Gary Floyd Posted April 13, 2005 Report Posted April 13, 2005 I feel bad for posting this for some reason http://scottkeith.ytmnd.com/
Jericholic82 Posted April 14, 2005 Report Posted April 14, 2005 When did everyone start hating SK? I know hes annoying sometimes but lately especially here no one likes him. Yea hes goofy looking and uses dumb phrases in his reviews, but hes usually pretty good when it comes to reviewing a show and recommending it. Even if he does use weird canadian humor that nearly 90 percent of the readers dont get. ah forget it, I hate that useless stupid moron.
Placebo Effect Posted April 15, 2005 Report Posted April 15, 2005 Because half the people on this board wish they were a well known wrestling columnist with a book deal.
Some Guy Posted April 15, 2005 Report Posted April 15, 2005 When did everyone start hating SK? I know hes annoying sometimes but lately especially here no one likes him. Yea hes goofy looking and uses dumb phrases in his reviews, but hes usually pretty good when it comes to reviewing a show and recommending it. Even if he does use weird canadian humor that nearly 90 percent of the readers dont get. ah forget it, I hate that useless stupid moron. I used to really like his reviews and thought he was pretty funny and informed. I;ve since found people funnier and more informed to read. I still skim through his reviews because he occasionally gets a good quip in and I'm pretty familiar with how rates things so I know what I'm going to get. That sais he does pan good matches just because he doesn't like one or more of the particpants. He gave JBL/Eddy from Judgement Day 2 stars I think and said that without the blade it was worse. That was an awesome match with incredible intensity and near perfect execution (there was a blown spot and Eddy didn't sell the table bump hardly at all). Tim Cooke called him on it at his blog and gave a very detailed review of the match and SK's response was to call Cooke a "kook" and let his mutants rip on Tim. He can be good at times but he has allowed his hatred of certain people to affect his credibility as a reviewer.
Mole Posted April 15, 2005 Report Posted April 15, 2005 Did you think Scott could get a hot girl? I like the guy and all, but he is an ugly SOB. Of course he is going to get an ugly bitch.
Black Lushus Posted April 15, 2005 Report Posted April 15, 2005 I've asked the same things before, you know, pertaining to the Scott Keith hate...it has something to with him being a huge dick when he ran this forum a few years back...a mod of admin. can elaborate more on that than I can...
Murmuring Beast Posted April 15, 2005 Report Posted April 15, 2005 Keith's not that bad looking to be honest.
iggymcfly Posted April 15, 2005 Report Posted April 15, 2005 I feel bad for posting this for some reason http://scottkeith.ytmnd.com/ I have to say this is definitely one of the funnier ytmnd things I've seen. And by one of the funnier, I mean I think most of them are retarded and this made me laugh out loud for a good 15 seconds. And it's kinda funny to see what a fatass he is; I always used to have this picture in my head of this little skinny guy sitting in front of a computer.
Jingus Posted April 15, 2005 Report Posted April 15, 2005 I've asked the same things before, you know, pertaining to the Scott Keith hate...it has something to with him being a huge dick when he ran this forum a few years back...a mod of admin. can elaborate more on that than I can... Scott ran the site way back when it was called The Smarks kinda like how Dames has run it ever since then. During his reign, he was indeed a huge dick and would ban people for little or no reason. And he basically jumped ship and abandoned the website once he got the gig writing for 411. That's why he still has heat 'round these parts.
Some Guy Posted April 15, 2005 Report Posted April 15, 2005 Keith's not that bad looking to be honest. Did he/she got banned for that post?
Jericholic82 Posted April 16, 2005 Report Posted April 16, 2005 I joined the board in feb 02 right before he left the smarks. So I had no idea he was liek to that members. He has actually replied to a few of my emails in the past and was nice enough to me.
Guest Arnold_OldSchool Posted April 16, 2005 Report Posted April 16, 2005 I feel bad for posting this for some reason http://scottkeith.ytmnd.com/ What's that song! So Catchy!
Bruiser Chong Posted April 16, 2005 Report Posted April 16, 2005 Considering his appearance, I'd say she got the short end of the stick on this one. I'm not one to slam on the guy for no reason, but I don't want to envision the Bonzo Gonzo that goes on in that bedroom.
Guest jumpingbombangel Posted April 16, 2005 Report Posted April 16, 2005 They had to have met on the internet.
Guest Ransome Posted April 16, 2005 Report Posted April 16, 2005 I used to really like his reviews and thought he was pretty funny and informed. I;ve since found people funnier and more informed to read. I still skim through his reviews because he occasionally gets a good quip in and I'm pretty familiar with how rates things so I know what I'm going to get. That sais he does pan good matches just because he doesn't like one or more of the particpants. He gave JBL/Eddy from Judgement Day 2 stars I think and said that without the blade it was worse. That was an awesome match with incredible intensity and near perfect execution (there was a blown spot and Eddy didn't sell the table bump hardly at all). Tim Cooke called him on it at his blog and gave a very detailed review of the match and SK's response was to call Cooke a "kook" and let his mutants rip on Tim. He can be good at times but he has allowed his hatred of certain people to affect his credibility as a reviewer. I agree, although I tend to continue to read his reviews if only for the fact that all of his other reviews of past PPVs/TV shows can be found on the Internet, so theres an easy basis for comparison with his opinions on older matches. When, say, some guy (pardon the pun) on this board posts 'Great match, ***½ stars', it's a little hard to judge what that means when you don't know their standards or how they rate similar past matches.
iggymcfly Posted April 16, 2005 Report Posted April 16, 2005 Yeah, honestly, whenever I want to check out how good a match was, I usually just check out the SK rants for a close standard. He's never off more than one star either way. After looking at a picture of him and his girlfriend fiancee though, I can't really say I have respect for him. Just as an aside, I was bored and looked through his blog the other day, and he talked for three paragraphs about how hard it is to make friends with normal people.
Murmuring Beast Posted April 16, 2005 Report Posted April 16, 2005 Keith's not that bad looking to be honest. Did he/she got banned for that post? Hey, don't slag The Keef.
Guest pinnacleofallthingsmanly Posted April 16, 2005 Report Posted April 16, 2005 You guys are wrong for this. You can diss a guy all you want, but talking about his woman is kind of low.
Slayer Posted April 16, 2005 Report Posted April 16, 2005 SK wouldn't look that bad if he 1) dropped some poundage and 2) got a better haircut
Jericholic82 Posted April 16, 2005 Report Posted April 16, 2005 as for his match ratings there all his opiniona dn just becuase you disagree doesnt make him-or you wrong. All of us have differing opinions. If you feel that he lets his personal grudges against some wrestlers affect his rants then I see why you dont want to read his anymore. However we all do that when we talk about matches. We all have biases. Its cool. We're only human after all.
JST Posted April 16, 2005 Report Posted April 16, 2005 Eh, so Jabba The Scott is happy. I don't judge.
Recommended Posts
Please sign in to comment
You will be able to leave a comment after signing in
Sign In Now