Seeing them live two weeks ago, I preferred Romeo since he just seems to be a more natural cocky heel. Like when the Heart Throbs played 'rock, paper, scissors' to see who started first. Antonio lost, so he started against Rosey. While he was on the apron before the bell rang, Romeo just casually turned to the front row fans (who were talking about this) and said "Dude, paper covers rock" like they were his friends or something.
He just seemed to be having a lot more fun than Antonio was. His charisma isn't forced, like Antonio's 'I am actually Brian Christopher' exagerrated heelishness.
Oh, and he had a better rental car. I wonder if he had to pay extra for those rims, though...