Regarding your box of pens, lets say they are worth 1,000 (they've been worth 1,000 for a while). If someone offers 500, just because that's the most they can offer (the Brewers), that doesn't mean they are worth 500 dollars. The Yankees essentially took out the Angels, Dodgers, and Giants out of the bidding by offering 140 million. I wasn't talking about the Brewers. If you go into a bidding war with those three teams, around the 115-120 range, teams that reside in California where CC is from, it would have not been a smart move for the Yankees. Just because Sabathia got low balled, doesn't mean the Yankees overpaid.