AMERICAN IDOl-SEASON 5: THE THREAD

[Yuna_Firerose 0]

Gideon's performance > any of Kevin's.

[C Dubya 04 0]

No way can Kevin ever hope to do anything that would even not be laughed at compared to that.

[Black Lushus 0]

Gedeon losing to Kevin and Bucky was definently a shocker...oh well...not really surprised with the outcome of the female group.

[RavishingRickRudo 0]

It was Gideons shitty painting. Believe that.

[Guest Rrrsh]

Fcking Bullshit on Gideon.

[starvenger 0]

Fuck. I can't believe the dorky kid made the top twelve.

He's got the granny and preteen votes. -shrug- All there is to it, I guess.

He has to have gotten some votes from all the Screeches out there too.

 

Bucky must've been benefitted from from the Kellie fans or something. No way he stays over anyone, including Kevin Arnold. And that goes double for Gedeon. I found the guy kinda creepy, but he at least had more talent than Bucky.

[Mik 0]

I thought Gedeon was a good singer, but he had a creepy "future rapist" personality and I wasn't surprised to see him go.

 

I just read Katherine McPhee's profile on the AI site and all along I thought she was a sweet, hot, nerd girl who could sing well. Well, what I didn't know is that she lives in Los Angeles and if she couldn't be a singer, she would be an actress. -5 points in my book for that.

[Black Lushus 0]

I just read Katherine McPhee's profile on the AI site and all along I thought she was a sweet, hot, nerd girl who could sing well. Well, what I didn't know is that she lives in Los Angeles and if she couldn't be a singer, she would be a porn star. +5 points in my book for that.

 

edited for what I really want to see

[starvenger 0]

I thought Gedeon was a good singer, but he had a creepy "future rapist" personality and I wasn't surprised to see him go.

The Crabman look doesn't work for everybody. Of course, it helps that Darnell looks more respectable than just about everyone else on "My Name is Earl".

 

Well, what I didn't know is that she lives in Los Angeles and if she couldn't be a singer, she would be an actress. -5 points in my book for that.

I've got a casting couch reserved for her...

[Guest SavageRulz]

I was sure Melissa would go before Ayla. Oh well.

 

I'm shocked that Chicken Little remains...I doubt he sticks around for much longer though. I figured Will would be gone, and while I had hoped Gedeon would go, I figured he'd stick around longer than that twit little kid.

 

It was nice seeing Bo sing again.

[chaosrage 0]

Fuck. I can't believe the dorky kid made the top twelve.

He's got the granny and preteen votes. -shrug- All there is to it, I guess.

 

He's got the http://www.votefortheworst.com/ votes too.

[starvenger 0]

Fuck that shit. BUCKY should be the guy votefortheworst is pushing.

[C Dubya 04 0]

Bucky is way better than Kevin.

 

I know I'm the only one here who likes Bucky, but at least he has a style and is good at it.

[The Niggardly King 0]

I just don't like Kevin. He's gotten worse ever since the auditions. He started off as the goofy kid that seemed to have a good potential talent, now I just can't stand to listen to him. Kevin needs a few more years to develope and get rid of that lisp... I'm sure he'd be great in 3 or 4 years, but right now he's not ready. At this point, he's the kid who would get laughed out of a high school talent show.

[Guest Princess Leena]

Kevin is a good singer... but, he's a good singer in the leader of the 8th grade choir group way. He's not ready for AI. I really don't get who's voting for him. But, I guess it's much like what happened with the equally shitty John Stevens... whatever the redhead kid's name was. And he was from Buffalo... so, the shitty radio stations here kept whoring for us to vote for him.

[Guest Princess Leena]

Fuck that shit. BUCKY should be the guy votefortheworst is pushing.

 

Bucky isn't that bad. I admit he's got a good, unique voice. He's just boring as shit unless you really like country.

[starvenger 0]

Kevin is a good singer... but, he's a good singer in the leader of the 8th grade choir group way. He's not ready for AI. I really don't get who's voting for him. But, I guess it's much like what happened with the equally shitty John Stevens... whatever the redhead kid's name was. And he was from Buffalo... so, the shitty radio stations here kept whoring for us to vote for him.

You're in Buffalo, Leena? I'm sorry... especially for our country springing Nicholas Picolas on you.

 

...in all seriousness, get sattellite radio.

[Guest Princess Leena]

Used to be. Moved out of that depressing area 6 months ago.

 

Nicolas Picolas... god, you reminded me of Kiss. Pain. Pain. Pain.

[RavishingRickRudo 0]

Let's let this be the only Nicolas Picolas reference in TSM history.

 

AI is proof that 1)Americans don't like Womens Basketball, and 2)Americans don't like articulate black men.

[The Niggardly King 0]

So who do you guys think will be the final four this year, my picks would be

 

Taylor

Chris

Kellie

Ace

 

Ace will go first, followed by Kellie and the final two shall be Taylor and Chris.

[Guest Princess Leena]

I don't know how the ending works... does it have to be 2 guys and 2 girls?

 

Anyway...

 

Katharine

Kellie

Chris

Ace/Mandisa.

[The Niggardly King 0]

There's something about Ace... I don't know, but he just seems like a potential stalker. Like he has the sweet act going and stuff... but dude just gives off a weird aura. It must be the eyes.

[naiwf 0]

Chris, Elliott, Katharine & Taylor. Ace will be 5th in a "stunner" and Kellie 6th.

 

Leena, there are no gender restrictions from here on out. The 3rd season the final 3 were all women, and the second season the last 2 were guys.

[The Niggardly King 0]

Too bad about Gedeon, but some people couldn't get past his mannerisms once he stopped singing. But I've met guys like that before and most of them are decent people. Gedeon just came across as the guy raised by his God fearing mother and grandmother in this old-fashioned way, but who wouldn't hurt a fly. It's too bad about him.

[starvenger 0]

Used to be. Moved out of that depressing area 6 months ago.

 

Nicolas Picolas... god, you reminded me of Kiss. Pain. Pain. Pain.

Trust me, Houston radio is much worse than what you got in Buffalo...

[Jericholic82 0]

I would have picked gedeon over bucky but alas. And ayla is a better singer potentially than Mellisa IMO but of course dumb blonde goes thru so no space there.

 

Elliot may have a shot at the title if he sticks around

[Guest fanofcoils]

My prediction of the top 12:

 

1. Taylor (should easily beat Chris in the finale)

2. Chris (has potential, unlikable, only 1 great performance, the rest sucked)

3. Kellie (too much charisma)

4. Kevin (the new Scott Savol in longetivity with the help of votefortheworst.com just like his "big bro" Scott)

5. Ace (will coast on his "looks")

6. Paris (lots of charisma though Gideon like hate will prevent her from reaching the top 4/5)

7. Katherine (lack of personality won't get her further)

8. Mandisa (has some charisma but not enough)

9. Elliot (very good voice, ear problem may hinder his "potential", I don't think he has as many fans as the ppl I listed above)

10. Bucky (has charisma but should showcase it each show to help him advance each week)

11. Melissa (decent but probably has more fans than Lisa)

12. Lisa (most likely the fewest amount of fans)

[Guest The Satanic Angel]

At work and can't go running around the internet ... any news on the show tonight? Theme? Who's doing what?

[Black Lushus 0]

At work and can't go running around the internet ... any news on the show tonight? Theme? Who's doing what?

 

oh man...

 

tonight is "Stevie Wonder Songs" night...this will be bad...AMERICAN IDOL CONTESTANTS SUCK AT SINGING STEVIE WONDER SONGS!!!

 

I don't know about inidividual performances...$100 says Elliot does "Lately".

[starvenger 0]

tonight is "Stevie Wonder Songs" night...this will be bad...AMERICAN IDOL CONTESTANTS SUCK AT SINGING STEVIE WONDER SONGS!!!

So very true. And Stevie's gonna be performing on Wednesday as well, which will just underline the suckfest that will ensue.

 

...Who needs Idol haters, when we can do that ourselves?

 

I don't know about inidividual performances...$100 says Elliot does "Lately".

Pretty sure SOMEONE will sing the song.

 

I wonder what the odds that someone will actually venture off the tried-and-true path will be. Rex Goudie sang (well, shouted) "Pasttime Paradise" on Canadian Idol, I could see Chris doing it.

 

Paris is probably singing "Sir Duke" or "Higher Ground".