I think Liverpool deserved it. Gudjohnsen's miss and the low shot that Dudek saved with were the only chances Chelsea made, with Liverpool's tackling spot on from start to finish. I also think the goal crossed the line. Just. They had the worst angles, Gallas' leg was at full stretch over the line when he kicked it, and Carvalho's position was the only thing making it tricky to judge. Props to Cisse for shaving a beanie hat onto his head.