Creatively, I really don't get all of the praise that 2000 is getting. While admittedly, the first few months leading into Mania were pretty good, and the Angle/HHH/Steph love triangle was very well done, for the most part, the actual storylines and shows became dull, predictable and at times flat out stupid. Remember the damn McMahon-Helmsley Fact-gime??? Remember the evil McMahons signing the faces handicap matches and lumberjack matches and table matches week after week after week? The constant screwjobs. A lot of the WWF/E's reliance on backstage skits started in 2000. Now it wasn't by any means a bad year (certainly a lot better than what we've been getting since), but I wouldn't look upon it as some golden age that we need to return to.
That said, it would be best if they had a writer who had some knowledge of wrestling and how things work.