I think a lot of people watching this show, though making valid points, are looking back and saying "wow that sucked that Jericho/Benoit only went 4 minutes" and how the idea that Nitro had better wrestling was a myth without realizing this is taking place a decade ago.
Yeah, a 4 minute Jericho/Benoit match is the sort of thing happening on Impact that we complain about now, but that match totally blew away every match on Raw the same week in terms of the work that was presented in that small amount of time. Flash Funk vs HHH was dreadfully dull and it lasted what seemed like 13 minutes.
For me, these shows are pure television nostalgia and should, for the most part, be treated as such. What is the statute of limitations on reviewing a show as "nostalgic fun" or a serious review? I know people hate hearing his name, but Scott Keith is giving decade old MNWs a 'serious' review with star ratings and as a result seems constantly down on them, but is giving 2 decade old NWA shows that seem to have an endless parade of squash matches a free pass.