Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

This is a topic that I started over at the WC message board almost a year ago, and it ended up being a huge discussion, and a very long topic. I found it very interesting what everyone had to say on everything that was talked about in the thread, and so I thought I'd post it here also to see what you guys have to say about it. Consider this just a starting point, not all of my thoughts on this, as it obviously isn't. The following is simply meant to begin the dicussion, and we'll all go from there. So here we go, the following is my original (albeit short) topic.

 

I recently entered a discussion with someone, and it began with a Hulk Hogan quote. He said that Flair was one of the greatest WORKERS of all time, but not wrestlers. I said I agree with Hogan, and the comments began. Here is my thinking...

 

...Ric Flair is simply great, in every way in my eyes. In my view, he is the greatest all around worker in the history of Pro. Wrestling. From character, to in ring work, to charisma, mic work, and everything else. I do NOT however see him as the greatest WRESTLER. WORKER yes, but not wrestler.

 

So, in your view, is Flair the greatest worker, wrestler, or neither, of all time?

 

Sincerely,

...Downhome...

  • Replies 275
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Guest Salacious Crumb
Posted

Flair is a good wrestler but that's not what makes him one of the greats.

 

What made Flair great was you could have him feud with the most boring sack of crap and he could make it interesting. Flair is the only guy that ever made Ronnie Garvin and Lex Luger interesting. You could give him the worst material and he could somehow make it work.

 

Even today he still manages to work magic on occasion. He's the only non-Kliq member to get a watchable match out of post-quad Triple H.

Guest Goodear
Posted

Flair is quite obviously not the best wrestler in history as Hogan defined it in that interview. There, Hulk was talking more about actual wrestling as a competition which would obviously not be up Flair's alley especially with Olympic and national amateur wrestlers on the roster.

 

As far as the complete package that goes into a worker as far as charisma coupled with the in ring action, I would have to place Flair extremely high although probably not at the top. Being more charismatic than the Harts or Steamboat and a better worker than the Hogans and Rocks of the world... I might but Flair in the top two behind Austin.

Guest Salacious Crumb
Posted

I would disagree with Austin b/c he never really had to carry the sorry loads like Flair did.

Posted

Very few guys and matches (for me anyway) have this thing which stands out from the rest. Emotion.

 

Ric Flair, Bret Hart and Chris Benoit today are the only guys who's emotions in the ring came out through their work for me. They made me care. Sometimes you have to stop thinking about what makes a good match. Stop trying to come up with points and stars and run off the emotion of the match.

 

Matches that have pulled me into the match and forget everything else.

 

Flair Vs Steamboat Clash 6

 

Bret Vs Perfect Summerslam 91

 

Bret Vs Austin Survivor Series 96

 

Benoit Vs Angle RR03

 

Just to name a few.

Posted

It's hard to make this determination for the simple fact that none of us has ever seem every wrestler/worker to ever set foot in the ring. But considering all the people that Ric Flair made look credible over his career, he's certainly one of the best workers I ever saw. Hell, he took on George South on WTBS in 1988 and had the crowd buying that South might pull off the upset, and South never won a match outside of the PWF in the Carolinas that I ever saw.

Posted
I've seen better.

Before I head out for the rest of the day, I'm currious as to who you would name as both "Best Overall Worker" and "Best Wrestler", both of all time. I know you dislike Flair, so who are the guys that you truly love to watch.

 

Not just now, as I said, but throughout the years.

Posted

I don't dislike Flair. Infact, I like Flair very much. I just hate Flair Marks who think he is the unquestioned lordgod of the ring when I wouldn't even put him in my top 10. If I had a choice to watch a flair match, or a match of the following, I would pick the following without a second thought...

 

-Benoit

-Guerrero

-Misawa

-Kawada

-Kobashi

-Jumbo

-Hansen

-Hogan

-Vader

-Takada

-Lyger

-Hart

-Austin

ah hell, lets throw some indy guys in there too..

-American Dragon

-Low Ki

-AJ Styles

Posted

Define worker and wrestler or else this discussion is useless.

 

I view worker and wrestler as characteristics in the same.

 

Flair is praised for having so many great matches. Here is a list of wrestlers who had just as many great matches that were in most cases better than 95% of Flair's best matches.

 

Mitsuharu Misawa

Toshiaki Kawada

Kenta Kobashi (just look at how his 1993 was better than any 3 years of Flair's combined)

Jushin Liger

Nobuhiko Takada

Akira Hokuto

Minami Toyota

Aja Kong

Volk Han

 

So no, as much as I like Flair, he doesn't come close to the above wrestlers in terms of the quality and substance in matches.

 

Tim

Posted
I don't dislike Flair. Infact, I like Flair very much. I just hate Flair Marks who think he is the unquestioned lordgod of the ring when I wouldn't even put him in my top 10. If I had a choice to watch a flair match, or a match of the following, I would pick the following without a second thought...

 

-Benoit

-Guerrero

-Misawa

-Kawada

-Kobashi

-Jumbo

-Hansen

-Hogan

-Vader

-Takada

-Lyger

-Hart

-Austin

ah hell, lets throw some indy guys in there too..

-American Dragon

-Low Ki

-AJ Styles

*double blinks*

 

You would rather watch a Hogan match than a Flair match?

 

YOU, the guy who ragged on me for months for sticking up with the WWE product?

 

*gasp*

Posted
I've seen better.

 

Before I head out for the rest of the day, I'm currious as to who you would name as both "Best Overall Worker" and "Best Wrestler", both of all time. I know you dislike Flair, so who are the guys that you truly love to watch.

 

Not just now, as I said, but throughout the years.

 

 

I agree with Rudo, i've seen better. As for whom, I've stated many a time that I feel the greatest in-ring worker of all time is Tom 'Dynamite Kid' Billington and the greatest in-ring worker today is Chris Benoit. However, my favourite wrestler *OVERALL* is without a doubt, Rob Van Dam.

Guest Salacious Crumb
Posted

Rudo,

 

I like AJ and everything but he's had some real clunkers as the NWA Champ.

Posted

Also, to clarify, by best WRESTLER I mean in-ring skill alone, his wrestling talent and everything. When I say best WORKER, I'm talking about all aspects that make someone a Pro. Wrestler, both in ring and out.

 

I'll be honest, there are guys that I'd rather watch a match of than Ric Flair, but when I sit back and think about who I'd rather watch over and over, both in ring and out, I can't come to the conclusion for anyone other than Flair.

Guest commie_050
Posted

I'm no Flair mark (I'd take Austin or Foley any day of the week)

 

And I loved the Hogan DVD

 

But ... shit.

Posted

I don't know why wrestlers have to be broken up into "American" and "Japanese" since the Japanese style has been heavily influenced by the American, and vice-versa. Only in non-traditional promotions like UWF-i or Pancrase, I can see the issue being made, since they have different rules and standards for a match.

Posted
I don't know why wrestlers have to be broken up into "American" and "Japanese" since the Japanese style has been heavily influenced by the American, and vice-versa. Only in non-traditional promotions like UWF-i or Pancrase, I can see the issue being made, since they have different rules and standards for a match.

They don't have to be, I simply like to hear what certain people think of both groups, US and Japanese. You can't doubt that there is a huge difference in the style in many cases between the two.

 

It's just, when someone lists all Japanese wrestlers, I'm just currious as to who they enjoy in the states, that's all.

 

*still shocked*

Guest ligerbomb03
Posted

Chris Benoit

Dynamite Kid

Kenta Kobashi

Mitsuharu Misawa

Toshiaki Kawada

Jushin Liger

Eddie Guerrero

Jumbo Tsuruta (RIP)

Posted

Seeing a few of you mention Tom Billington puts a huge ass smile on my face.

 

I don't care what any of you here say, but I'M the biggest DK mark here. I could watch his matches and never tire of them.

Posted

Why are you shocked - I'm pretty sure I've stated my Hogan Mark tendancies on this board a few times....

 

I don't see a lot of style differences with the "big" promotions in Japan. I found the transition quite easily into All Japan style since the pacing was similar to Hogans matches and the slow build wasn't an issue. Maybe promotions like Toryumon and Mich Pro where its more Lucha-based, but even then that's not a huge leap as say, Lucha Libre is.

 

If you want a reference, why don't you just say "who do you like in the WWE or WCW?"

Posted
If you want a reference, why don't you just say "who do you like in the WWE or WCW?"

As I said, when I see someone ONLY mention Japanese wrestlers, I'm just currious as to who they like in the States, that's all.

Posted

Flair is one of the better wrestlers and one of the best workers, but in no way or how is he the greatest.

 

Wrestlers- I would have to go with Bret Hart and Chris Benoit. Benoit had the ability to carry everyone to a watchable match and Hart too.

 

Workers- Austin and Hogan. They were able to get the crowd cheering wildly at any given moment. The Rock is close behind them.

Guest Salacious Crumb
Posted

Bret Hart will never be the greatest b/c he dogged it when the cameras weren't on.

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...