Second Shooting Star to the Right is excellent. Fuck the miming, just make the entire CW division the Lost Boys (Neverland, not vampire), and whoever's the champion gets to be Peter Pan. At the same time, get a heavyweight stable who are the pirates, with Paul 'Hook' Burchill as their leader.
Mark Henry can cameo as the guy who eats Burchill's hand, and Mysterio's daughter can be Wendy.