It depends on the scoring system. If passing TDs are equal to rushing/receiving TDs in your league, then Manning is the top QB on the board because of better health and better talent around him then McNabb. Otherwise, he is down at #4 (behind McNabb, Culpepper & Vick) but still more consistant than those guys. I wouldn't get rid of him. I assume you are playing with less than 20 teams since you got 4 guys that should have been drafted in the top 20 (Williams, Henry, Moss & Manning). Tim Brown is finished and Adrian Peterson is going to steal A-Train's job. Everybody else is fine, assuming Boston stays healthy this year.