The thing is, Belfour has been great. He's currently 5th all-time in career wins, and has the potential to finish his career in 2nd place (he's at 419, Terry Sawchuk had 447), will probably finish up in the top 10 in career shutouts (he's #11 right now with 69, just 2 behind #10), and has 2 Vezinas and a Stanley Cup (which is more important as a goalie, IMO, since 9 times out of 10 he's the most important player on the ice, especially in the playoffs). Aside from Roy, Brodeur, and Hasek, he's the best goalie of his generation.
I'd put Sakic and Jagr in ahead of Forsberg and Neely. Neely was a great player, no doubt, but he was injured a lot. I wouldn't complain if he made it, since he deserves it, but Jagr dominated the league for years, led the NHL in scoring 5 times, and was the MVP. If he's not in, it's hard to make a case for anyone else from this era. As for Sakic, I think he deserves some advantage for being the captain of a dominant team and being relatively healthy through his career, while Forsberg has had trouble staying healthy for the past few years. If both retired tomorrow, I'd put Sakic ahead of Forsberg. Other than that, I agree with your locks.