AMERICAN IDOl-SEASON 5: THE THREAD

[Xavier Cromartie 0]

I want to have sexual intercourse with Brenna.

[ZGangsta 0]

Ok, Lisa (the 16 year old) was fucking amazing, and Katherine was almost as good and really hot. And dear God does that Brenna chick have an amazing rack or what? I agree that she needs to start doing really slutty songs if she's going to make it. There's no way she wins though since they always go with the 'humble innocent' type (except Fantasia was 19 with a kid so you know she gives it up *shudder*) so Katherine has the best shot.

 

And yes Hawk, I actually did have a blond girl named Heather Cox in my high school.

 

As for the guys, I want to vote for the grey haired dude, but then there's Ace Young. And anyone with a name as wicked as Ace Young has to have my vote.

[Hawk 34 0]

Tonight, it's the men's turn...

 

Let's just hope it's not a replay of last night

 

ACE

Age: 25

 

Bobby

Age: 19

 

Bucky

Age: 28

 

Chris

Age: 26

 

David

Age: 17

 

Elliott

Age: 27

 

Gedeon

Age: 17

 

Jose

Age: 28

 

Kevin

Age: 16

 

Patrick

Age: 27

 

Taylor

Age: 29

 

Will

Age: 16

 

So we got a couple pre-teen looking kids, a guy who looks old enough to be those kids father, an obvious top 5 in Ace Young. Simon and Randy have been wanting a boy to win this time around after girls going 3 for 4. I think the winner probably comes out of this group.

 

The girls only have 3 names who were good enough to be considered top 5 worthy. After tonight, that list probably drops down to 2.

[Mik 0]

KEVIN!

[Hawk 34 0]

KEVIN!

 

Kinda looks like Bob Barron...and he's from NY too. Creepy.

[starvenger 0]

except Fantasia was 19 with a kid so you know she gives it up *shudder*

She probably did it listening to KCi and JoJo (her cousins) too. How's that for disturbing?

[Black Lushus 0]

KEVIN!

 

Kinda looks like Bob Barron...and he's from NY too. Creepy.

 

Will actually looks more like Barron minus the glasses and zits.

[starvenger 0]

After going through the performances again I'm changing my elimination picks from Stevie/Melissa to Stevie/Heather.

 

And is Jose Hispanic or Filipino?

[Black Lushus 0]

After going through the performances again I'm changing my elimination picks from Stevie/Melissa to Stevie/Heather.

 

And is Jose Hispanic or Filipino?

 

I want to say Filipino, his mother looked pretty damn Southeast Asian to me. (I lived in the Phillipines for over 3 years)

[Jericholic82 0]

That girl who is a twin is HOT!

yknow she lives in the same area which I just moved to (plus tBrenna as well, actually much closer) I'll tell her you like her if I ever see her lol

 

seriously, last night's show was pretty mediocre. I guess it was "first week jitters" or something but a lot of it seemed off. bad song choices to boot. The 16 year old Lisa and the last one of the night were best IMO.

 

sorry I am areayd forgetting names.

 

Simon seemed more nice than usual.

 

 

Hope the guys are better ( I agree that they seem to be pushing for a guy to win this year as only one guy has won in 4 seasons.)

[Jericholic82 0]

I want to have sexual intercourse with Brenna.

that was direct.

 

 

Quote of the thread so far.

 

 

Don't you love how the thread has already turned into a discussion of which girl singer is the hottest?

 

Makes you realize the ratio of male to female members here at TSM

[starvenger 0]

And is Jose Hispanic or Filipino?

 

I want to say Filipino, his mother looked pretty damn Southeast Asian to me. (I lived in the Phillipines for over 3 years)

I didn't see his mother, but you do have a point - Jose has the nose.

[starvenger 0]

Don't you love how the thread has already turned into a discussion of which girl singer is the hottest?

 

Makes you realize the ratio of male to female members here at TSM

I believe it's a requirement for reality show threads here.

[Hawk 34 0]

Don't you love how the thread has already turned into a discussion of which girl singer is the hottest?

 

Makes you realize the ratio of male to female members here at TSM

I believe it's a requirement for reality show threads here.

 

There is a discussion about who is the hottest? Katherine, easily. Who are we wanting to fuck? Brenna, hands down.

 

At least with AI; it has a purpose. You can't deny that looks are a big issue with AI. If you look like a star, viewers and voters will initially respond to you better.

 

 

Girls especially do this with the male performers. It's no different.

[Black Lushus 0]

 

 

Girls especially do this with the male performers. It's no different.

 

indeed...not to ruffle anyone's feathers, but Constantine got by as far as he did on looks, not singing.

[starvenger 0]

At least with AI; it has a purpose. You can't deny that looks are a big issue with AI. If you look like a star, viewers and voters will initially respond to you better.

 

indeed...not to ruffle anyone's feathers, but Constantine got by as far as he did on looks, not singing.

 

Both true. Although I find it funny that he got kicked off the week he sang a Nickelback song badly. I didn't think that was possible. Singing Nickelback badly that is.

[Hawk 34 0]

That's something i wanted to touch on, I hope they change things up as far as musical selection goes.

 

I'd like see them force them into different genres. Kelly did well after AI, by adding a rock-edge to voice. Have the girls perform with real band and see if they can be diverse from rock-ish songs and pop ballads.

[starvenger 0]

Well, there's the matter of knowing what direction you want to take. I think Kelly and her management team had a good idea of what to do, and adjusted accordingly.

[Black Lushus 0]

I'd like to see the producers play to each performers strengths...a fantastic rock sounding guy is going to get hammered when they do show tunes...a country-ish chick will get killed when they do Today's Top 40 Pop Hits...an R&B singer is going to die when they do country...it's not like each winner has gone on to POP stardom, Kelly the exception. Instead of doing genres, I really wish they'd let them sing anything available in whatever catalog they use.

[RavishingRickRudo 0]

Jose is Filipino, sez so in his video interview on the site.

 

This has to be the oddest male group yet in terms of freaks and geeks.

[The Niggardly King 0]

Bobby, Gideon, and Jose are taking this damn thing tonight.

[RavishingRickRudo 0]

Hicks, Patrick, and Jose, fuckaz.

[Black Lushus 0]

I'm fully confident Taylor Hicks will blow the joint away...and America will hate him because he acts Special Olympics-ish and has gray hair.

[RavishingRickRudo 0]

I disagree. Americans will vote for him to make themselves feel better about not being superficial and judging primarily on talent. This will take him far, but not to the finals.

[Xavier Cromartie 0]

I like Will because he looks like a young Fred Savage.

[Hawk 34 0]

I like Will because he looks like a young Fred Savage.

 

I'm glad im not the only one thinking this.

[Hawk 34 0]

It's time for NIGHT TWO.

 

Let's hope the men have something to give us, because if night one was any indication...it's going to be a rough season otherwise.

 

They are pushing Lisa, Paris and Katherine so far. Katherine, ...wow. I'm still all bout her right now.

[Black Lushus 0]

ah man, Taylor's in full SpEd mode already.

[Hawk 34 0]

ah man, Taylor's in full SpEd mode already.

 

I missed his audition episode, is there something behind this or is he just "acting"...

[Black Lushus 0]

ah man, Taylor's in full SpEd mode already.

 

I missed his audition episode, is there something behind this or is he just "acting"...

 

nah, I think he just gets overly excited sometimes...he may have some sort of OCD going on, not sure.