Peyton may have good (even great) regular season stats, but let's look at his postseason stats now:
'99 vs. Titans - 19/43 att, 227 yds, no TDs
'00 vs. Dolphins - 17/32 att, 194 yds, 1 TD
'02 vs. Jets - 14/31 att, 137 yds, no TDs, 2 INTs
I will continue to state that until Manning wins a big game (or rather, several big games, like the big one) that he's an overrated QB who gets a lot of media time because he's an "aw shucks" pretty southern boy