sting 13. The Undertaker 14. Brock Lesnar 15. Mick Foley 16. Kurt Angle 17. Roddy Piper 18. Bill Goldberg 19. Vader 20. Terry Funk 21. Eddie Guerrero 22. Chris Jericho 23. Ricky Steamboat 27. Steiner Brothers 30. Harley Race 31. Ultimate Warrior 33. Kerry Von Erich 34. Dusty Rhodes 35. Curt Hennig 38. The Road Warriors 40. Superstar Billy Graham 44. Bruno Sammartino 45. Jake Roberts 50. Stan Hansen 51. The Great Muta 52. Jack Brisco 54. Bruiser Brody 56. Terry Gordy/Miracle Violence Connection (I had him as part of the Freebirds) 61. Barry Windham 64. Magnum T.A.   2. Wrestlers in my top 64 who just missed (first 100 picks).   65. Jimmy Snuka 67. Rey Mysterio 68. Sid Vicious (as a member of the Skyscrapers) 69. The Big Show 70. Jerry Lawler 72. Sgt. Slaughter 89. Lex Luger 100. Yokozuna   Great picks here, a few main eventers, a couple of solid workers (Sgt. Slaughter is underrated). Chalk this up to slight differences of opinion, perhaps some crowding with posters preferring Japanese workers.   3. Whiffs, Guys in my top 64 who went beyond the 100th pick.   Now we get to the portion where drafters are simply missing the boat on great talent, underrating guys who could carry a promotion, or make a significant contribution. Kudos to those who took the bait and made a wise choice on a late round pick.   101. Junkyard Dog - For a time, one of the most popular wrestlers in the country. 102. Nikita Koloff 104. Nick Bockwinkel - A wrestler with Bockwinkel's cockiness and interview style would no doubt make a top heel today. I could easily see him paired up against John Cena. 110. Trish Stratus - Possibly the greatest female wrestler in U.S. history, incredibly beautiful. Capable of filling a variety of roles. 117. Sabu - Unique style, still unmatched in wrestling. A genuine sensation in the 1990s, unwillingness to work at times hurt his potential. 128. Dory Funk Jr. - Interesting to think what he would do nowadays. Playing the grizzled veteran along with his backstage teaching skills, he'd be an asset to any organization. 131. Lou Thesz - Could he make it today? I think his wrestling skill could carry him, particularly as a stooging heel. 137. The Sheik - The most feared, savage heel of all time. 161. David Von Erich - Future NWA champion until his untimely death. David is a "what if" story, so I can't blame people for overlooking him. 176. Buddy Rogers - Top heel of his era, huge television star. Think Randy Orton cockiness combined with Ric Flair's charisma. Drew the biggest wrestling crowd in the United States in 1961. 38,000+ at Comiskey Park to see him win the NWA title, a mark unsurpassed until 1984.   4. Undrafted wrestlers.   Seven mostly old-school wrestlers who could benefit any promotion.   Mil Mascaras - One of the most popular latino wrestlers in history, used dazzling aerial manuevers in his prime. Fred Blassie - Before managing, was a blond, vicious heel with incredible talking ability. Billy Robinson - A great performer from Britain. Had less backstage warts than the Dynamite Kid. His mat work is good even by today's standards. Jim Londos - Who? The greatest gate attraction of the pre-1950s era. At 190 lbs., handsome and tanned, would make a great babyface champion for a light heavyweight division. Bobo Brazil - Popular black wrestler who re-defined racial boundaries. 6'6". Gene Kiniski - Largely unknown NWA champion. Good worker and talent, around 6'4". His size would make him credible and his heel work would carry him from there. Ernie Ladd - A former NFL star, legitimately huge with great heel mannerisms. Johnny Valentine - Greg's father worked the same style, but better.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Live Wrestling, Part III

A bit of background on this one. For years, WWE ran frequent shows at the Catholic Youth Center in Scranton, PA. Its history dates back at least to 1964, with Bruno Sammartino main eventing shows. Even as the Attitude era flourished in large arenas, WWE would come back to the CYC and run shows in front of 3,800 fans. In the Summer of 1998 however, the catholic leadership saw the product becoming too distasteful, and barred the WWE. So wrestling left the area for two years.   I never saw a wrestling show at the CYC, but I did attend a Harlem Globetrobbers game there. The best information I can find is that the CYC is now owned by Lackawanna College. Here's a virtual tour of the facility.   http://www.ecampustours.com/VirtualTours/V...83&ItemID=8   July 16, 2000. For the first time, the new First Union Arena at Casey Plaza hosts a WWE event (they had WCW Thunder in January). I had upper deck seats to catch this lineup.   Bull Buchanon defeated Al Snow WWF European Champion Eddie Guerrero defeated Perry Saturn Taka Michinoku & Sho Funaki defeated the Dupps WWF Tag Team Champions Edge & Christian defeated the Acolytes The Undertaker defeated Kurt Angle via count-out Ivory defeated Jackie WWF Hardcore Champion Steve Blackman defeated Gangrel WWF Hardcore Champion Steve Blackman defeated Essa Rios Matt & Jeff Hardy defeated Road Dogg & X-Pac Kane defeated the Big Bossman   None of the matches truly stands out. Undertaker/Angle really turned out to be a dress rehearsal for their Fully Loaded PPV match, minus the finish. This was a good show though, nothing was remotely close to bad.   Three years later, first level seats at the same venue (now called the Wachovia Arena at Casey Plaza).   Maven & the Hurricane defeated Lance Storm & Chief Morley when Hurricane pinned Morley Christopher Nowinski pinned Tommy Dreamer WWE Women’s Champion Jazz defeated Trish Stratus and Victoria by pinning Trish WWE Raw Tag Team Champion Kane pinned Christian Bubba Ray, D-Von, & Spike Dudley defeated Rico & 3 Minute Warning in a tables match following a 3D on Jamal through a table Sylvian Grenier & Rene Dupree defeated Scott Steiner & Test when Test was pinned as he was distracted by Stacy Keibler and Steiner on the floor Booker T pinned Rodney Mack WWE Raw World Champion Triple H pinned Kevin Nash after ramming the challenger’s head into an unprotected turnbuckle   Here things are clearer. The Dudleys' table match was no more than a standard six man tag with a table finish. I was sour on HHH/Nash at the time, but in retrospect I need to admit that they had a fine match.   I think arena shows are excellent as a fan. Live television shows can be hit or miss as the company is more concerned with angle development. At the live events, it's simply matches, and every angle is done with the live audience in mind.   Coming tomorrow: The Draft Lottery in 2007 and Benoit loses his mind.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Yankee Competition, Tiebreakers and Playoffs

Final Standings of pool play.   Giants 6-4 Dodgers 6-4 Highlanders 6-4 Yankees 6-4 Bridegrooms 4-6 Gothams 2-8   With four teams tied, a tiebreaker is actually easy to set up. Teams seeded one and four will compete, along with teams seeded two and three. The winners will play for the top spot, the loser of that getting the second spot. The losers of the first game will play for third place and the final playoff entry. The Giants pick up the first seed thanks to their 4-2 record against the other three teams. The Dodgers will get home field against the Highlanders due to better run differential. Hera are the tiebreak matchups.   Yankees (Hunter) @ Giants (Gomez) Highlanders (Ruffing) @ Dodgers (Pettitte)   Giants 3, Yankees 2 Dodgers 6, Highlanders 3   Dodgers 6, Giants 1 Yankees 5, Highlanders 2   First round is Giants vs. Yankees, winner battles the Dodgers. Both series will be contested best of five.   Earle Combs hit .481/.526/.750, taking MVP honors. Jimmy Key will take best pitcher honors with two wins, 23 innings pitched and a 2.74 ERA.   Yankees 3, Giants 4 Yankees 1, Giants 4 Giants 3, Yankees 4 Giants 8, Yankees 2 Giants win series 3 games to 1.   Giants 2, Dodgers 15 Giants 1, Dodgers 10 Dodgers 9, Giants 10 (13 Innings) Dodgers 4, Giants 6 Giants 8, Dodgers 9 (10 Innings) Dodgers win series 3 games to 2.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

All Time MLB Draft

I'm blatantly ripping off a concept from Bored. The best player from each pick in the draft. The MLB June draft has run from 1965 to the present.   1. Alex Rodriguez, SS 2. Reggie Jackson, OF 3. Robin Yount, SS 4. Dave Winfield, OF or Barry Larkin, SS 5. Dwight Gooden, RHP 6. Barry Bonds, OF 7. Frank Thomas, 1B 8. Todd Helton, 1B 9. Barry Zito, LHP 10. Mark McGwire, 3B   Not one #1 overall pick has yet made the Hall, though Junior Griffey and A-Rod certainly will. Having no player better than Zito at #9 is a surprise, ditto for Doc Gooden at #5.   11. Greg Luzinski, 1B 12. Billy Wagner, LHP or Nomar Garciaparra, SS 13. Manny Ramirez, OF 14. Derrek Lee, 1B 15. Chase Utley, 2B 16. Lance Parrish, IF 17. Roy Halladay, RHP 18. Willie Wilson, OF 19. Roger Clemens, RHP 20. Mike Mussina, RHP   21. Rick Sutcliffe, RHP 22. Craig Biggio, C 23. Jason Kendall, C 24. Rondell White, OF 25. Chuck Knoblauch, 2B 26. Alan Trammell, SS 27. Vida Blue, LHP 28. Lee Smith, RHP 29. George Brett, SS 30. Mike Schmidt, SS   Where are the Hall of Famers? Currently, 19 members of the Hall of Fame began their careers out of the amateur draft. Only six of them (Jackson, Yount, Winfield, Puckett, Fisk, Molitor) were chosen in the first ten picks of the draft. Five of them were not picked in the top 100, and Ryne Sandberg was the 511th pick in his draft. Nolan Ryan was the 226th pick, Goose Goosage was chosen 204th.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Over/Under, 2008 Edition

Over/Under   I'm establishing a rule for myself. 15 overs and unders. Let's see where that leads.   Baltimore Orioles 66.0 66.0 UNDER Florida Marlins 69.0 69.0 UNDER Pittsburgh Pirates 70.0 70.0 OVER Kansas City Royals 71.0 71.0 OVER Washington Nationals 72.0 72.0 OVER Tampa Bay Devil Rays 73.0 73.0 OVER San Francisco Giants 73.0 73.0 UNDER Oakland Athletics 74.0 74.0 OVER Texas Rangers 75.5 75.5 OVER Minnesota Twins 75.5 75.5 OVER Houston Astros 76.0 76.0 OVER Chicago White Sox 77.0 77.0 UNDER Cincinnati Reds 79.0 79.0 OVER St. Louis Cardinals 80.0 80.0 UNDER Colorado Rockies 83.0 83.0 UNDER San Diego Padres 84.5 84.5 OVER Seattle Mariners 85.0 85.0 UNDER Milwaukee Brewers 85.0 85.0 UNDER Toronto Blue Jays 85.5 85.5 UNDER Arizona Diamondbacks 86.0 86.0 OVER Los Angeles Dodgers 86.5 86.5 OVER Philadelphia Phillies 86.5 86.5 OVER Atlanta Braves 87.0 87.0 UNDER Chicago Cubs 89.0 89.0 UNDER Cleveland Indians 89.5 89.5 OVER Los Angeles Angels 92.5 92.5 UNDER Detroit Tigers 93.0 93.0 UNDER New York Yankees 93.5 93.5 UNDER New York Mets 94.0 94.0 UNDER Boston Red Sox 94.5 94.5 OVER   I noticed that I tended to go the over on mostly sub-.500 teams and under on mostly over-.500 teams. As a whole, I think most teams are ranked fairly on this list. For example, the Cubs are listed above the Brewers. I took the under on the Cubs and over on the Brewers. I still think the Cubs are favorites, I just think the win margin will end up 88-86.   I will be happy to answer questions about individual teams. The Astros replaced three awful players in their lineup (Ausmus, Biggio and Everett) with J.R. Towles, Kaz Matsui and Miguel Tejada. Their rotation sucks, but it sucked last year too, no loss. And it's a weak division.   The Pirates will no doubt finish below .500, but 92 losses? Not a sure thing in the NL Central. The Pirates are an odd team in that they are bad, but they lack truly bad players. They just do not have a truly standout player on their team. (Unless Jason Bay rebounds.)

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Political Stuff

I don't usually blog about politics, but I feel the urge. Pennsylvania runs their primaries quite late in the season, around late April. Consequently, we have little say in the Presidential primaries. Political ads have begun popping up, but I have yet to see a plethora of spots for presidential hopefuls. Some of the local politicians have started in earnest. Two candidates air ads on local television for the Republican nomination for Pennsylvania's tenth district (More on the district later). Here is one hopeful, Dan Meuser!     A blogger for the Morning Call refers to Meuser as robo-candidate! Indeed, Meuser has that stereotypical conservative politician look about him. His commercial targets illegal immigrants, a popular hot-button issue when you have nothing else to offer. Here is what amuses me. The commercial refers to his ideas as "the Meuser Plan." I can just imagine him showing up for Congress the first day, when the House of Representatives tell Mr. Freshman Politician what he can do with his plan. Newbs do not exactly carry a lot of pull around Congress.   (As an aside, part of this glorious plan is to make English the official language. Personally, I have taken to crossing out all the latin words on my currency. You need to start somewhere.)   Chris Hackett also runs ads, his campaign promises to fight wasteful spending. There's a fresh idea. It bothers me mostly that campaigns involve such blatant pandering and empty promises, but I guess that is how the public reacts.   I mentioned the tenth district, and here is where this all fits in. This seat is currently held by a democrat. It was Republican from 1961-2005. The first candidate became Governor after one term, the second has a stretch of highway named after him. The third, Don Sherwood, was caught in a love scandal and was defeated in the last election. This seat is easily winnable for the Republicans, so no wonder they are eager to fight Chris Carney.   It's not my district, so I don't need to put much thought into it. We have our own long term Congressman (Paul Kanjorski-D) who is going to be opposed by Mayor Lou Barletta of Hazleton (he of the illegal immigrant crackdown). Democrats have won 24 of the last 25 elections there, so Barletta has an uphill battle.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Phillies Prospects - A Review

Let's take a look at the Phillies' top 30 prospects and see how they look with less than three weeks left in the minor league season. Little statistics here, just opinions and analysis. If you need numbers, they are readily available.   1. Carlos Carrasco Good season, showing he can handle AA and making two good starts now in AAA. Not dominant, but probably a good mid-rotation starter in the making.   2. Adrian Cardenas Performed well in Clearwater before a trade to the Oakland organization. Now promoted to AA Midland, where the Athletics have moved him back to shortstop.   3. Joe Savery Disappointing showing, but low home run totals are encouraging. Savery has actually DH'ed in four games as well. Still a prospect.   4. Josh Outman Outman actually performed worse when converted to the bullpen. Traded to Oakland, the A's have placed him back in the rotation and promoted him to AAA Sacramento.   5. Kyle Drabek Coming back from Tommy John surgery, pitching in the Gulf Coast League. Next year will indicate where he stands.   6. Dominic Brown Great plate discipline and some pop. Potential star player on the rise.   7. Greg Golson That he can handle AA pitching and hit for average yet is a great sign. Strikes out often but shows a good approach at the plate. He is not a wild hacker.   8. Lou Marson Top-notch AA season. Phillies' catcher of the future.   9. Andrew Carpenter Hugely disappointing season, only now showing signs of coming around.   10. Jason Jaramillo Last really good offensive season was in Lakewood. A non-prospect, IMO.   11. J.A. Happ Has good minor league numbers but looked bad in the Majors. At 25, he's short on time.   12. Scott Mathieson Second Tommy John surgery. A longshot.   13. Freddy Galvis Slick fielding shortstop. Not producing much in Low A but not completely overmatched. Still very young.   14. Edgar Garcia Getting hammered at AA. Garcia has always been young for his levels, never impressive but always climbing the ladder.   15. Jason Donald Big season, climbing into the Phils' top ten next season.   16. Travis D'Arnaud Performance at Williamsport behind his already good defensive reputation will shoot him up the charts. If this has seemed an overly optimistic view of the Phillies' system, wait til we're finished.   17. Heitor Correa Has not pitched.   18. Travis Mattair Not performing well at Lakewood. Has at year a year to turn things around.   19. Julian Sampson Good groundball pitcher, but not getting many strikeouts. Again, has a year or two to improve yet.   20. Brad Harman Showing power, but numbers otherwise disappointing in AA Reading. He has a future if he can stick at shortstop, probably as a utility infielder.   21. D'Arby Myers Did so badly at Lakewood that he got pushed back to Williamsport. A good athlete but status is slipping fast. Too bad. "I'm thinking D'arby" could have been big.   22. Carlos Monasterios Poor season in Clearwater. Does not look like that Bobby Abreu trade will pan out.   23. Quintin Berry Currently riding a 30 game hitting streak. Speedy, not much power. He could be a fifth outfielder down the road.   24. Joe Bisenius At 25, if you can not handle AAA and do not dominate AA, you're not a prospect.   25. Tyler Mach Retired.   26. Antonio Bastardo Very good strikeout numbers, but beginning to struggle at higher levels. Has a future as a reliever.   27. Mike Zagurski Tommy John surgery.   28. Matt Spencer Traded to Oakland after a disappointing FSL campaign. He's hitting (albeit hacking) at High A Stockton. He was skipped a level, so I'd wait before writing him off.   29. Drew Naylor Great season in Lakewood but struggling in Clearwater. Still an encouraging campaign.   30. Lincoln Holdzkom Rule V pick returned to Boston before the season.   Next, five players who emerged this season.   Michael Taylor. Great numbers combined between Low and High A. One of the highest OBPs in the minors.   Michael Stutes. 0.85 ERA with matching peripherals in ten starts.   Jason Knapp. Strong strikeout numbers for high school draftee in GCL.   Zach Collier. Early numbers from supplemental draftee are encouraging.   Justin De Fratus. 20 year old pitching well in Williamsport.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

World Baseball Team

Had this idea at work. Simple concept, create an All-Star team using only one player from each country. 25 man roster, plus a manager.   Starters C: Dave Nilsson, Australia 1B: Sadaharu Oh, Japan 2B: Glenn Hubbard, Germany SS: Luis Aparicio, Venezuela 3B: Reno Bertoia, Italy LF: Larry Walker, Canada CF: Devon White, Jamaica RF: Roberto Clemente, Puerto Rico DH: Babe Ruth, USA   Rotation SP Pedro Martinez, Dominican Republic SP: Bert Blyleven, Netherlands SP: Chien-Ming Wang, Taiwan SP: Dennis Martinez, Nicaragua SP: Tony Mullane: Ireland   Bullpen CL: Mariano Rivera, Panama RP: Lance Painter, United Kingdom RP: Moe Drabowsky, Poland RP: Danny Graves, Vietnam RP: Bobby Chouinard, Phillipines RP: Byung-Hyun Kim, Korea   Bench C: Eddie Ainsmith, Russia IF: Orlando Cabrera, Columbia IF: Hector Espino, Mexico (the minor league home run king) OF: Elmer Valo, Czechoslovakia   Manager: Bruce Bochy, France

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Phillies Prospect List, Rough Draft

Coming up with a list of the Phillies' Top 30 prospects, a step ahead of Baseball America.   1. Carlos Carrasco, RHP 2. Jason Donald, SS 3. Michael Taylor, OF 4. Dominic Brown, OF 5. Travis D'Arnaud, C 6. Kyle Drabek, RHP 7. Lou Marson, C 8. Zack Collier, OF 9. Vance Worley, RHP 10. Joe Savery, LHP 11. J.A. Happ, LHP 12. Sebastian Valle, C 13. Michael Stutes, RHP 14. Jason Knapp, RHP 15. John Mayberry Jr., OF 16. Edgar Garcia, RHP 17. Antonio Bastardo, LHP 18. Drew Naylor, RHP 19. Andrew Carpenter, RHP 20. Quintin Berry, OF 21. Freddy Galvis, SS 22. Julian Sampson, RHP 23. Michael Cisco, RHP 24. Sergio Escalona, LHP 25. Jeremy Slayden, OF 26. Anthony Gose, OF 27. Brad Harman, 2B/SS 28. Michael Zagurski, LHP 29. Anthony Hewitt, SS 30. Jason Jaramillo, C   This is a work in progress. Any questions, comments or suggestions are more than welcome. I'm curious to see how it stacks up against BA's list later this offseason.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Dodgers/Athletics World Series: Game 3

I rented this game recently off Netflix. I thought I had pegged the Gibson walk-off, but this game certainly did not disappoint. A 2-1 victory highlighted by Mark McGwire's walk-off home run in the ninth. A few thoughts:   -It surprises me somewhat that you rarely hear about this homer from McGwire, even during his playing days. You would think a player known for his home run exploits would have this one highlighted.   -McGwire's home run game came three days after Gibson won game one with his own home run. This was the first time two batters hit walk-off home runs in the same series. The only other series to earn this distinction was the 2004 NLCS.   -I will never, ever complain about too many pickoff throws again. Bob Welch threw over eight times after Steve Sax reached base to leadoff the game. The eighth inning was interminable, with the Athletics obsessed with neutralizing Lasorda's running attack.   -Despite the throw overs, the constant threat of hit and runs, steals, etc. make this game very interesting. Broadcaster Vin Scully does an outstanding job of giving the relevant situation, letting the viewer know the potential strategy given the statistics and results of the season. Fox should watch Scully and NBC work games and take notes.    

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Bob Gibson, 1968

Forty years ago, Bob Gibson set a near-record by posting a 1.12 ERA over a full season. Of course Gibson benefitted from favorable pitching conditions, but his mark is still third all time even taking the deadball era into account.   What amazes me most about the season is not the ERA, but the fact that Gibson lost nine games in the process. Without exaggeration, I can find 200 pitchers who had more impressive single season records. I thought it would be interesting to take a quick look at those losses. Retrosheet.org has game logs of course, but thanks to Baseball Reference's Play Index we can create a quick list.   http://www.baseball-reference.com/pi/shareit/HSpC   There are ten games on this list. Nine of Gibson's losses, and a tenth game the Cardinals lost after Gibson left the game. For the record, Gibson had three no-decisions in 1968, the Cardinals went 2-1 in those games. In one loss, Gibson surrendered six runs, three of them earned. He allowed just six hits in a complete game, two walks, and 15 strikeouts. All six runs scored in the final three innings.   Three times Gibson lost 1-0 games. In one game he pitched a dual shutout with the Phillies' Woodie Fryman before losing in the tenth. Don Drysdale beat him 2-0, the other run coming off a reliever in the ninth (Gibson left for a pinch-hitter). In the third, the Giants' Gaylord Perry countered with a no-hitter. In those four three-run outings, Gibson pitched eight innings in all four. Two were complete games, the other two saw Gibson lifted for pinch hitters with his team trailing.   Here are Gibson's wins for that season.   http://www.baseball-reference.com/pi/shareit/KtNf   Those two at the bottom are Gibson's no decisions that the Cardinals won. Two things stand out about the wins. One, Gibson pitched 9 or more full innings EVERY SINGLE TIME he won a game. Second, Gibson won a game while allowing more than one run just twice. Talk about earning your victories.   Many teams struggled to score runs in 1968. The Cardinals finished fourth out of ten teams despite a team containing Orlando Cepeda, Lou Brock, Roger Maris, Curt Flood and Tim McCarver. Just three players (Brock, Flood and Dal Maxvill) posted OBPs above .310.   By any measure Gibson was a dominant force that year. If he had the hitting the SF Giants for example enjoyed that season, he would have gone 30-3. As it was though, it's a remarkable season in spite of the nine losses.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Phillies' Offseason Thread

We've got a couple of Phillies' fans on this board. Instead of clogging the MLB thread in Sports, I figured I would post my thoughts here, and maybe we'll run with this throughout the offseason. What do the Phillies need to do to improve this offseason? I'll address the trouble spots.   1. Third Base   Abraham Nunez hit .211/.303/.273 this season in 322 at bats. That performance is a big reason why the Phils failed to reach the postseason. You can take that kind of performance from a slick fielding utility infielder, but it is unacceptable for a regular starter at any position. The problem the Phillies face is that the market is barren as far as infielders go this offseason. It looks like Aramis Ramirez will be available, but he will be expensive, he's streaky and his plate discipline is an issue. This is a place where the Phils might be well served to trade for a team's extra third baseman, such as Josh Fields (White Sox) or Mark Teahen (Royals).   2. Bullpen   Right now the Phillies' pen shapes up like this...   Closer: Tom Gordon Setup Man: Geoff Geary RHRP: Ryan Madson LHRP: Matt Smith   The Phils have some options including Eude Brito, Clay Condrey and Brian Sanches. Brito's future in the majors is in the bullpen, and it is time to find out if he can play or not. Condrey's good as the last man in the bullpen who you can easily option back to AAA if you need the spot. Sanches had a great year in AAA, but I'm not certain that he is an MLB caliber reliever. Fabio Castro will probably end up in AA Reading for more seasoning. One option could be Yoel Hernandez, who has an excellent slider but missed most of the season due to injury.   There are several good options on the free agent market. David Riske has pitched seven seasons with a 123 ERA+ to show for it. Justin Speier has developed into one of the game's best middle relievers since he left Colorado three years ago. Chad Bradford's groundball tendencies would be a good fit in a hitters' haven like Citizens Bank Park. Boston reliever Keith Foulke also might be worth a flier. He had a poor year, but few free agents have his ceiling. Among the lefties, the top choices are Jamie Walker, Ray King and Steve Kline. Steve Kline is a very attractive choice. He's not only a gritty, dirtbag type of player, he's also a local product who hails from Sunbury, PA.   The Phils will be in good shape if they can sign one of those guys, and great shape if they get two.   3. Starting Pitching   So far the Phillies can count on Cole Hamels, Brett Myers and Jon Lieber to return next season. Jamie Moyer has a mutual option of that the Phillies should exercise their end. Gavin Floyd is a potential option, given that he is still only 23 years old and improving. In this market, you can't count on stardom. The only pitcher I would comfortably throw big money at is Jason Schmidt (or Mike Mussina, if the Yankees' decline his option). The best thing here is probably to find an innings eater who can keep the Phils in the game. Potential targets include Miguel Batista (useful due to his ability to convert to relief), Tomokazu Ohka, or Jeff Suppan.   4. Catching   There are no free agent catchers better than Carlos Ruiz, so Ruiz should be given every opportunity to win the starting job. Ruiz is a line drive hitter with an excellent arm behind the plate. Chris Coste is a capable backup who can also play the corners. Given Coste's versatility, it would be wise for the Phils to grab an extra backup. Gregg Zaun or Robert Fick would be good options here.   5. Right Field   Neither Aaron Rowand nor Shane Victorino hits quite well enough to play in a corner. It might be time for the Phils to finally indulge in Trot Nixon, settling him in a platoon with Jeff Conine (assuming he remains in Philly). As always, there are several outfield options for a team who can think creatively. Roward would be good trade bait to fill any of these five spots.   In any case, this should be an interesting offseason.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Phillies' Pharm Report

About a month into the season, it's a good time to see how the kids are doing in the minors. Rankings are the preseason rankings courtesy of Baseball America. The letters in parenthesis refer to the league. They run in the following order, from highest to lowest.   AAA: Scranton/Wilkes-Barre, International League AA: Reading, Eastern League A+: Clearwater, Florida State League A: Lakewood, South Atlantic League Short Season A: Batavia, New York-Penn League Rookie: GCL Phillies, Gulf Coast League   1. Cole Hamels, SP (Age 22) 1-1, 1.77 ERA, 20 1/3 IP, 16 H, 4 ER, 0 HR, 9 BB, 29 Ks (A+) 1-0, 0.00 ERA, 7 IP, 3 H, 0 ER, 0 HR, 0 BB, 14 Ks (AAA)   Hamels earned a call to Scranton after a good start in Clearwater, and absolutely steamrolled the Norfolk Tide in his first start. As long as he stays healthy, he is a premium talent.   2. Gio Gonzalez, SP (Age 20) 1-1, 1.48 ERA, 24 1/3 IP, 15 H, 4 ER, 1 HR, 8 BB, 28 Ks (AA)   Gonzalez is a lefty on the short side of 6' tall. The usual concerns from scouts are the only mark on his report. His first four starts in AA are about as good as you can get from a 20 year old pitcher. He's bound to have a rough start here and there to drive back his rate stats, but early returns are outstanding. Gonzalez is close to breaking onto Top 50 prospect lists.   3. Greg Golson, OF (Age 20) .159/.209/.206, 1 HR, 2 RBIs, 1 SB (A)   63 at bats, one extra base hit. As Baseball Prospectus noted, "it would be nice if his performance bore the slightest resemblance to what the tools watchers say he can do." Maybe Golson has upside. But there is no way he deserves the number three ranking in the organization, no matter how thin it is. It is still early, but if I do not see results at the end of the year, I am writing him off.   4. Michael Bourn, OF (Age 23) .230/.269/.324, 0 HR, 4 RBIs, 9 SB (AA)   Bourn's batting line includes three triples, and he has yet to be caught stealing. Bourn is an extremely fast runner with excellent plate discipline. The problem is that he has very little power, and pitchers are not apt to pitch around him when he will not drive the ball. That negates his ability to get on base. Bourn posted an acceptable .348 OBP last season, but that will not propel him to star status. Bourn is good defensively with a great arm, so at minimum he can provide a team with a 5th outfielder.   5. Scott Mathieson, SP (Age 22) 1-1, 4.26 ERA, 25 1/3 IP, 24 H, 12 ER, 2 HR, 6 BB, 30 Ks (AA)   That K:BB ratio is extremely good, and he does not allow an unusual number of home runs. Allowing twelve runs is more bad luck than anything else. Mathieson's carried this kind of stat line his entire career however. There are several who think Mathieson's future is as a power closer. Since he carried his ratios to AA, he at least has a future somewhere.   6. Daniel Haigwood, SP (Age 22) 1-1, 2.61 ERA, 20 2/3 IP, 17 H, 6 ER, 0 HR, 17 BB, 17 Ks (AA)   Seventeen walks?! Ouch. Haigwood's other numbers are very good, but that is a serious red flag. It could be a sample size issue, or an indication of something lurking underneath. We need more data here.   7. Welinson Baez, 3B/SS (Age 21) .250/.241/.393, 1 HR, 8 RBIs, 0 SB (A)   Yes, Baez's on base percentage is lower than his batting average. He has not drawn a walk in 56 at bats, while striking out 16 times. Baez has tools and had a great year last year after three shots at the Gulf Coast League. I am pessimistic at this point. Baez was a league repeater and lacks plate discipline. He's still got time though.   8. Mike Costanzo, 3B (Age 22) .263/.310/.450, 3 HRs, 12 RBIs, 0 SB (A+)   Costanzo's numbers are slightly low, but given that it is less than a month in and the Florida State League is a tough hitters' league, it is not a serious problem just yet. Costanzo led Division I baseball in walks last year, so I do not think his plate discipline is an issue.   9. Brad Harman, SS/2B (Age 20) .217/.286/.261, 0 HRs, 6 RBIs, 2 SBs (A+)   Harman had a great series in the World Baseball Classic for Australia, but has struggled mightily in the Florida State League. The walks are there, I think this is just a case of a slow start.   10. Jason Jaramillo, C (Age 23) .250/.328/.385, 0 HR, 5 RBIs, 0 SB (AA)   The Phillies' Great White Hope behind the plate. The Phils' skipped a level for Jaramillo, and he's held his own so far in Reading. Considering his primary asset is his defense, this is certainly encouraging.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Phillies Prospect Retro: 1998

Ten years ago, Baseball America started listing top prospects by team. The Phillies at the time had a weak system, and BA chose reliever Ryan Brannan as the Phillies' top prospect. Brannan never reached the major leagues. Over ten years have passed, so now it is apparent whether any of the Phillies' farm products at the time became successes or failures. Looking back, could any of their players made better picks as top prospects? I drew up a list of the top ten based on current career win shares. Players in the organization as of January 1, 1998 and claimed rookie eligibility status.   1. Jimmy Rollins, SS (18 years old) Sally League: 270/332/370, 46 stolen bases   Impressive second year, as Rollins displayed a bit of pop, plate discipline, lots of speed. A shortstop who happened to be one of the youngest players in the league AND exceeded the league OPS is certainly a top prospect.   2. Randy Wolf, LHP (20 years old) NY-Penn League: 4-0, 1.57 ERA, 40 IP, 8 BBs, 53 K's.   Wolf was the Phillies' second round pick in the 1997 draft. It is hard to put a lot of stock in 40 innings. Michael Cisco would qualify as a top prospect under the same criteria. It would be interesting to go back and read scouting reports on this one.   3. Marlon Anderson, 2B (23 years old) Eastern League: 266/318/374, 27 steals in 42 attempts.   Those numbers are hardly impressive at all. Low average, little power, high caught stealing rate. Anderson would explode for 62 extra base hits the next year in AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. Anderson spent a couple years playing second base for the Phillies before settling in as a valuable spare part for the New York Mets.   4. Desi Relaford, SS (23 years old) International League: 267/323/400, 29 steals.   You want a higher batting average, but that's not bad from a 23 year old SS in AAA. Relaford bombed as a starter though in 1998. Relaford got mileage out of a career as a utility infielder. His placement on the list is due to longevity rather than real ability.   5. Johnny Estrada, C (21 years old) NY-Penn League: 314/341/489.   223 at bats, 9 walks and 15 strikeouts? How do you evaluate a player like that? Estrada never got his OBP up. He reached the Majors in 2001 thanks to an injury to Mike Lieberthal, but was terrible. He had a solid year with the Braves in 2004, but otherwise he was a poor hitter. A player like this lives and dies on his batting average and when you do that, it better be closer to .320-.330.[/i]   6. Carlos Silva, RHP (18 years old) Appy League: 2-2, 5.12 ERA, 58 IP, 14 BBs, 31 K's.   Home run rates are unavailable, so I don't know if Silva's ground ball tendencies were readily apparent. While Silva crashed and burned in 2008, he's had a fine career thus far as a starting pitcher.   7. Adam Eaton, RHP (19 years old) Sally League: 5-6, 4.18 ERA, 71 IP, 30 BBs, 57 K's.   Nothing in the stat line really stands out. The Phillies packaged Eaton to the Padres for Alan Ashby before the 2000 season. Eaton had a 4.13 ERA in 2000 and since then has NEVER posted a better than average ERA in a season of any length.   8. Bobby Estalella, C (22 years old) International League: 233/321/418   A beast. Estalella had power to spare, and was built like a truck. Unfortunately he had yet to hit for an acceptable average. Estalella exploded the following season in Scranton, posting a .993 OPS in 76 games. Estalella hit just .216 though in 904 MLB at bats.   9. Wayne Gomes, RHP (24 years old) International League: 38 IP, 24 BB's, 36 K's, 2.37 ERA MLB: 42.7 IP, 24 BBs, 24 K's, 5.27 ERA   How the heck did this guy ever come around with those peripherals. Gomes had three decent seasons from 1998-2000, before losing effectiveness.   10. Derrick Turnbow, RHP (19 years old) Appy League: 24 IP, 16 BB, 7 K's, 7.50 ERA.   Wow. Turnbow found his stuff for one good season in Milwaukee, but otherwise he had extreme control issues his entire career.   I think Rollins and Wolf were obvious talents at the time. The rest are generally a collection of journeymen who had lengthy careers as reserves. In retrospect, Rollins probably should have been the number one prospect.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Phillies Pharm Report, Part Two

Rather than bury this in an old discussion, I figured I would start anew.     Let me reexamine the top 10 as ranked by Baseball America before the season and then I'll hit on the other prospects Pinjockey discusses.   1. Cole Hamels, SP   Cole Hamels had an extraordinary ascent through the minors before struggling at the Major League level. He's struck out a batter an inning though, and control was usually not a problem in the minors. The big thing is that Hamels has reached a career high in innings pitched. Hamels is still on track.   2. Gio Gonzalez,SP   112 strikeouts in under 100 innings for a 20 year old in AA is highly impressive. The home runs as Pinjockey said are high, but Reading's a fairly good home run park. He'd cut that in half in Scranton. Gonzalez needs to cut down on the walks, but he's another top flight prospect still on target.   3. Greg Golson, OF   The best athlete in the system. That would be even more impressive if he could play baseball. This is Golson's second year at Lakewood and he still can't hit. .220 batting average with 92 Ks against 18 walks. Until Golson actually produces, he's not a prospect in my view.   4. Michael Bourn, OF   Bourn's made a hell of an impression in Scranton, hitting three triples, stealing bases and playing great defense, all in his first week. I think he'll cool off as word of his weaknesses gets around. Bourn has great speed and plate discipline. The problem is that he lacks power, and pitchers will challenge him and defenses will play shallow. There's a fine line between great leadoff hitter and Jason Tyner. I think Bourn at minimum is a good 5th outfielder.   5. Scott Mathieson, SP   I don't think the Phils could have asked for a better season so far. Mathieson dominated AA, went to the majors and held his own, and just made a good start at Scranton. He's still just 22, and his fastball sits in the mid-90s. This is a big IF, but imagine a rotation of Brett Myers (25), Ryan Madson (25), Gavin Floyd (23), Cole Hamels (22), Scott Mathieson (22) and Gio Gonzalez (20). That's a ton of young pitching, and I don't think most fans realize how much the Phils have.   6. Dan Haigwood, SP   Traded to Texas for P Fabio Castro.   7. Welinson Baez, 3B   Baez finally hit on his third trip through Rookie ball and kept it up through Short Season A last year. It was a fluke. Baez is hitting .216 in Lakewood with 111 strikeouts in 287 at bats. Not a prospect at this point.   8. Mike Costanzo, 3B   Mike at least has the excuse of skipping a level. He walks, but that's about it. I doubt Costanzo's got much potential.   9. Brad Harman, SS   Harman drew good reviews as part of Australia's entry into the WBC. His power dropped off a cliff though, and he does not look like much. Harman's young though, and given that the FSL is a pitchers' league I would give Harman another season before writing him off.   10. Jason Jaramillo, C   Jaramillo's struggled this year, but given that he skipped high A and that he's a better defensive catcher, it's not as bad as it looks. Jaramillo's probably at least got a future as a backup.   Early reports on Edgar Garcia are encouraging to a point, particularly the 19/1 K:BB ratio. The low K rate worries me slightly, but he is extremely young yet. Jeremy Slayden is a few months younger than Josh Kroeger. Kroeger's in AAA, Slayden's in Low A. Slayden would have to be a hell of a hitter to make up the difference in levels. He's not a prospect. Carlos Carrasco is having an extremely impressive season, and has easily moved into the Phillies' top ten.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Top 25 Phillies, Via Win Shares

Eight years ago, Bill James produced his book on win shares. In that book, he listed each franchise's top 25 players by that statistic. In the ensuing period, the Phillies have had a run of success, finishing above .500 nearly every season and winning back to back division titles for only the second time in franchise history. With the club now producing several franchise players, I thought it might be worth updating the list.   1. Mike Schmidt (467) 2. Ed Delahanty (365) 3. Richie Ashburn (289) 4. Robin Roberts (277) 5. Steve Carlton (276) 6. Sherry Magee (274) 7. Bobby Abreu (247) 8. Pete Alexander (238) 9. Roy Thomas (233) 10. Del Ennis (215) 11. Dick Allen (211) 12. Johnny Callison (209) t-13. Gavvy Cravath (188) t-13. Chuck Klein (188) t-15. Jimmy Rollins (184) t-15. Greg Luzinski (184) 17. Willie Jones (179) 18. John Titus (177) 19. Cy Williams (176) 20. Sam Thompson (166) 21. Billy Hamilton (165) 22. Pat Burrell (163) t-23. Von Hayes (158) t-23. Fred Luderus (158) 25. Darren Daulton (154)   Chase Utley currently has 126 win shares. He is signed through 2013, and if he maintains his current pace he could begin to challenge that top six. Ryan Howard has 94 win shares. No one else on the team is currently within striking distance. Rollins is under contract through 2011. Again, he could end up with about 260 win shares at the end of his deal.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Phillies Prospects: Top 30 (Final List)

Let's run with this. Some of the rankings might be off by one or two. I'll never be satisfied as a whole, and in general it's impossible to really create a solid list. I just hope to avoid making some stupid mistakes.   1. Carlos Carrasco, RHP A strikeout an inning at AA and AAA, just 21 years old. 2. Jason Donald, SS Gotta love a shortstop who can post a .500+ slugging percentage. 3. Dominic Brown, OF The scouts love him. I'll buy into the hype. 4. Lou Marson, C I have qualms about his power, but it's much easier to go with the flow on this one. 5. Michael Taylor, OF Took a huge jump in one season. 6. Kyle Drabek, RHP Looks great in the Hawai'ian league. Ace potential. 7. Travis D'Arnaud, C 8. Zachary Collier, OF 9. Joe Savery, LHP Bad season, but peripherals weren't terrible. Deserves another look. 10. Jason Knapp, RHP 11. Sebastian Valle, C 12. Vance Worley, RHP 13. J.A. Happ, LHP I'm leary even rating him this high. He walks far too many batters for a pitcher without blow away stuff. 14. John Mayberry Jr., OF Hard to dismiss this kind of power potential. Doesn't strike out as much as you'd think for a player of this profile. 15. Michael Stutes, RHP Statistics are impressive, but really lacks impressive stuff. Even watching him, you think nothing of it and all the sudden, you have 8 K's marked on your scorecard. 16. Antonio Bastardo, LHP Big HR rate in Reading is a red flag. 17. Freddy Galvis, SS Bat is iffy, but I LOVE the defense. This is a guy I want to watch. 18. Julian Sampson, RHP While not striking out batters, extremely low HR rate is a good sign for a young pitcher. Keep an eye on this one as a possible Chien-Ming Wang type. 19. Michael Cisco, RHP Completely under the radar, but posted a 30/0 K:BB ratio as a starter in Lakewood, with no home runs. 20. Drew Naylor, RHP 21. Edgar Garcia, RHP Never impressive, but still very young. 22. Quintin Berry, OF Should make a fifth outfielder someday with his speed. Complete lack of power. 23. Andrew Carpenter, RHP Seemed to recover as the season developed. Thanks to an inning of mopup relief, he's forever a champion. 24. Sergio Escalona, LHP 25. Anthony Hewitt, SS Performance was awful, but there's potential if he can learn to make contact. 26. Anthony Gose, OF 27. Michael Schwimer, RHP 6'8" reliever, posted high strikeout rates in Williamsport and did not allow a single HR. 28. Jeremy Slayden, OF Why on earth has he never been pushed a level? 29. Chance Chapman, RHP Old for Lakewood, but I think he has a future career as a reliever. 30. Brad Harman, 2B/SS Performance was bad, but he's still quite young, plays defense well and has some power. Possibly a utility infielder in the future. He put on a show at the last World Baseball Classic for Australia, and should get another chance this time around.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

More on J.A. Happ

Fans of teams tend to overrate their prospects. Sometimes this reaches absurd levels. I mentioned J.A. Happ in my last entry, and apparently a few amateur prospect watchers weight him highly due to his close proximity to the Majors. Does a high level outweigh potential? What about performance vs. scouting? When I develop a prospect list, I think the correct way to go about it is to view the players as trading chips. If you were trading for a team's top prospects, which ones would you value? (Ignoring positional and team needs and such.)   J.A. Happ led the International League in strikeouts, at the age of 25. For comparisons sake, these are the other starters who have finished top ten in strikeouts at the same age. Brandon Knight, Brandon Duckworth, Travis Harper, Luke Hudson, Eric Junge, Denny Lail, Everett Stull, Tim Rumer, Brad Woodall, John DeSilva, Mike Oquist, Jesse Cross, Dave Telgheder, Josh Hancock, Aaron Heilman, Brian Burres, Virgil Vasquez, J.A. Happ, Jeff Niemann and Chris Lambert. Note any All-Stars on that list? None of them even held a starting pitching job long term. Oquist had the most wins, with 25. To make a pitcher on that level a team's top ten prospect is simply delusional.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

 

Similarity Scores

SS- Jim Fregosi CF- Alex Ochoa 2B- Alfonso Soriano 1B- Norm Cash RF- Leon Roberts LF- Gil Hodges C- Jason Varitek 3B- Billy Ripken P- Brad Radke   What kind of lineup is that? If similiarity scores have merit, it is a similar lineup to one posted by the Philadelphia Phillies down the stretch. Similarity scores seek to compare two players' statistics and measure their comparability. A score of 1000 would indicate two players who are exactly alike. Scores under 900 indicate players who are not very similar. Bill James developed the concept as a way of judging Hall of Fame arguments. Thanks to spreadsheets and computers, statisticians can instantly compare thousands of players to determine which players are MOST comparable. Baseball-Reference.com has taken the concept further, using similarity scores to measure players at specific ages. Miguel Cabrera is currently most comparable to Hideki Matsui. But if you compare him to other players when they were 23, Henry Aaron appears at the top of the list (as he has the last three years). This is a good omen for Cabrera's career.   Looking at a list of players comparables can give us an idea of what to expect from a player's career. A player with a lot of All-Stars and Hall of Famers is a good bet to continue to have a Hall of Fame career. Some players might have a mix of HOFers, and guys who flamed out early in their careers. If no players similar to a certain player produced much after that point in their careers, we would expect caution. With that in mind, let's take a look at the 2006 Phillies still under contract, and see what we might find.   Understand that when I look at comparables, I am looking at what they did AFTER the age of the player to that I am comparing. Also, Similarity Scores are NOT era adjusted.   C: Carlos Ruiz. Ruiz has only played 69 games in his career, so there is no comp list available. A list of players who played 69 games at the age of 27 would likely contain plenty of scrubs, but that's not entirely fair. You just can not draw a good list with too little data. The same holds true for fellow catcher Chris Coste. Free agent catcher Mike Lieberthal's best comps are Jason Varitek and Terry Steinbach. On average, Lieberthal's top ten comps played two more reasonably productive seasons.   1B: Ryan Howard. Howard's best comp is Norm Cash, an intriguing choice. Ryan Howard at the age of 26 hit 58 home runs. Norm Cash hit .361 with 41 homers, a huge fluke season later attributed to corked bats. Cash produced well into his late 30s hitting 20-30 home runs a season in an era where that reached the top ten.   2B: Chase Utley. Utley's best comps are Alfonso Soriano, Jeff Kent, Marcus Giles, Vinny Castilla and Pedro Guerrero. All of Utley's comps had huge careers with the exception of Giles, who still has time to rebound from a dismal 2006.   SS: Jimmy Rollins. Rollins' best comps are Jim Fregosi and Alan Trammell. Trammell had a great career. Fregosi flamed out early, but not before the Angels dealt him for Nolan Ryan. Rollins more than any other player has a big boom/bust quotent in his comp list. Along with Ryne Sandberg and Lou Boudreau, it includes weak hitters like Zoilo Versalles, Frankie Crosetti and Granny Hamner.   3B: Abraham Nunez. Nunez's best comp is Billy "F.F." Ripken. Ripken was an awful hitter. The only player on Nunez's list to hit above league average was Dave Anderson, who had 84 at bats left. The Phils desperately need an upgrade here.   LF: Pat Burrell. Burrell's best comp is Gil Hodges, a perennial Hall of Fame candidate. With respect to Hodges, this says more about why he isn't a HOFer. Most of Burrell's comps had 5-7 more years left, hitting about 10% above league average. I doubt that's worth $13.5 Million a season, but the Phils can live with that.   CF: Shane Victorino. Alex Ochoa, a player probably seen as an also-ran but was also a terrific fourth outfielder for a few years. Ochoa played five more years hitting league average. With Victorino's defense, that's a big plus.   RF: Aaron Rowand. Carl Everett. Fortunately this measures production and not attitude. It's difficult to get a read on Rowand's comp list because there are many current players on the list. Most of the others were league average hitters who played 5-6 more years.   SP: Brett Myers. Myers best comp is Brad Radke, who went 94-85 over the next eight seasons. Frank Viola is the best player on Myers' list, Sammy Ellis is the worst. No Hall of Famers, but a few All Stars.   SP: Jon Lieber. Lieber's best comp is Kevin Tapani, a player who finished 9-14 for the 2001 Chicago Cubs and then retired. Second is Shane Reynolds who didn't pitch past 37, third is John Burkett (25-17 over two years), and Charles Nagy (retired). Jamie Moyer is seventh on the list, and no other pitcher lasted more than two more seasons. The Phils only need one more good one.   SP: Cole Hamels. Hamels' best comp is Floyd Bannister, the father of Mets' pitcher Brian. Floyd pitched league average ball for 14 seasons. There are some good pitchers on the list, no real stars, but that's what you get with 23 starts. This list would look better if Hamels improves next year.   CL: Tom Gordon. Gordon's best comp is Charlie Hough, which seems a little. Gordon throws gas and a wicked curve from the bullpen. Hough threw a knuckleball. Gordon started and converted to the bullpen. Hough started as a reliever and converted to starting.

EVIL~! alkeiper

EVIL~! alkeiper

×