This is fair, but that still doesn't make up against the 3 Roy has. He also got one facing off against Brodeur directly, back in 2001. He had a damned 1.70 GAA and a .934 average.
You make great points about Roy, I freely admit that. I'll be honest, part of is that I just don't like the guy.
The Devils have lost Stevens, Neidermayer and Rafalski, and he's still playing great in net. So it's not just his D and the Devils style.