I wonder about Roy Halladay every once in a while.  I think getting hurt the past 2 seasons could eventually hurt his chances, especially since breaking his leg last year might have cost him a 2nd Cy Young award if he had kept pitching as well as he had in the first half of the season. 
  
Throwing out '04, he's been one of the best pitchers in the league since 2002 (his '02 numbers are probably nicer than his '03 season, too, minues the walks), dominant for stretches, plus he's 'old school' and throws a lot of complete games for this era, so some voters might like that. 
  
I know it's hard to tell this early, but it's something I spend some time thinking about. 
  
I apologize if this is rambling, but I just got home from work and really need to go to sleep.