Finlay vs. Rey on Smackdown a few weeks ago is my current MOTY. Probably not the most popular pick at the moment, but there ya go. I haven't seen Wrestlemania yet, so I don't know if there are any candidates there. Angle & Undertaker was awesomeness... but finishers were getting killed left and right. It's kinda DVDRish to say it... BUT YOU DON'T COUNTER THE TRIANGLE CHOKE DAMMIT! It was still a great match though. Credit to both men. But Finlay and Rey was just fucking awesomeness to watch. I was there, so maybe I have some bias to it, but it blew away anything I saw at that show and have seen this year. And the ending was perfect in timing and execution. Finlay is the best heel wrestling wise to Rey Mysterio, probably the best face-in-peril in the WWE. It worked so well.
And at this time, I am more entertained by Finlay than Angle. Finlay has the subtle stuff down to a science and he is awesome in his Rudo Dick Heel mode. He just carries himself in that ring better than any other, and sells like a mofo. He made smarks want to see more of Lashley, and at the time, that was a hard thing to do. Finlay's work with with Lashley has made me a Lashley fan!
Kurt Angle can only do so much... and his body is totally falling apart on him. I love him as a worker... but I can't place him over FINLAY~! at this time.
My Top 5
1. Finlay
2. Rey Mysterio
3. Kurt Angle
4. Chris Benoit
5. Jamie BY GOD Noble