Guest Choken One Posted August 10, 2003 Report Posted August 10, 2003 Any reason for your belief or are you just starting a random topic for no reason? My thoughts... If *Candiate X* has lived and been a Naturalized Citizen of America for 15+ years...I say he is every bit as american as the rest of us...He/She paid taxes just like us folks do... Just because he/she was born in another country shouldn't prevent her from seeking office like any other white, blood sucking American-Born politician... It's 2003. If America is supposedly the land of the Free and the home of equal Rights and Opportunity...then we shouldn't prevent equally qulified potential Candidates to run for office.
bob_barron Posted August 10, 2003 Report Posted August 10, 2003 My answer is No. Why not- my uncle was born Israel but moved to the US when he was 1. He's lived here for 50+ years. And because of that he shouldn't be president?
Guest JMA Posted August 10, 2003 Report Posted August 10, 2003 I don't see how not being born on American soil makes someone who has lived here awhile any less American. I vote "yes."
Vern Gagne Posted August 10, 2003 Author Report Posted August 10, 2003 Any reason for your belief or are you just starting a random topic for no reason? My thoughts... If *Candiate X* has lived and been a Naturalized Citizen of America for 15+ years...I say he is every bit as american as the rest of us...He/She paid taxes just like us folks do... Just because he/she was born in another country shouldn't prevent her from seeking office like any other white, blood sucking American-Born politician... It's 2003. If America is supposedly the land of the Free and the home of equal Rights and Opportunity...then we shouldn't prevent equally qulified potential Candidates to run for office. I didn't feel like going into detail, on my first post. Bob's Uncle is more understandable. I have questions about adults who move here. It's if fine they become citizens, and support this country, but to me it isn't the same as being a U.S. born citizen. They may still have strong feelings for their native countries. That's just not something, I want the President or Vice President to have.
Guest Fallen Angel Posted August 10, 2003 Report Posted August 10, 2003 *gets wishy-washy* I can totally understand both sides. While I'm sure the majority of naturalized immigrants are decent, hard-working people who love America, you have to wonder if some, once in the position of power, wouldn't allow their ties to their former homeland to affect foreign policy and whatnot. Domestic policy, as well, I suppose. I don't know -- I don't see it as a big enough deal. With the millions of jobs a man or woman can take in this nation, I fail to see how keeping one or two off-limits is so grave. And for record, I'd have no problem with a naturalized immigrant holding high office. Just not the highest.
Guest JMA Posted August 10, 2003 Report Posted August 10, 2003 Does it really matter if they have feelings for their native country? As long as they have America's best interests at heart I'd be cool with it. Hell, it might even make international relations better. Keyword is "might."
Firestarter Posted August 10, 2003 Report Posted August 10, 2003 Does it really matter if they have feelings for their native country? Yes.
Guest JMA Posted August 10, 2003 Report Posted August 10, 2003 Yes. I don't mean them being nationalistic, just liking their country. Like I said, as long as they would have America's best interests at heart.
Guest JMA Posted August 10, 2003 Report Posted August 10, 2003 And yes, I fully realize the possibility of the foreign President being biased toward his own country.
Guest Fallen Angel Posted August 10, 2003 Report Posted August 10, 2003 Therein lies the problem. Have you ever been tempted? If so, you know sometimes, some temptations are hard to resist. The President in only human, and the law should account for that.
kkktookmybabyaway Posted August 10, 2003 Report Posted August 10, 2003 I voted “no” because I’m a big ol’ xenophobe…
Corey_Lazarus Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 I voted "yes" because I don't really care where they're from if they do a good job.
Guest Choken One Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 I doubt America will vote for some one from a Middle Eastern nation...
Dr. Tyler; Captain America Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 I don't think I like the idea, unless they were born overseas because their parents were in the military.
Guest Choken One Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 Or if they were the Ambassador to Korea's Son or something?
Dr. Tyler; Captain America Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 Well, technically, that would mean they're born on American soil.
Downhome Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 I vote yes. By keeping people from doing so, we may be hurting our country more than helping it. I say have some sort of rule where you must live here for 15-20 years, and then after that, it's game.
Vern Gagne Posted August 11, 2003 Author Report Posted August 11, 2003 Well, technically, that would mean they're born on American soil. If he means the Korean ambassador to the U.S., their children are not citizens.
NoCalMike Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 azif half our elected leaders don't have feelings towards certain countries for certain reasons.
Guest HBK16 Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 I said yes. My view on politics isnt too strong but the reason I voted yes is because I was born in Argentina and I would like to see an Argentinian president....Actually I wouldnt.
rising up out of the back seat-nuh Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 Does it really matter if they have feelings for their native country? Yes. If someone can do a good, impartial job, then it doesn't matter whether he is biased towards a country or not. Do you think Bush wasn't biased towards Saddam and Iraq after his dad went to war with them? Ultimately, I don't think Americans would ever elect a remotely non-American president anyhow. By the way, I said yes
Jobber of the Week Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 How many other countries allow something like that, is what I'm wondering.
Guest MikeSC Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 My answer is No. Why not- my uncle was born Israel but moved to the US when he was 1. He's lived here for 50+ years. And because of that he shouldn't be president? Because then you can have a person who has been a citizen for 2 months running for President. The gov't has the right to set up WHATEVER criteria they wish for a candidate. Heck, why must somebody be 35? -=Mike --- You have to draw a line SOMEWHERE, kids.
Guest MikeSC Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 Yes. I don't mean them being nationalistic, just liking their country. Like I said, as long as they would have America's best interests at heart. If you have affection for your "home" country --- America will never be the #1 concern. -=Mike
Dr. Tyler; Captain America Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 Affection is different from nationalism. You can still have fond memories about your home country while loving America more. Regardless, I'm against it because as Jobber said, it's not like we're bucking precedent here.
Guest TheZsaszHorsemen Posted August 11, 2003 Report Posted August 11, 2003 It really depends on the man himself, doesn't it?
Recommended Posts
Please sign in to comment
You will be able to leave a comment after signing in
Sign In Now