I think the problem was he would state his opinion which was usually against the popular opinion of this forum, and not really support it. Instead he would restort to stating his "credentials", and basically trying to prove he "knows more then us".
That's what got on the nerves of most of the people in the WWE folder. See, even when Truthiness 1st started posting him, and even cabbageboy and DarKnight... Sure they would have opinions that don't agree with the popular opinion here, but they wouldn't act like they know more then us because of some bullshit "credentials".
When he says absolute bullshit like "MVP has no charisma", without really supporting that arguement, when their is plently of evidence of MVP displaying his great charisma in promos and segments etc, it just makes Noah Fentz look like a fool.