AMERICAN IDOl-SEASON 5: THE THREAD

[Black Lushus 0]

thank god Taylor moves on...that dude is great, fellas.

[naiwf 0]

Either the two white boys are tall or Sway's a fucking midget.

 

Crooner boy's dead, so America's still doing well. My money is on Sway being saved by the Filipino community.

[starvenger 0]

Either the two white boys are tall or Sway's a fucking midget.

Sway's just short.

[naiwf 0]

I'm happy with the 8 cuts so far, I can't remember the last time that was the case on AI. They do need to cut Kinnik and the two Savage brothers next week though (Kevin & Will).

[Black Lushus 0]

I actually prefer Kevin to Bucky, myself.

[UZI Suicide 0]

So, what drugs were Paula Abdul on tonight? She seemed a little wasted.

[Mik 0]

I was pretty worried that Kevin wasn't going to make it, but thankfully America was using their brain last night and kept him in the competition.

[Guest Rrrsh]

So what guys got cut?

[starvenger 0]

So, what drugs were Paula Abdul on tonight? She seemed a little wasted.

Dunno, but the fact that she told Elliott that "Stevie Wonder would be proud" this week when he sang a Stevie song LAST week was pretty funny.

 

Speaking of which, there should be a rule where no Idol is allowed to sing a Stevie Wonder song, EVER.

 

So what guys got cut?

Sway (the Filipino guy) and David (the crooner). Not entirely unexpected - most figured they would go before the Top 12, the question was when it would happen.

 

But what interests me about the guys is Bucky - he has no business still being in this competition. Is he drawing in the Kellie Pickler voters or something?

[Xavier Cromartie 0]

Noooooooo!!!

 

So anyway Mandisa is quite the blob.

[Guest Rrrsh]

Both Kevin and Bucky NEED to go before teh Top 12

[4hartthreat 0]

Both Kevin and Bucky NEED to go before teh Top 12

 

 

I agree 100%. Those two should be the next guys to go. And I guess I am the only one here who really likes Will. I liked him going into the top 24 even though they showed very little of him, and I like him even more after this week. I thought he did great with "Lady."

[starvenger 0]

As far as I'm concerned Will, Kevin and Gedeon are fighting for the final two spots. Chris could drop a deuce on Idol and go through, Ace is pretty, Elliott is frustratingly inconsistent but sounds like Adam Sandler, and Taylor gets the underdog vote (and is good, to boot).

 

On the women's side Kinnick is a dead woman singing but I'm having trouble figuring out who the second woman should be. If we were rating based on singing ability Kellie would be gone but like Ace she's getting a push so she goes nowhere, so it's probably gonna be Melissa or Kyla. I'm leaning towards Melissa at this point.

[C Dubya 04 0]

I like Bucky personally, but really, I have a soft spot for anyone who sings Skynard.

 

I would have booted Bob Barron before Sway, but whatever, neither one deserved to go too far.

 

If Brenna had stayed, I don't think I could have watched anymore. She makes me want to get violent. I think she also has a rude awakening coming her way. Plus, clearly she's only in it for the money. Her best shot in life is to be a golddigger.

[Black Lushus 0]

If Brenna had stayed, I don't think I could have watched anymore. She makes me want to get violent. I think she also has a rude awakening coming her way. Plus, clearly she's only in it for the money. Her best shot in life is to be a golddigger.

 

I think she could probably accomplish that goal quite easily.

[starvenger 0]

If Brenna had stayed, I don't think I could have watched anymore. She makes me want to get violent. I think she also has a rude awakening coming her way. Plus, clearly she's only in it for the money. Her best shot in life is to be a golddigger.

Thanks a lot. Now I can't get that frakking song out of my head.

[Guest Princess Leena]

I watched until Carrie sang some song. It still amazes me how she won. AI really likes to drag things out, don't they.

[Black Lushus 0]

yeah, Carrie was always just average to me, but America sure does love them some country chicks.

[starvenger 0]

I believe it's sweeps season, so... yeah. As for Carrie... well, I call her Carrie Underwhelm for a reason. Is she even getting a push on regular radio? Because I literally haven't listened to regular radio at all since I got Sirius last July as a wedding present, and I have heard no Carrie at all...

[C Dubya 04 0]

Carrie was okay on the show (I like Bo a lot better) but this song of her's is terrible. I can't believe that it's popular.

[starvenger 0]

Carrie was okay on the show (I like Bo a lot better) but this song of her's is terrible. I can't believe that it's popular.

It's a combination of payola and the fact that 2 companies control something like 95% of radio stations in the US...

[Guest The Satanic Angel]

Carrie should have gone on Nashville Star. She's not pop, she's country.

[Guest Princess Leena]

She probably should have. Country has a zillion blonde girls who look just like her. That's the only reason I'm surprised she won... she's got a good voice, but go to any college, and there's 100 girls who look just like her. And probably have no personality and talk like a dumbo, just like her.

 

And, wow, that Katharine really is pretty. People usually overrate the looks of most of these AI people... but, she's something. She has to lose, so she can get in a different career than singing.

[Black Lushus 0]

I couldn't even hum Carrie's song...how does it go? something like jesus don't need seat belts because he's muthafuckin jesus or some shit?

[Black Lushus 0]

And, wow, that Katharine really is pretty. People usually overrate the looks of most of these AI people... but, she's something. She has to lose, so she can get in a different career than singing.

 

softcore porn, alongside you?

[C Dubya 04 0]

I couldn't even hum Carrie's song...how does it go? something like jesus don't need seat belts because he's muthafuckin jesus or some shit?

 

JESUS TAKE THE WHEELLLLLLLLLL, I Can't drive tonighghghghghttttttttttt.

[Black Lushus 0]

hahahaha shit man, I was way off! I knew it had something to do with Jesus and cars!

[Guest Princess Leena]

 

And, wow, that Katharine really is pretty. People usually overrate the looks of most of these AI people... but, she's something. She has to lose, so she can get in a different career than singing.

 

softcore porn, alongside you?

 

If she was alongside me, it wouldn't be softcore.

[Black Lushus 0]

 

And, wow, that Katharine really is pretty. People usually overrate the looks of most of these AI people... but, she's something. She has to lose, so she can get in a different career than singing.

 

softcore porn, alongside you?

 

If she was alongside me, it wouldn't be softcore.

 

PICZ PLZ KTHX

[Ravenbomb 0]

hahahaha shit man, I was way off! I knew it had something to do with Jesus and cars!

 

Why, yes, I DO love Jesus and Cars!