I was the same way. Not on re-watching it, but watching it the firt time. I actually thought Orton was going to hit the RKO and get the pin at the end, but then when Hardy reversed it I was like Yes!!
Jeff has been my favourite wrestler since I got into wrestling, as I stated before. (Well, not exactly true.. I used to watch and like Austin, but not on a regular basis.)
The most memorable match of any RAW/SD to me has been the Hardy vs Taker ladder match. I really wish Jeff would have won that. But, maybe he'll get his chance now. It's certainly what the fans seem to want.