Steviekick 0 Report post Posted March 2, 2004 Well, after a three month delay, round one is posted. There is no real criteria on this, just vote for who you think is the greater of the two artists until we find the definitive TSM comic book artist. If your not sure of someone, go to images.google.com and type in their name to find some samples. Round one will last till Saturday at Midnight....good luck. Alex Ross (Batman: War On Crime, Marvels, Kingdom Come) vs. David Mazzucelli (Batman: Year One) Mark Bagley (Thunderbolts, Ultimate Spider-Man vs. Kevin Maguire (Jusitce League 80s, FKAJL) Jim Lee (Batman, X-Men) vs. Mike Grell (Grendel) Craig Thompson (Blankets, Goodbye, Chunky Rice) vs. Steve Dillon (Preacher and the second Marvel Knights Punisher mini-series). George Perez (Avengers, Teen Titans, Crisis, some Marvel/DC crossover) vs. Chris Bachalo (Sandman and Generation X) Jack Kirby (Avengers, FF, X-Men, New Gods) vs. Mike Turner (Witchblade and Fathom) Darrick Robertson (New Warriors, Transmetropolitan) vs. Moebius (Silver Surfer LS, Airtight Garage) John Romita, Jr (Amazing Spider-Man, Inc. Hulk): vs. Milo Manara (Click, Butterscoth, Sandman: Endless Nights) Jae Lee (Inhumans, Fantastic 4 1234) vs. Curt Swan (Superman) Mike Deodato (Avengers, Thor, Hulk) vs. Joe Madureira (X-Men, Battle Chasers) Ed McGuiness (Thundercats, Superman) vs. Craig Thompson (Blankets, Goodbye, Chunky Rice) Al Williamson (Flash Gordon, half of the EC library) vs. Barry Windsor-Smith (Conan, Rune) Greg Land (Sojourn) vs. Marc Silvestri (The Darkness) Steve Epting (El Cazador, Crux, Avengers) vs. Tom Grummett (Superboy, Power Company, Robin) Joe Orlando (Tales from teh Crypt) vs. Berni Wrightson (Swamp Thing) Wally Wood (Daredevil, lots of EC stuff) vs. Mark Texiera (mid-90s era Ghost Rider, Wolverine) Frank Quitely (Ultimate X-Men) vs. Frank Miller (Daredevil, The Dark Knight Returns) Jack Kamen (EC and Mad Magazine) vs. Dan Jurgens (Superman) Will Eisner--The Spirit vs. Eduardo Risso--100 Bullets, Batman Mike Kaluta (Vampirella) vs. Neal Adams - X-men, Avengers Steve Ditko - Spider-man, Dr. Strange vs. Michael Gaydos (ALIaS ) Mike Wieringo (Flash, Tellos, Fantastic Four) vs. Jim Steranko (Nick Fury Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D.). Joe Kubert - Hawkman, Sgt. Rock vs. Mark Texiera (mid-90s era Ghost Rider, Wolverine) John Cassaday (Capt. America, Planetary, Desperadoes) vs. John Buscema (Savage Sword of Conan, Silver Surfer) Jim Steranko (Nick Fury Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D.). vs. Todd McFarlane (Spawn, Spider-man) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Steviekick 0 Report post Posted March 2, 2004 my votes.... Alex Ross (Batman: War On Crime, Marvels, Kingdom Come) Kevin Maguire (Jusitce League 80s, FKAJL) Jim Lee (Batman, X-Men) Steve Dillon (Preacher and the second Marvel Knights Punisher mini-series). George Perez (Avengers, Teen Titans, Crisis, some Marvel/DC crossover) Jack Kirby (Avengers, FF, X-Men, New Gods) Moebius (Silver Surfer LS, Airtight Garage) John Romita, Jr (Amazing Spider-Man, Inc. Hulk): Jae Lee (Inhumans, Fantastic 4 1234) Mike Deodato (Avengers, Thor, Hulk) Ed McGuiness (Thundercats, Superman) Barry Windsor-Smith (Conan, Rune) Marc Silvestri (The Darkness) Tom Grummett (Superboy, Power Company, Robin) Berni Wrightson (Swamp Thing) Mark Texiera (mid-90s era Ghost Rider, Wolverine) Frank Miller (Daredevil, The Dark Knight Returns) Dan Jurgens (Superman) Will Eisner--The Spirit Neal Adams - X-men, Avengers Steve Ditko - Spider-man, Dr. Strange Jim Steranko (Nick Fury Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D.). Joe Kubert - Hawkman, Sgt. Rock John Buscema (Savage Sword of Conan, Silver Surfer) Jim Steranko (Nick Fury Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D.) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
starvenger 0 Report post Posted March 2, 2004 I noticed that Craig Thompson, Jim Steranko and Mark Texiera are all on there twice... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Steviekick 0 Report post Posted March 3, 2004 Ah damn it to hell... I fucked up. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
pochorenella 0 Report post Posted March 3, 2004 My votes: Alex Ross (Batman: War On Crime, Marvels, Kingdom Come) Mark Bagley (Thunderbolts, Ultimate Spider-Man Jim Lee (Batman, X-Men) Steve Dillon (Preacher and the second Marvel Knights Punisher mini-series). George Perez (Avengers, Teen Titans, Crisis, some Marvel/DC crossover) Jack Kirby (Avengers, FF, X-Men, New Gods) The king rules all. Darrick Robertson (New Warriors, Transmetropolitan) Don't care for either one John Romita, Jr (Amazing Spider-Man, Inc. Hulk) Jae Lee (Inhumans, Fantastic 4 1234) I hate Swan Joe Madureira (although I really like both guys here) Ed McGuiness (Thundercats, Superman) Barry Windsor-Smith (Conan, Rune) Marc Silvestri (The Darkness) Tom Grummett (Superboy, Power Company, Robin) Joe Orlando (Tales from teh Crypt) vs. Berni Wrightson (Swamp Thing) Don't know either one Wally Wood (Daredevil, lots of EC stuff) Frank Quitely (Ultimate X-Men) Sorry, Miller... Dan Jurgens (Superman) For lack of a better choice... Will Eisner--The Spirit Neal Adams - X-men, Avengers Steve Ditko - Spider-man, Dr. Strange Mike Wieringo (Flash, Tellos, Fantastic Four) I know Steranko is an innovator, but I'm not that familiar with his work, so... Joe Kubert - Hawkman, Sgt. Rock John Buscema (Savage Sword of Conan, Silver Surfer) Todd McFarlane (Spawn, Spider-man) What gives with the repeat nominations? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
brokentusk16 0 Report post Posted March 11, 2004 Alex Ross (Batman: War On Crime, Marvels, Kingdom Come) Mark Bagley (Thunderbolts, Ultimate Spider-Man Jim Lee (Batman, X-Men) Steve Dillon (Preacher and the second Marvel Knights Punisher mini-series). George Perez (Avengers, Teen Titans, Crisis, some Marvel/DC crossover) Jack Kirby (Avengers, FF, X-Men, New Gods) Darrick Robertson (New Warriors, Transmetropolitan) John Romita, Jr (Amazing Spider-Man, Inc. Hulk): Curt Swan (Superman) Joe Madureira (X-Men, Battle Chasers) Ed McGuiness (Thundercats, Superman) Barry Windsor-Smith (Conan, Rune) Greg Land (Sojourn) Tom Grummett (Superboy, Power Company, Robin) Berni Wrightson (Swamp Thing) Wally Wood (Daredevil, lots of EC stuff) Frank Miller (Daredevil, The Dark Knight Returns) Dan Jurgens (Superman) Eduardo Risso--100 Bullets, Batman Neal Adams - X-men, Avengers Steve Ditko - Spider-man, Dr. Strange Mike Wieringo (Flash, Tellos, Fantastic Four) Joe Kubert - Hawkman, Sgt. Rock John Cassaday (Capt. America, Planetary, Desperadoes) Todd McFarlane (Spawn, Spider-man) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
cynicalprofit 0 Report post Posted March 11, 2004 Alex Ross Hate Mark Bagley personally and dont know the other guy, so no vote. Mike Grell Steve Dillon Chris Bachalo Jack Kirby Moebius Dont like either Romita Jr or Mara, so no vote Jae Lee Joe Madureira Dont know McGuiness or Thmpson so no vote Barry Windsor-Smith Marc Silvestri Dont know Epting or Grummett so no vote Berni Wrightson Mark Texiera Frank Miller Dan Jurgens Will Eisner Neal Adams Steve Ditko Jim Steranko Joe Kubert John Buscema Todd McFarlane Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
