Jump to content
TSM Forums
Sign in to follow this  
Guest Redhawk

Your ideal MLB playoff scenario

Recommended Posts

Guest Redhawk

Pick any combo you want, unless you can remember which division winner is supposed to play the wild card and all of that. I don't, so here's mine...

 

Oakland (AL West) vs. Boston (wild card)

New York (AL East) vs. Chicago (AL Central)

Chicago (NL Central) vs. Atlanta (NL East)

Florida (wild card) vs. San Fran (NL West)

 

Boston vs. New York

Chicago vs. San Fran

 

New York vs. San Fran

 

San Francisco wins the World Series

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

AL:

Oakland (AL West) defeats Kansas City (AL Central)

Boston (AL East) defeats Seattle (Wildcard)

NL:

Chicago (NL Central) defeats Atlanta (NL East)

Montreal (wild card) defeats San Fran (NL West)

 

LCS:

Oakland defeats Boston

Montreal defeats Chicago

 

World Series:

Montreal defeats Oakland

 

 

Yeah, I wish...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Anglesault

New York vs KC

 

Seattle vs. Boston

 

Atlanta vs. SanFran

 

Philly vs. Chicago

 

New York vs. Boson (Crushing Sox dreams is fun.)

 

Atlanta vs. Chicago

 

New York vs. Atlanta

 

Yankees win.

 

This is ideal. Boston ain't making it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In case anyone cares, the Wild Card team plays the team with the best record unless they are both from the same division. If that were to be the case then the wild card team plays the division winner with the second best record.

 

 

New York vs. KC

Seattle vs. Boston

 

Atlanta vs. L.A.

Cubs vs. Giants

 

 

New York

Boston

 

L.A

Cubs

 

New York

L.A

 

World Series Champs: L.A. Dodgers

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mine would go something like this...

 

Seattle       \
                Seattle  \
Kansas City   /           \
                            Seattle  ---
New York      \           /             |
                Oakland  /              |
Oakland       /                         |
                                        +--- Montreal
Atlanta       \                         |
                Chicago  \              |
Chicago       /           \             |
                            Montreal ---
San Francisco \           /
                Montreal /
Montreal      /

 

Eh, so it didn't come off like I wanted...still legible.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I want the Braves to take over the top spot from the Giants giving

 

Philly/Atlanta (A winable series for the Phils)

SF/St.Louis

 

Yankees/Red Sox

Mariners/Royals

That scenario with those teams would look like this under the existing rules:

 

Giants/Phillies

Braves/Cardinals

 

Yankees/Royals

Mariners/Red Sox

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Braves vs. Cubs

Marlins vs. Giants

 

Yankees vs. A's

Mariners vs. White Sox

 

Braves vs. Marlins (upset special baby)

A's vs. Mariners

 

Marlins vs. A's

 

Marlins... Hey it's plausible. When I did the Marlins wildcard thread they were only 3 games over .500 and look at now...haha. Go Fish!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mulder is pretty much done for the year, which REALLY hurts Oakland's chances of making the playoffs. Therefore(and remember this is my IDEAL scenario)

 

Yankees vs. White Sox

 

Seattle vs. Boston

 

LCS

 

Boston vs. NYY (What baseball fan DOESN'T want this matchup?)

 

NL

 

Braves vs. Astros

 

Giants vs. Cardinals

 

LCS

 

Braves vs. Cardinals

 

WS

 

Boston vs. Braves

 

Winner: Guess ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My ideal playoff scenerio just went out the door with Mark Mulder likely out for the season.

 

I just hope Yankees and Giants die a quick death in the divisonal series but I doubt it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Of course you're all wrong considering none of you have the Twins even making the playoffs. I'm not a Twins fan, but come on, you know there going to get in.

It's your ideal playoff scenario.

 

Seattle over Minnesota

New York over Oakland

 

Seattle over New York

 

Houston over Atlanta (one can hope)

San Fran. over Florida

 

San Fran. over Houston

 

San Fran. over Seattle

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Boston v. Seattle

 

Yanks v. Royals

 

Giants v. Marlins

 

Braves v. Cubs

 

 

Boston v. Yanks

 

Marlins v. Braves

 

 

Boston v. Braves

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Boston vs. NYY (What baseball fan DOESN'T want this matchup?)

Me.

 

Jason

Me too...been there, done that, Yankees win. Yawn.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Pick any combo you want, unless you can remember which division winner is supposed to play the wild card and all of that. I don't, so here's mine...

 

Oakland (AL West) vs. Boston (wild card)

New York (AL East) vs. Chicago (AL Central)

Chicago (NL Central) vs. Atlanta (NL East)

Florida (wild card) vs. San Fran (NL West)

 

Boston vs. New York

Chicago vs. San Fran

 

New York vs. San Fran

 

San Francisco wins the World Series

Exactly the same scenario as mine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Pick any combo you want, unless you can remember which division winner is supposed to play the wild card and all of that. I don't, so here's mine...

 

Oakland (AL West) vs. Boston (wild card)

New York (AL East) vs. Chicago (AL Central)

Chicago (NL Central) vs. Atlanta (NL East)

Florida (wild card) vs. San Fran (NL West)

 

Boston vs. New York

Chicago vs. San Fran

 

New York vs. San Fran

 

San Francisco wins the World Series

Exactly the same scenario as mine.

Yankees and Giants? Oh jesus that's when I might stop watching baseball for good. Fuck em' both.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Pick any combo you want, unless you can remember which division winner is supposed to play the wild card and all of that. I don't, so here's mine...

 

Oakland (AL West) vs. Boston (wild card)

New York (AL East) vs. Chicago (AL Central)

Chicago (NL Central) vs. Atlanta (NL East)

Florida (wild card) vs. San Fran (NL West)

 

Boston vs. New York

Chicago vs. San Fran

 

New York vs. San Fran

 

San Francisco wins the World Series

Exactly the same scenario as mine.

Yankees and Giants? Oh jesus that's when I might stop watching baseball for good. Fuck em' both.

More reason for it to happen. No more "Fuck Bonds" threads.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Pick any combo you want, unless you can remember which division winner is supposed to play the wild card and all of that. I don't, so here's mine...

 

Oakland (AL West) vs. Boston (wild card)

New York (AL East) vs. Chicago (AL Central)

Chicago (NL Central) vs. Atlanta (NL East)

Florida (wild card) vs. San Fran (NL West)

 

Boston vs. New York

Chicago vs. San Fran

 

New York vs. San Fran

 

San Francisco wins the World Series

Exactly the same scenario as mine.

Yankees and Giants? Oh jesus that's when I might stop watching baseball for good. Fuck em' both.

More reason for it to happen. No more "Fuck Bonds" threads.

Actually my reasons for the Giants is their ownership not Bonds but its too involved to get into.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ALDS

Yankees v. Mariners

Royals v. BoSox

 

ALCS

Yankees v. BoSox

 

NLDS

Marlins v. Giants

Braves v. Cubs

 

NLCS

Braves v. Marlins

 

World Series

Marlins v. BoSox

 

World Series Champs: Flip a coin. If heads, Marlins. If tails, Marlins. If it lands on its edge, BoSox.

 

EDIT: Meh, I'm a Mets fan. Since they're long gone, the playoffs might as well be funny.

Edited by DerangedHermit

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Umm...Marlins love much?

 

And if you don't want to see the Yanks vs. Bosox in the ALCS you are either #1 an Oakland fan(Bored) or #2 a Yankee fan, because you are SCARED of Boston :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Umm...Marlins love much?

 

And if you don't want to see the Yanks vs. Bosox in the ALCS you are either #1 an Oakland fan(Bored) or #2 a Yankee fan, because you are SCARED of Boston :)

Now THAT is funny.

 

Of course now with Mulder out for the year and Zito stuck in mediocrity and the lack offense the A's suddenly are a long shot to make it to the postseason.

 

If the A's don't make it I'll root for Red Sox and Cubs...and then Apocalypse will happen with then both make it. :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest undisputedjericho

Division Series

AL: New York over Oakland, Seattle over Chicago

NL: Atlanta over St. Louis, San Francisco over Houston

 

League Championship

AL: New York over Seattle

NL: Atlanta over San Francisco

 

World Series

New York over Atlanta

 

This is who I think will get into the playoffs...from there, it's all up in the air, though obviously I want the Yanks to come out on top.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Anglesault
Umm...Marlins love much?

 

And if you don't want to see the Yanks vs. Bosox in the ALCS you are either #1 an Oakland fan(Bored) or #2 a Yankee fan, because you are SCARED of Boston :)

Sure am afraid of seeing the Yanks with the Bosox in October.

 

Beacuse I don't even think the Sox are making it this year. It's late Summer, and the annual BoSox nosedive hasn't even taken full effect yet

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Gatornibs

Yankees vs Red Sox

Seattle vs KC

Atlanta vs Chicago

San Fran vs Florida

 

Yankees/Seattle

Atlanta/San Fran

 

Atlanta/Seattle

 

Seattle

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×