I played it at Wal Mart on the X Box (OMG SELLOUT!).
Andy Kaufman vs Jerry Lawler..
KAUFMAN WINS!
About the only positives I got out of it were the roster, which was pretty awesome, and hearing Tony Schiavone, Larry Zbyszko & Bobby "The Brain" Heenan (Felt like I was watching WCW again even though for the most part it was repetitive).
The graphics were OK but having just gotten WM 19 today (for $4.99 at CC) I'd say that its graphics were much better looking. I know theres a style difference between the two but still. Also, I really hated the controls but it was more of an infamiliarity with the X Box controller than anything.
I only played it for about 6 or 7 minutes, but from what I Saw Id say it was probably a wee bit better than LOW2 (which I have for Gamecube). LOW:S isn't coming out for the Gamecube so I dont have to worry about it (I probably would have passed).