As far as what I've seen of straight up wrestling matches that have no gimmicks, no idiots letting a nut job do it, no managers etc, I would put Muta, Eddie, and Jericho on the same level. Everything else would come in second I think. This is only counting badly done, or plain goofy blades.
The funnest one I've ever seen is still Corino's blood = art supply match against Jerry Lynn. That was some creative use of a gimmick.