baseball-reference.com updated their comparison lists. Here's Miguel Cabrera's...
Similar Batters through Age 23
Compare Stats
1. Hank Aaron (959) *
2. Orlando Cepeda (931) *
3. Frank Robinson (925) *
4. Joe Medwick (920) *
5. Mickey Mantle (914) *
6. Andruw Jones (907)
7. Ken Griffey (906)
8. Hal Trosky (905)
9. Vladimir Guerrero (900)
10. Al Kaline (900) *
Yep.
By the way, ESPN is ALL OVER the A-Rod to the Marlins rumor. I'd be thrilled, even if it took Dontrelle and my future favorite pitcher Chris Volstad to get it done (and probably another one like Ricky Nolasco). A-Rod is from Miami, he would actually sell tickets and the offense next year would be insane. I still don't really think it's realistic, but it's what the media is pushing right now so I can't pretend it doesn't exist.