With my next pick, I'm taking Sweet N Sour Larry Sweeney
Why Sweeney?
As seen in ROH, IWA and the other 2000 era indies, the dude is ridiculously oozing in charisma and talent. He is a great tweener; even when he's being his most dastardly heelish, he's too damn entertaining that he can't not be cheered.
In ring style wise, he would fit in fine with my roster. As far as I'm concerned, he's really a steal, because I can not only use him in the ring, but as a manager, talk show segment host and as a commentator.
12 large, brother. 12 large.