With my next pick, I'm getting a little beastly...
Bob Sapp
He's ridiculously charismatic, has an impressive look and is legitimately tough. I'd book him as one of my top faces, kind of like Hogan/Warrior/Sting were used. Plus, when needed, he can do comedy and it wouldn't hurt his character. He would be my mainstream crossover character and we would make a killing on merchandising.