American Idol Season 4

[MooreMark 0]

Ok, I don't find Mikalah good or good looking at all anymore. She was hideious in every way tonight.

 

I hope that her or Constantine go. I liked Nadia the most even though the judges didn't. Juggs and Carrie were pretty good. Most of the contestants were on tonight.

[Jericholic82 0]

Ok Maybe I shouldnt have said jess was a "frontrunner" but what I meant was she and carrie did seem to be the best of the night (well at least according to simon)

 

as a whole everyone was better this week.

[starvenger 0]

Well, the Housemartins have nothing to worry about - they've still done the best cover of He Ain't Heavy, He's My Brother...

[Mik 0]

Finally - she's gone.

[Jericholic82 0]

Actually I thought Mikalya sounded better this week, if they were goign to get rid of the weakest performance IMO they shoudl have gone with either constantine or anwar . Actually I wish it was const cuz he is starting to grate on my nerves. Mik had a different voice, I wouldnt call her a bad singer persay, but she had a different, maybe stylized voice. Thus she wasnt that versatile. Plus her attitude probably didnt go well with the audience. Personally I liekd her NY style tude, but then again im biased.

 

Im starting to really think the mistake on Tues was a ratings ploy.

 

Please let nikko (ok he sounded pretty good this week, but he still is too generic IMO) or const. go next week.

[Exslade ZX 0]

Im starting to really think the mistake on Tues was a ratings ploy.

Thinking about it..it probaly was. They knew they were cancelling Point Pleasant this/next week, so I guess they had to find a way to do it.

[Lightning Flik 0]

Constantine probably was a frontrunner with the votes this past week. Why? Because he sang a David Cassidy song and considering I know a few David Cassidy fans (including my mom) and they told me that he nailed that song perfectly and if they'd vote for him they would (we be Canadians, eh), I'm guessing he just bought himself a few weeks of being on the show, as now all those David Cassidy fans probably just went "We have to vote for him!"

 

Honestly, I'll agree with whoever said Bo should already be making the album. Why is this competition still going? He's the clear cut winner in my mind.

[Jericholic82 0]

Constantine probably was a frontrunner with the votes this past week. Why? Because he sang a David Cassidy song and considering I know a few David Cassidy fans (including my mom) and they told me that he nailed that song perfectly and if they'd vote for him they would (we be Canadians, eh), I'm guessing he just bought himself a few weeks of being on the show, as now all those David Cassidy fans probably just went "We have to vote for him!"

 

Honestly, I'll agree with whoever said Bo should already be making the album. Why is this competition still going? He's the clear cut winner in my mind.

Good point. But every year on Idol you have to have the token pretty boy who the girls love. Fortunately none of them has ever won the show and I dont think will this year. Actually I would like Bo to win, just to have something really different for this time.

[CanadianChick 0]

It's been two good weeks of eliminations. The two worst (by quite a big margin too) are gone. Excellent.

 

Bo's performance was pretty outstanding, I must say. I'm rooting for him.

[Damaramu 0]

I hate Nadia. I hope she goes next week. Her, Vonzell, or Scott.

 

Bo is my man and if he doesn't win it then it doesn't really matter b/c I know Simon will be waiting backstage for him with a fat record contract in hand. Hell Bo, Jessica, Carrie, and Constantine are all gettign something out of this.

I know nobody here likes Constantine but I think he's awesome plus they keep complimenting his showmanship and I know they think he can sell records.

[Jericholic82 0]

It's been two good weeks of eliminations. The two worst (by quite a big margin too) are gone. Excellent.

 

Bo's performance was pretty outstanding, I must say. I'm rooting for him.

I disagree, I felt that Anwar was the weakest (of course constan, but he wasnt weak, just cheesy) But I still want to see anwar stick around so no biggee.

 

As for more conspiracy theories, isnt it convenient that Nadia was int he bottom three, just one night after mentioning Marios name on tv (and from the looks of it, visibly pissing off simon) I'm not saying they are tinkering with the votes, but.. I dont know so whatever,

 

 

It would appear that they are trying hard to pimp Nikko, so people forget hes a scrub, who only is there due to someone quitting.

[Exslade ZX 0]

It would appear that they are trying hard to pimp Nikko, so people forget hes a scrub, who only is there due to someone quitting.

Wha..? They haven't said anything good about him much. First performance, they all pretty much said he did bad..saying the nerves must have got to him. Second performance, yea, they complimented him (well, Randy and Paula did, while Simon did his sort of...on the fence thing) but did you not hear the guy? Like Simon said, barring a few missed notes or so, he rocked that song.

 

And he shouldn't have had to be there because somebody quit anyways. It was clear he should have been in the top 12 anyways. His 'Georgia' on the final night was better then a lot of the stuff that Federov did (I mean..who voted for this kid?) or some of the stuff Scott did, or Constantine for that matter, he was clearly in the better half of the guys.

[Damaramu 0]

Yeah but America obviously doesn't like Nikko and Simon seems to be gunning for him.

 

Now Paula needs to quit her god damn bias. She's always standing up and going nuts for certain people and then gushing over them for no reason. Like Mikahla or whatever her name was.

Plus she needs to shut the hell up when Simon is talking and let him speak his opinion.

[Jericholic82 0]

Good points. I just dislike him becuase I dont see anything special about him, hes a decent singer, but some of his performances have been horrid(like his bad Michael Jackson impressionfrom a few weeks back) , and hes just too much of a bland generic r and b singer to be this far in this competiton IMO. But I see why so many of you apprantly like him. I just have no use for this Steve Urkel Lookalike if I am being honset. Then again I guess I have less respect for him due to him being a replacement contestant. But it's not his fault. However if he comes out next week and does some cartwheels and attempts to turn a double play, I might get a kick out of it

 

And I like I said I dont want to make up conspiracy theories, but I would pay close attention to the next weeks.

 

Remember this show is not about music, its about tv ratings and corporate greed.

[MooreMark 0]

Yeah but America obviously doesn't like Nikko and Simon seems to be gunning for him.

 

Now Paula needs to quit her god damn bias. She's always standing up and going nuts for certain people and then gushing over them for no reason. Like Mikahla or whatever her name was.

Plus she needs to shut the hell up when Simon is talking and let him speak his opinion.

Well, Paula hated on Mikalah like a huge bitch. She's always giving deathstares.

 

I felt bad for Mikalah leaving and Nadia being in the bottom when shit like Constaloo are getting by.

 

Mikalah did suck lastnight though so overall I don't mind.

 

Next week has to be either Scott/Constantine/Anthony with me HOPING that Constaloo gets the boot.

[MooreMark 0]

It's been two good weeks of eliminations. The two worst (by quite a big margin too) are gone. Excellent.

 

Bo's performance was pretty outstanding, I must say. I'm rooting for him.

I disagree, I felt that Anwar was the weakest (of course constan, but he wasnt weak, just cheesy) But I still want to see anwar stick around so no biggee.

 

As for more conspiracy theories, isnt it convenient that Nadia was int he bottom three, just one night after mentioning Marios name on tv (and from the looks of it, visibly pissing off simon) I'm not saying they are tinkering with the votes, but.. I dont know so whatever,

 

 

It would appear that they are trying hard to pimp Nikko, so people forget hes a scrub, who only is there due to someone quitting.

Anwar was bad lastweek aswell. He was a little over the top campy with this week's performance. He even sucked coming into the group performance. Anwar needs to step it up badly.

 

Constantine has been consisently bad and still has yet to give a performance worthy of being in the top 12. He NEEDS to go.

[Lightning Flik 0]

I know nobody here likes Constantine but I think he's awesome plus they keep complimenting his showmanship and I know they think he can sell records.

Actually I thought Constantine was fucking brave to pull that song out and not fuck it up. He's not afraid to pull out the stops and frankly you are right, he can sell records with his showmanship.

 

But to win American Idol, probably not. Not if Bo keeps singing like he is. And how the fuck did Mikalah make it this far?

[nogoodnick 0]

Which one is Bo? Ive only seen the last 2 episodes. It looks like they've got a real solid group this year.

[Guest Shadow]

Bo is the long-haired one who performed "Time in a Bottle" this weekend.

[MooreMark 0]

I know nobody here likes Constantine but I think he's awesome plus they keep complimenting his showmanship and I know they think he can sell records.

Actually I thought Constantine was fucking brave to pull that song out and not fuck it up. He's not afraid to pull out the stops and frankly you are right, he can sell records with his showmanship.

 

But to win American Idol, probably not. Not if Bo keeps singing like he is. And how the fuck did Mikalah make it this far?

"God Bless The Child" that was more than enough to give her a spot in the 12. After that it went from decent (somewhere), bad (son of a preacher man) and horrible (love will lead you back).

[Jericholic82 0]

well its not like Im goign to shed a tear or anything. A young aspring singer cant buy that type of publicity.

[MooreMark 0]

The theme is 90s, tonight.

[starvenger 0]

So far, only Nadia's sang well. Must be because she's back to the Scary Spice fro...

[Guest Shadow]

i just turned in. what have they performed?

[starvenger 0]

Bo - Remedy, The Black Crowes. 6.5

Juggs - Um, don't remember

Anwar - I Believe I Can Fly, R. Kelly. 5

Nadia - I'm The Only One, Melissa Etheridge. 8.5

Constancrap - Don't know. 5

[Your Paragon of Virtue 0]

Constantine wasn't that bad, I agree with Simon in that he was better than Bo. I like how they purposely compare the two rockers too.

[starvenger 0]

So, is Nikko's dad Lonnie or Ozzie?

[Mik 0]

Ozzie.

 

He went all out tonight pulling out Tevin Campbell... bold move.

 

Vonzell "won" this week. When the music started, I was like... not Whitney, but she won me over with the performance.

[MooreMark 0]

Bo - Not very good, not bad.

Juggsica - She was really underwelming. I think she needs a song with big notes to keep her in because she is in direct competition with Carrie.

Anwar - Horrible beginning, overdone song, I just don't know. Anwar went from the top of the world to the bottom of the bunch.

Nadia - Awesome performer, not the best singer. I like her.

Constaloo - I could barely watch this because of his horrible expressions. He is terrible.

Nikko - Best male of the night by far.

Anthony - A couple rough notes, but still better the constaloo. He's probably gone, which I don't care about.

Carrie - She's got one of the best voices but she doesn't connect.

Scott - He really tried but again he did an overdone song. I think he has one week left in him because he isn't very different vocally.

Vonzell - The overdone bitch queen did yet another overdone song. Probably second best after Nadia or Carrie.

[Jericholic82 0]

They did ok tonight. Nothing too horrid. some better song choices by the lot, but yet some bad ones as well. They need to not have such a wide selection as "the 90s" or whatever. or someone needs to help them choose a good song for thier voice. Const sounded better tonight but his facials are still annoying. it seems like he is not the rock guy he portrays.

 

Wonder wholl get cut?